Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Soxtalk.com

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

southsider2k5

Admin

Everything posted by southsider2k5

  1. QUOTE (greg775 @ Oct 10, 2012 -> 09:32 PM) You mean Ozzie? Ozzie doesn't care bout a little message board so I got to fight his battle for him. Oney?
  2. QUOTE (BigSqwert @ Oct 10, 2012 -> 03:27 PM) Unstoppable? I wouldn't consider Noah an offensive threat and Bynum is seemingly always banged up. Plus we'd lose our 2nd most effective scorer. I wouldn't like that scenario at all. It is much easier to find a 3 than a 5 in the NBA>
  3. QUOTE (forrestg @ Oct 10, 2012 -> 01:18 PM) Jake is not a #1,2, but perhaps at the low end of a # 3 starter. I think Jake didn't prove enough to me toward the end of the season to give him any more than the 2 year 22m.. We have paid him premium money for no season that he was worth his keep. I would say 22million - the buyout. I like Jake but he did complete the season although not with great success. You cannot honestly tell me that that you think there were at least 60 better starting pitchers than Jake Peavy this year.
  4. QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Oct 10, 2012 -> 02:57 PM) Seriously, how on earth can you see this chart: and say it supports this: If the chart on the left is "extremely high" for upper income brackets, what the hell were the 1960's? It would be nice if you could quote accurately. The statement was on the differences in rate rates between the different brackets. You know the actual definition of a progressive tax code? Now, ~8% on the low end to 32% on the high end Then ~16% on the low end to ~ 70% on the high end So the ratio of tax rates has gone from about 4.5 times higher on the top brackets to 4 times higher, and this is the big tragedy? The progression of the tax code hasn't moved nearly as much as the extremists want to make it out to be, and you just proved it with a left wing paper. Congrats. Even though the reality is that a 100% tax rate on the richest American's wouldn't cover the deficit, this apparently is what is wrong with this country.
  5. QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Oct 10, 2012 -> 02:55 PM) Nobody in this thread has said that our total tax system isn't at least somewhat progressive. I said that it's not very progressive, because it isn't. Once you get past some logarithmic growth at the very low end, it's relatively flat. Especially compared to the 1960 rates directly next to it! None of your nonsense flailing about total tax share has anything to do with that. You've been attempting to portray the US system as highly or even "extremely" progressive by using proxy measurements that aren't solely a function of tax rate and ignoring everything else. Those charts show that our tax system is marginally progressive at the federal level (and that doesn't yet account for state and local taxes, which are typically regressive!) but also that median income has been damn near flat for decades while the top 5% income has skyrocketed. That chart, coupled with the knowledge that income gaps aren't as severe in the other countries referenced in your original response, completely explain why the top brackets account for a large share of the tax burden even with a barely progressive tax system. Even with the selectiveness of the taxes selected in your article, there is still about a 400% tax rate difference between the lower and upper tax brackets. But apparently that qualifies as "barely progressive". Talk about ignoring everything else.
  6. Rey Olmedo was outrighted to Charlotte.
  7. QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Oct 10, 2012 -> 02:44 PM) If by "extremely high" you mean "unusually and historically low," sure. Have you read or even skimmed the P-S paper, or is that more lib propaganda? The charts you keep posting agree with what I am saying. They go higher as you go up the income brackets.
  8. QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Oct 10, 2012 -> 02:36 PM) So, blinders it is. What is my "class warfare" "intentional distortion" of citing an academic paper by two of the biggest names in income and taxation policy? Why can't you even address the findings of that study or the actual concept of progressiveness of the tax system instead of throwing out a bunch of indirectly related "facts and statistics?" What have I distorted? I've completely accepted that, in the US, the top decile (or whatever top-cutoff you want) pays a large percentage of total taxes. This is because they also collect a large percentage of total income. This is indisputable, yet you have failed to even acknowledge a central component of the data you are presenting. PERCENTAGE SHARE OF TAXES IS A FUNCTION OF BOTH RATE AND INCOME SHARE. It's that simple, and yet you can't seem to see it. Individual percentage rates are also extremely higher for upper income brackets, which is the very definition of progressive. Higher brackets pay higher individual rates, even when excluding things like EITC which would turn most of the lower brackets into negative tax rates.
  9. QUOTE (KyYlE23 @ Oct 10, 2012 -> 02:09 PM) I think the Strasburg Situation officially has mindf***ed the Nationals now. Good job Rizzo. Good job Boras. He could give a s*** less about the Nationals, or any other team in baseball.
  10. QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Oct 10, 2012 -> 02:29 PM) The world where you are actually talking about tax rates, which is what "progressiveness" of the system refers to, because everything you're flinging out to avoid actually addressing the progressiveness of the tax system is a function of multiple inputs, progressiveness being one of them. You know why the poorest 50% pay 1.85% effective income tax rate? Because that's pretty damn close to what their share of the income is and they can't afford to live if they paid any more. That's why I posted the GINI index, which you ignored. That's why multiple people have pointed out, repeatedly, that you're conflating two separate things. Tax share-by-decile is a function of both rates (progressiveness) and income distribution. TSBD=%R*%I. If %I is really, really high, then %R can be relatively low and TSBD will still be high. Either there's some mental block that is preventing you from seeing this (Morton's Demon), or you're being intentionally dishonest. Not accepting your class warfare isn't intentionally dishonest. It is ignoring your intentional distortion of every other fact and statistic out there for reality.
