QUOTE (greg775 @ Sep 11, 2009 -> 10:54 PM)
I really don't understand your position.
In my world, Paulie has been a great player and last year didn't deserve the bashing. He came back nicely this year and may in fact finish with 30 HRs.
Same for Dye. His track record I'd think makes it easier to not bash him.
For me, it's much easier to bash a guy like Rios for making out after out after out and not blaming Oz for "not giving him regular playing time." Pleeeeeze. You didn't say that, but somebody did.
I mean if Rios had hit a home run there I'd have applauded his ass. He didn't. He DPed again.
My position?
You asked why people boo Wise and Konerko but not Rios. I gave you reasoning as to why it may be happening.
Paulie and Dye deserve criticism as much as AJ, Pods, Jenks or anyone who is still on this roster from the "magical" 2005 season. At a certain point, guys get older and regress. If a guy needs replacing because he's starting to be less effective, people will boo them or complain about them. That's the perpetual-ness of baseball. The old guys get older, then get replaced by young guys.
If you are going to wear blinders against guys who won in the past but ignore their failings now, then there's always the 2005 WS DVD.