caulfield12
Members
-
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Currently
Viewing Topic: Grant Taylor to starting rotation in 2027. Hagen Smith stays in the bullpen. Per Getz.
Everything posted by caulfield12
-
7/10
QUOTE (Balta1701 @ Jul 10, 2013 -> 04:02 PM) I wouldn't feel nearly as strongly about him missing if it weren't for this forum. It's actually amusing, that so many people are actively rooting against him, because of a thread or two on a message board forum, haha. That's fine, it is making this baseball season easier for me to deal with.
-
Rosenthal: Sox should market Sale
QUOTE (Balta1701 @ Jul 10, 2013 -> 04:01 PM) I still say I will trade Sale if Mike Trout is on the market. I don't care if a team is trading me the #1 prospect in baseball, I don't. Those guys don't always turn into all-stars. Heyward's been struggling. Weiters has been good but not great (.708 OPS this year). Delmon Young was a #1. Matsuzaka was a #1. Don't forget Josh Hamilton, Matt Cain, Tim Lincecum, Pujols, Greinke, etc. David Price, to a lesser extent. Strasburg isn't quite the same pitcher as before, either.
-
Rosenthal: Sox should market Sale
We have to cross our fingers and pray he doesn't go down to elbow surgery in 2014 or 2015 or we'll all be revisiting this thread and saying what an idiot Hahn was for holding onto him too long when each year going forward (riddled with non-competitive teams and sub-.500 records and apathy) the White Sox ended up blowing the opportunity of a decade to rebuild their franchise and breathe new life back into it.
-
7/10
QUOTE (southsider2k5 @ Jul 10, 2013 -> 03:48 PM) They aren't in his corner. They are in their own ratings corner. Big difference. So you would differentiate that from Obama 100%?...they (the so-called traditional as well as blogging/new age media) were all politically liberal and "left leaning," AND it was in their best interest because very few people had "in the middle of the road" thoughts and either loved or hated him, more or less? More page views = more advertising revenue, more revenue=higher profits and higher salaries for media. Puig is the perfect story in many respects, he represents the American Dream (the new version of it, as well as the anti-immigrant/backlash side of it), he's a minority, that brings a certain degree of controversy with it...he plays for the new Death Star L.A. Empire (since the Yankees are no longer so hate-worthy as 10-15 years ago, with the Red Sox also joining in)...there's always nobody saying they don't have an opinion or don't care. Then you have the Papelbon's and Bochy's and other players representing baseball tradition, that he hasn't earned his stripes yet, that he's taking a spot away from someone more deserving...and yet that wasn't said nearly as much last year when Trout and Harper made it. I'm exaggerating a bit to make a point, but the Puig argument is pretty polarizing, even for non-Dodgers fans. Everyone has a pretty strong viewpoint, one way or the other. It's not like ANYBODY cares who takes the last spot in the AL (the five relievers).
-
2013 Cubs catch all thread
QUOTE (southsider2k5 @ Jul 10, 2013 -> 03:46 PM) The discussion has become that having prospects is somehow better than having a major league team for a lot of people. f*** that s***. Given the choice, I choose the major league team every single time. Of course, for the White Sox we are in s***ty major league team, s***ty farm system/development, the worst case scenario. Not that I would trade teams, but, from a fan's point of view, they have more reasons for optimism...maybe there's only a 25-50% chance it actually works out, but they're following a concerted strategy and not just throwing darts at a board.
-
Red Sox interested in Thornton
QUOTE (Y2JImmy0 @ Jul 10, 2013 -> 02:38 PM) But he won't be here. How much is the option for? A team trading him could look at him as a guy that they also get next year. no way, he's paid almost like a closer, it would be a huge overpay just on salary alone, not to mention surrendering anything of value prospect-wise.
-
Rosenthal: Sox should market Sale
QUOTE (Eminor3rd @ Jul 10, 2013 -> 03:04 PM) This only makes sense if: 1) The Sox want to do a long-term rebuild like the Cubs or Astros, and it is the precursor to dumping off literally everyone else worth anything 2) You get multiple ML ready position players and then decide to keep Peavy and Rios and compete next year And 2 just doesn't happen quite as much as it used to. Although the Haren for Skaggs/Corbin payoff would be a nice outcome...add in a position prospect at AA/AAA, done, steak dinner, boom.