  11. QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Oct 10, 2012 -> 02:22 PM) Well I'm glad you admit how dishonest and silly your first post was. Arbitrarily excluding certain tax categories (in your case, every single tax in the country but one) isn't the way to make a good argument. WHICH IS EXACTLY WHAT YOU ARE DOING>
  12. QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Oct 10, 2012 -> 02:24 PM) but, if you'd bother to read the P-S paper (more lib propaganda?!) or any of the other studies on the total tax system in the US, you'd see that, outside of FIT, the system is damn near flat if not actually regressive depending on the state your reside in. So if you narrow the focus to ignore, by far, the biggest source of taxes in the country, it ends up telling the story you want it to tell. And you have the nerve to call someone intellectually dishonest? Give it a rest.
  13. QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Oct 10, 2012 -> 02:22 PM) Well I'm glad you admit how dishonest and silly your first post was. Arbitrarily excluding certain tax categories (in your case, every single tax in the country but one) isn't the way to make a good argument. I wish for once you could admit how dishonest any of the BS you post is.
  14. QUOTE (CrimsonWeltall @ Oct 10, 2012 -> 02:23 PM) Who said that? I was just showing you that a system where rich people pay a huge percentage of the taxes isn't necessarily progressive at all, much less strongly progressive. By making up a scenario that doesn't exist in reality. Great. That is superhelpful
  15. QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Oct 10, 2012 -> 02:18 PM) Zing! But do you get why paying a higher share of total taxes says nothing directly about how progressive the system is? The rich pay higher total shares, higher individual shares, higher percentages of income, and pretty much any other statistic you want to throw out there. As of 2009, the poorest 50% pay 1.85% effective income tax rate. The top 10% pay over 10 times that percentage of their income in taxes. In what world is having over a 1000% higher rate of income taxes paid not progressive?
  16. QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Oct 10, 2012 -> 02:17 PM) lol I just had someone explain to me that apparently people don't pay taxes because they have zero income.
  17. QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Oct 10, 2012 -> 02:15 PM) You are trying to make a slight-of-hand with the terms and, of course, with the "nothing at all" claim. "Percentage of taxes paid" and "tax rates" are not the same thing. Percentage of taxes paid is a function of both tax rates and income distribution. The P-S paper is talking about total tax progressivity. The article you quoted is talking about total taxes collected. Yet you still intentionally and knowingly used the misleading "47% don't pay any taxes! (of one very specific type of tax, to the exclusion of all other taxes)" line. Of course things won't make sense when you're being intentionally dishonest. Of course this thread would have about five posts in it if that weren't the case.
  18. QUOTE (Soxbadger @ Oct 10, 2012 -> 02:15 PM) Are you confusing state/local tax. Because the US does not have a VAT tax on all sales. There may be a few federal taxes, but those are exceptions. When you go to Target/Walmart, you dont pay national sales tax. So the other taxes don't count, just because of their classification. Gotcha.
  19. QUOTE (Soxbadger @ Oct 10, 2012 -> 02:13 PM) http://taxfoundation.org/blog/news-obama-o...sive-tax-system No it doesnt, the original article in 2008 clearly states that its only showing income/social security, its not taking into account other taxes that the US does not collect at all. Its not a complete picture. Because 25% VAT in Sweden is a pretty significant amount of money not to consider. And taxes that the US taxpayer pays too. Those aren't the only two taxes that rich people pay.
  20. QUOTE (Soxbadger @ Oct 10, 2012 -> 02:10 PM) That article is purposefully misleading. This is an old article, its from 2008: http://taxfoundation.org/blog/news-obama-o...sive-tax-system Those parts are left out of the Washington Times article. Youll notice that they mention Sweden, Sweden has 25% Vat tax, US 0. So when the rich guy in Sweden buys a $500k Bentley, he pays 25% to the Swedish govt. In the US, 0. Thus the rich pay more federal taxes in Sweden, its just not all "income tax" there are other taxes. Damn conservative media bias. There sure are. And you just ignored the ones in the US in your example.
  21. QUOTE (CrimsonWeltall @ Oct 10, 2012 -> 02:10 PM) Two-person country has flat tax rate of 10%. Homeless Joe pays 10% of his $0 income, for $0. Mr. Rich pays 10% of his $10,000,000 income for $1,000,000. Mr. Rich pays 100% of the country's taxes. SUPER PROGRESSIVE FLAT TAX So 47% of filers have no income?
  22. QUOTE (NorthSideSox72 @ Oct 10, 2012 -> 02:08 PM) Right. That now shows 63k added. What did it say BEFORE the revisions? If it said zero, then you'd be right that of the 86k REVISED ADDITIONS, 63k were government jobs. If it showed, say, 60k before, then only 3k of the 86k bump was government. You are confusing your numbers here. The only way you are right, is if that number was zero before the revisions. That is the number. 63k added.
  23. QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Oct 10, 2012 -> 02:02 PM) But it still doesn't say anything about the progressiveness of our tax system. You do realize that, right? The top 10% are paying 45% of taxes. 47% pay nothing at all. The system is not progressive. That makes absolute sense to me.
  24. QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Oct 10, 2012 -> 01:58 PM) That's not the same thing as the progressiveness of our tax system, though. If anything, given that our system isn't very progressive, it shows that the income gap in this country is significantly larger than in other countries. This flat out shows that more taxes come from the richest taxpayers than anywhere else. The highest brackets are paying a way higher percentage of the taxes in this country.
  25. QUOTE (StrangeSox @ Oct 10, 2012 -> 01:48 PM) Tangential but P-S had a good paper last year examining how progressive the US tax system really is: http://elsa.berkeley.edu/~saez/piketty-saezJEP07taxprog.pdf Turns out, not very, especially compared with historical levels. So much for "punishing success." http://p.washingtontimes.com/blog/watercoo...-pay-larger-sh/

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.