Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Soxtalk.com

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Y2Jimmy0

FutureSox Writer
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Y2Jimmy0

  1. The same pitching can be found in rounds 11-20 in most cases and those players usually get paid more than guys in 7-10. Nobody is reaching. High School players cost money though and the money has to come from somewhere. Especially if you spend slot value in the first round. Look at last year specifically, slot for Carlson at 1 and they went significantly overslot in rounds 2, 4 and 5. Saved money in 6-10. They went over for Boughton in the 11th and drafted pitchers like Max Banks who are similar to anyone they would've gotten in 6-10 anyway. It's all about how many players you can land with your pool space and the looking at the totality of the draft class.
  2. Tim Elko was one of those punted picks. It's just the wrong way to look at the draft. I always put the players in order by signing bonus. Many players taken in rounds 11-20 are more highly regarded than guys in 7-10. If you want a player that is signing for $50K, it makes sense to do it rounds 7-10 and re-allocate that bonus pool space. Everyone in rounds 11-20 can get $150K without penalty. It's just important to understand how the draft and bonus pools work. Roch Cholowsky has an incredibly high ceiling too. Perennial All Star SS with plus defense is his ceiling. The reason why the floor argument comes into play is that he's a definite big leaguer but I also believe that he's the most likely guy to reach his high ceiling. Jacob Lombard has a higher ceiling. He also has a way more difficult path to actually reaching that immense ceiling. Taking Roch Cholowsky is a no brainer for me.
  3. Easy decision for me. I could be talked into Emerson for a discount but I think he'll cost around the same as Cholowsky.
  4. 2025 Golden Spikes Season: .353/.480/.710, 23 homers, 14% walk rate, 9% strikeout rate. 2026: In 12 less games, .330/.475/.684, 21 homers, 13% walk rate, 13% strikeout rate, 34K/34BB/23HBP. Chase rates improved, exit velocities stayed same basically. Higher strikeout rate, slightly worse walk rate while being avoided for a good majority of the season. The difference is miniscule and it's all such a small sample.
  5. Roch Cholowsky has essentially had the same season as last year when he won Golden Spikes. Where is that article from, Caulfield? I was pretty certain that the White Sox were going to take Griffin and I'd been in contact with the Griffin pre-draft. It would be interesting to find out that he didn't want to play for White Sox.
  6. Berroa was throwing in Arizona for months. The next part of the rehab was pitching in games. What should they have done instead? Austin Hays is always injured. It's why he was so cheap. I'm guessing he'll be injured again too.
  7. Y2Jimmy0 replied to BamaDoc's topic in FutureSox Board
    oh yeah my bad. 2025 was fine.
  8. Y2Jimmy0 replied to BamaDoc's topic in FutureSox Board
    Heard them heavily linked to Konnor Griffin all spring. He would've been a discount. Scouts had questions about the swing (Ryan Fuller not in org yet), analytics dept didn't like Cags and medical team flagged Wetherholt. Getz made decision to take Hagen Smith. Looks like a mistake.
  9. Y2Jimmy0 replied to BamaDoc's topic in FutureSox Board
    I think the amateur scouting is really good. Drafting strategy in 2025 was definitely questionable though. Yesavage wasn't in same tier as Hagen as a prospect. Hagen looked like a quick moving college arm.
  10. The only picks that can be traded are: 30. Royals, 31. DBacks, 32. Cardinals, 34. Pirates, 37. Rockies, 69. Tigers, 70. Reds, 71. Marlins, 73. A's and 74 Twins. Quero is super young with options. DFA talk is nuts.
  11. It's not a floor pick. This is what I've said though: How high does someone else's ceiling have to be to pass on the floor that Roch provides? Cholowsky could be a perennial All Star SS with plus defense and power and he could be in the majors by midseason 2027. Him being to the majors quickly and the defense is the floor. Emerson hits left-handed and probably has the better hit tool. He's not quite Bobby Witt Jr but pretty awesome for a prep guy. Could have a higher ceiling than Cholowsky. Also less likely to reach it but pretty safe bet for a star high school guy. Jacob Lombard has the highest ceiling of them all. 70 power and speed with plus defense at shortstop. He could be Manny Machado. But he might not get out of AA. I hope this helps.
  12. 100% coming. They do like Lombard. I'd be really surprised by that pick though because he won't be that cheap.
  13. Yeah it just doesn't matter all that much. Whoever the Sox decide to take won't be turning down what they offer. And they likely don't seriously start talking money until like 24-48 hours before the draft.
  14. Batting average is worse on Fridays for sure. .900 OPS still though. How is Grady Emerson doing on Fridays playing against teenagers from tiny catholic schools in Texas? I guess I'm struggling to measure the importance of these small sample size stats. Nobody ever mentions Vahn Lackey's sophomore season.
  15. You should tweet these numbers so I can retweet them without stealing it haha
  16. I never thought Colson was a bad shortstop. I always thought he could stay there. People who thought otherwise didn't watch. Bonemer might legit be 1B or LF though.
  17. Cholowsky is the best college shortstop in like 20 years. These guys usually go pro out of high school. There are some recent college guys who look pretty good though. Kurtz and Wetherholt both very good and Roch is a plus defender at shortstop. Cholowsky's numbers are basically the same as last year. K rate up a tad, walk rate down a tad. Power is similar, chase rate is better, exit velo similar etc. And teams don't really pitch to him that often. I'm actually more impressed with his junior year than sophomore year.
  18. I remember when the author was basically banned from baseball for cheating in the international market with the Braves. The Sox aren't trading Murakami.
  19. I don't think anyone. Bonemer is an exciting prospect but there are real defensive concerns right now and he's striking out 30% of the time in High-A. Cholowsky is an immediate top 10 prospect in baseball with potentially gold glove level defense at shortstop.
  20. Y2Jimmy0 replied to BamaDoc's topic in FutureSox Board
    Albertus played on Saturday in the ACL.
  21. Roch isn't a great runner and we wasn't great with wood in Cape Cod and Team USA. Those are literally the only blemishes though. Joe is the best. I always enjoy doing his show. I keep coming back to the same thing with Cholowsky. I just don't think the Sox can pass on him and Emerson won't be much cheaper anyway.
  22. They should move Anthony Kay to the bullpen and have Hagen Smith start in the majors.
  23. Y2Jimmy0 replied to BamaDoc's topic in FutureSox Board
    Thanks Ron. I think he plays in the majors for sure. I'd rather see him than Tanner Murray for example. I'm not sure he ever becomes a regular though.
  24. White Sox 5 Round Mock for FutureSox: https://www.futuresox.net/2026/04/18/chicago-white-sox-2026-5-round-mock-d/

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.