-
7/10
QUOTE (Jake @ Jul 10, 2013 -> 02:44 PM) I'm starting to hate Puig so much that I will actively avoid the innings he would play in the A-S game That sounds like the next yahoo contributor network article. You should just write an article bashing him, the hype, the media and Commissioner's office all campaigning for him actively, Don Mattingly, all the messageboard hooligans like me, it would be funny. But you have to be really over the top and act almost like you hate him on a visceral level. Like many people feel about Harper.
-
Rios, $1M traded to Rangers
QUOTE (witesoxfan @ Jul 10, 2013 -> 02:31 PM) Worth noting is that the Boras guy is Ellsbury's agent. Yeah, he could get $18-20 million. And Viciedo's. And Kendrys Morales.
-
2013 Cubs catch all thread
QUOTE (hammerhead johnson @ Jul 10, 2013 -> 01:23 PM) When did Balta hit his head? I don't recall you being this slow back when I used to post here regularly. It's a fascinating development. Right around the time of the Cubs' series...the 3 games.
-
7/10
QUOTE (witesoxfan @ Jul 10, 2013 -> 02:27 PM) I'd tune into the game just to watch Barry Bonds if he were selected, but I wouldn't vote for him. That's an extremely flawed and weak argument. It doesn't matter. No way Selig will have the All-Star Game without Puig there now. I'd be willing to bet a lot of money they find a way, somehow.
-
Red Sox interested in Thornton
QUOTE (Y2JImmy0 @ Jul 10, 2013 -> 02:17 PM) I tweeted him and asked about that. Hayes responded to me that Thornton has an option for next year. I thought he was free at year's end. team option, i think he will get a 500K buyout....he's GONE
-
7/10
Fine, the simplest argument of all. Is there ANYONE besides Braves' fans and Greg Walker who are going to tune in specifically to watch Freddie Freeman get one AB and maybe 2-3 innings on the field?
-
Red Sox interested in Thornton
QUOTE (flavum @ Jul 10, 2013 -> 02:12 PM) https://twitter.com/DanHayesCSN/status/355055545486544896 "price for Thornton is steep". Um, ok. Sets way back machine to 2006-2010 before Jim Thome at-bat.
-
FS Midseason Top 25 Prospects
QUOTE (ChiSox_Sonix @ Jul 10, 2013 -> 02:05 PM) I understand the reasoning, I just don't agree with it. I get that he has no stats to ooh and ahh over but there are people who have seen him. People who do this for a living and he was very highly regarded by many of them. Obviously, kids like him have an enormously high bust rate and likelihood of making the majors should be taken into account. However, pure potential, should also matter. Michael Ynoa, Miguel Sano, Gary Sanchez and Jurickson Profar were all ranked by BA in their respective organizations top prospects (3, 4, 7, 5) just months after their signings and without playing any games in any league yet as well (and all were several months younger than Zapata). If the people doing the ranking wanted to leave him out of their ranks that's fine, but if enough people included him and as a result he fell in the top 25, it should have been taken into account IMO. I mean, if we were trying to make a trade with another team and they had a choice between Zapata and Santos Rodriguez, it's fairly safe to assume what player they would choose to take. Right. Or even Daniel Webb vs. Zapata, there'd be an excellent debate, as the White Sox, more than anything else, need/lack young power bats at every position in the line-up besides Viciedo (he makes it).
-
FS Midseason Top 25 Prospects
QUOTE (Jake @ Jul 10, 2013 -> 12:21 PM) We all know what the standard is in high school baseball, though the hay is really made in club ball. We see these kids at events like Area Code Games and elite club tournaments where they often match up against other draft talent. Even when not, scouts know how good a given American player's competition is. Look at Tim Anderson, who may be a high-high-first round talent but there was too much uncertainty about his competition to know for sure. Now imagine a 16-year-old who has only played against a bunch of exploited kids in a country where there are many fewer scouts and eyeballs in a bunch of simulated games. Disagree wholeheartedly....there's a reason why players like Albert Pujols, Logan Morrison, etc., weren't noticed playing JC ball in KC, or why Mark Buehrle slipped out of the entire draft almost. If anything, there are too many buscones and too many eyes on them, but don't kid yourself....there are a plethora of scouts there and in Venezuela.
