What do you WANT to happen, and what WILL happen?

 

Can I bump this thread in September after I see how this year's selling and replacing has gone?

Can I bump this thread in September after I see how this year's selling and replacing has gone?

Sure.

 

I voted for wanting Ozzie out at the end of the season, and that nothing will change at the end of the season.

 

And I'm basing the last thing on JR's loyalty to "his guys", and I think Ozzie and KW are definitely that.

 

I think Ozzie would be best served by taking the Florida Marlins job from 2011 and using his managerial style in the NL.

 

KW I think has enough runs on the board to survive say a 90 loss season, but changes will have to be made somewhere, but I don't think that'll be for the manager and the GM.

 

The Peavy trade is obviously blowing up in KW's face right now unless he can turn it around, the Pierre acquisition giving up 2 decent prospects, 1 who has been great in the Dodgers rotation and not waiting for Damon was one of KW's worst moves since I've been a Sox fan, albeit Pierre has been better lately.

 

The DH situation obviously has been a big negative, although Jones has been one of our better hitters. I think also when a lot of people say we need to add more OBP to the lineup, to be good in that stat in our ballpark is pretty hard, as Dye said in the media a while back, you need to have decent power to succeed hitting at the Cell.

The main reason I'm holding out on criticism of these guys is that 2-3 months ago, I said our reasons for success this season went as follows:

 

1. Carlos Quentin

2. Carlos Quentin

3. Carlos Quentin

4. Carlos Quentin

5. Carlos Quentin

6. Alex Rios

7. Carlos Quentin

8. Gordon Beckham

 

Out of about my top 10 reasons for offensive success this season, 8 or so have been bad. Now, if we were counting on something insane, like Mark Kotsay being the key to the offense, that'd be one thing, but frankly, a lot of the guys we asked to be workable pieces have actually been workable pieces so far.

 

It's been the guys that no one in their right mind wanted to dump for nothing prior to the season failing that has really murdered us this year. Now, if you're going to blame KW for not dumping Beckham and Quentin in the offseason and replacing them with, I dunno, Jermaine Dye and Placido Polonco, well, I'd love to see where anyone thought that was a good idea.

Well, Gordo appears to be breaking out of it, so now we just need Carlos to remember he's awesome.

I'm undecided. I want to see how this season plays out. I will say that the clock should at least be ticking on both guys (Ozzie considerably more than Kenny). Since the second half of 2006, this team is 293-315. That's simply not getting it done. And it starts at the very top. I would also like to say that I'd like to see a more sabermetric way of thinking when it comes to running an organization. I don't see that ever happening with Ozzie as manager. Like it or not, the game is changing rapidly (and the evolution of sabermetrics is a big part of that). And the Sox are running in quicksand while other teams are blowing right by them.

Well, Gordo appears to be breaking out of it

Really? He's put up a .511 OPS his last 7 days.

Really? He's put up a .511 OPS his last 7 days.

 

I was thinking the same thing. He has 1 multi-hit game in his last 10.

I voted for wanting Ozzie out at the end of the season, and that nothing will change at the end of the season.

ditto

 

Unless this team falls into a death spiral, no one is going anywhere. Even if that happens, Ozzie is the only one on the hot seat IMO.

Unless this team falls into a death spiral, no one is going anywhere. Even if that happens, Ozzie is the only one on the hot seat IMO.

How do you define a "Death spiral"?

Unless this team falls into a death spiral, no one is going anywhere. Even if that happens, Ozzie is the only one on the hot seat IMO.

 

Do we have to morph into the '03 Tigers before changes are made? Unless there's a big turnaround, we're looking at 4 below .500 seasons in the last 5. Unacceptable.

 

Make that 3 below .500 seasons in the last 4.

Edited May 28, 201015 yr by Jordan4life

I voted for wanting Ozzie out at the end of the season, and that nothing will change at the end of the season.

 

Agreed completely. I voted KW on the second one though, only cause KW said himself that he would take any kind of blame and either re-sign or possibly move somewhere else in the position. (moving up wouldn't be a bad idea for him)

Unless this team falls into a death spiral, no one is going anywhere. Even if that happens, Ozzie is the only one on the hot seat IMO.

I feel like they've been barely circling the drain all season and wouldn't be one bit surprised to see the dreaded "death spiral" take effect at some point. This offense is just not very good at all and if the pitching falters the team has no chance.

Looks like my votes are along the same line of the majority here. I think it's time for Ozzie to go, but I imagine nothing will happen. Regardless, this team is probably going to look a lot different in 2011, and I think a new manager would be a wise choice.

Really? He's put up a .511 OPS his last 7 days.

Well if you didnt watch the games then I think thats what you would use to evaluate him. Take last night for example, everything he hit was hard, but came up with one hit. Someone who hasnt been watching would say it wasnt a good game, when in fact he squared up the ball almost every time he made contact. I see him coming out of it this weekend to be honest.

Nothing will change in the management circles. In my opinion Reinsdorf likes both a lot and we may instead see some revamping of the team

Edited May 28, 201015 yr by elrockinMT

Well if you didnt watch the games then I think thats what you would use to evaluate him. Take last night for example, everything he hit was hard, but came up with one hit. Someone who hasnt been watching would say it wasnt a good game, when in fact he squared up the ball almost every time he made contact. I see him coming out of it this weekend to be honest.

 

Like you said, I don't care what his batting average is right now. I'd rather he have a game like last night where he hits everything hard and gets one hit than a game where he gets two infield singles and strikes out the other at bats. The problem is that every time it looks like he's coming out of it, he'll have a 2 game stretch where he strikes out 6 times and looks overmatched.

Like you said, I don't care what his batting average is right now. I'd rather he have a game like last night where he hits everything hard and gets one hit than a game where he gets two infield singles and strikes out the other at bats. The problem is that every time it looks like he's coming out of it, he'll have a 2 game stretch where he strikes out 6 times and looks overmatched.

Exactly. If he was able to consistently hit the ball hard, even for a 5-6 game stretch, the balls would be falling a lot for him.

Like you said, I don't care what his batting average is right now. I'd rather he have a game like last night where he hits everything hard and gets one hit than a game where he gets two infield singles and strikes out the other at bats. The problem is that every time it looks like he's coming out of it, he'll have a 2 game stretch where he strikes out 6 times and looks overmatched.

I think the consistency is on the way -- he really did look better last night against a very good pitcher. With Q though I have yet to see anything. He's fallen and can't get up.

I want KW to stay and i want Ozzie gone. I think KW will get a Paxson-like promotion and Hahn will become the GM, and Ozzie will (sadly) stay.

Unless this team falls into a death spiral, no one is going anywhere. Even if that happens, Ozzie is the only one on the hot seat IMO.

 

 

Completely agree.

Well if you didnt watch the games then I think thats what you would use to evaluate him. Take last night for example, everything he hit was hard, but came up with one hit. Someone who hasnt been watching would say it wasnt a good game, when in fact he squared up the ball almost every time he made contact. I see him coming out of it this weekend to be honest.

 

The last few days it seems like teh ball is coming off of his bat with more authority. I know that is the eye test, but I think you are right about it being soon.

I'm at the point where I want Ozzie gone. That being said, I don't see anything happening. I mean, in 2007 when we lost 92 games we gave him a f***ing extension.