-
7/10
QUOTE (Balta1701 @ Jul 10, 2013 -> 01:58 PM) WTF Overlay that NL voting map against either the 2008 or 2012 presidential election map. They're pretty close to identical, comparing Puig and Freeman head-to-head. One mustn't forget, there's likely to be some racism (subtle or overt) at play here as well. But that discussion is opening up a whole different can of worms.
-
Rios, $1M traded to Rangers
I think we keep Dunn and roll the dice on being able to compete next year if we can add 2 pieces. No more than 2 though....McCann will be expensive, and so will Ellsbury. Choo would be the other good option for leadoff. And I would prefer Jacoby, simply because he's already in the AL and it seems NL players often have difficulty transitioning to the AL in their first season. Of course, Choo also is quite familiar with the AL and AL Central. And I think you absolutely have to deal Danks/Peavy and either Rios or Ramirez...probably can't keep both of them, and still come up with the payroll numbers that will work from JR's perspective.
-
7/10
QUOTE (fathom @ Jul 10, 2013 -> 01:53 PM) caulfield, you must be watching/listening to different things than me, as just about everyone I've heard doesn't think Puig should make it. There's a solid majority of the national baseball media network in his corner though. This really is a lot like Obama/Hillary, and then the Obama presidential elections. The "media" bias issue. The East and West coast vs. the South/Heartland. The old school traditional values/conservative "silent majority" being for Freeman. It's fascinating, if you look at the voting trends, even on a county by county basis. Of course, Pence dominates the northern half of CA. Maybe if he wasn't on the ballot, then Freeman would probably lose, along with the early votes going to Adrian Gonzalez.
-
7/10 Sox vs Cats
Phegley benched, lol.... Sort of. I'm sure he would probably be in there with another 2/4 and homer or double game.
-
7/10
QUOTE (ChiSox_Sonix @ Jul 10, 2013 -> 01:33 PM) Yes, but crimes agianst Puig, aka the best LF ever, are basically crimes against humanity The backlash will be more interesting now if he doesn't make it. There will be a lot of squirming around in NYC in the commissioner's office, trying to find someone to "sit out" for a dubious injury so Puig can at least be invited to the game. Just count how many articles and comments are going to start appearing tmrw at 3 p.m. if he loses. It's going to be a PR mess.
-
Rios, $1M traded to Rangers
QUOTE (Jake @ Jul 10, 2013 -> 12:37 PM) John Danks was a near-MLB ready prospect, the original subject of conversation. Okay, that didn't make sense paired with Juan Uribe, and talking about "scrap heap."
-
2013 Cubs catch all thread
QUOTE (hammerhead johnson @ Jul 10, 2013 -> 12:38 PM) Quote the post where someone guaranteed that all of their blue chip prospects would reach the majors. And it's not a bad thing to have a s***load of quality prospects. When the time comes, I'm sure that they'll flip quite a few of 'em for proven major league assets. There is nothing to be pessimistic about. Except for being in the same division with the best organization in baseball right now, as well as the Reds and the Pirates on the rise and having the same number of prospects, but many of them on the pitching side. Maybe you can finish ahead of the Brewers, but that's kind of a given without Braun and with Gallardo probably being traded.
-
7/10
I still hate Buddy Bell, and listening to that interview of 22 minutes made it even worse. I also hate Braves and Blue Jays fans, for all the collusion going on with All-Star votes this week.
-
Rios, $1M traded to Rangers
QUOTE (Jake @ Jul 10, 2013 -> 12:34 PM) John Danks. Juan Uribe was also a scrap heap trade get. Not really. He was nearly Rookie of the Year for the Rockies his first season and then had a season like Viciedo is having now... But I wouldn't call it the scrap heap, I would just say we sold Aaron Miles at his highest possible value. John Danks was scrap heap? A Top 10 draft pick at that age....don't think so.