Everything posted by caulfield12
-
White Sox at Detroit Tigers
In all fairness, we've done plenty of damage against Verlander in the last five seasons. This line-up is just in one of their collective slides, nothing new for the last decade. And the opposing starters have a LOT to do with it. Just because you've faced someone 10 times doesn't mean you can then use that knowledge every time out to beat them. If that were true, then we would have turned the corner against Liriano, Santana or Sabathia a long time ago. Just like college basketball teams that get more and more knowledgeable about their opponents when they play 3 or more times in one season, it actually in many ways gets harder and not easier to beat someone like that. Think of it from the flip side. Everyone's seen what Mark Buehrle does for the last 10 years. There are no secrets about it. His stuff now is basically what your average high schooler in a top notch program features. Yet he's had 2 no hitters and has gone through numerous teams like a buzzsaw during his career. It's not that those teams weren't prepared to face him, they were just out-executed, out-thought and usually swung at his pitches or got themselves out. That's the nature of hitting and pitching. Normally, over 5-6-7 innings, you'll take 3 runs off Verlander (as long as it's not 0-1-2 runs), hope your own starter holds them down and turn it over to the bullpens.
-
This year will end before the trade deadline with a firesale
QUOTE (iamshack @ Apr 23, 2011 -> 07:10 AM) I forgot about Mark's contract kicker, so that could be a problem. If Jackson posts a 3.5 ERA and the acquiring team only has to pay him $4 million or so, yes, I think you'd get a very solid prospect in return. Dunn has a heck of a track record and I don't think his contract would provide much of a barrier, but yeah, you might have to hold on to him for a year or so and then deal him. Thornton has been one of the best setup men in the league for a few years now. I don't think the contract extension really would scare many teams away. Danks/Floyd/Quentin would probably be the biggest draws, and I think the haul would be pretty decent, along with Jackson. You're (the acquiring team) guaranteeing at least $12 million that Matt Thornton will get it back together again. How many teams out there could afford to take that risk? For a set-up guy? If you do manage to find a trading partner, you're not going to get much back in return, just a salary dump (which does have some value, except in putting a competitive team back out there as soon as possible, assuming the payroll would consequently take a huge hit again). If we traded him anytime in the last 2-3 seasons, with his bargain contract, we could have gotten back a good haul, but the devil's in the timing. Otherwise, we could have gotten something back for Jenks or Crede.
-
This year will end before the trade deadline with a firesale
I think you'd have to cut the difference in the middle. It all comes down to what you can get back for Danks and Quentin based on his hot start. You have to find the right matches with teams needing pitching (easier) than someone needing a defense-limited corner OFer/DH in CQ. Ramirez and Beckham, logically, wouldn't be traded....although I can see some arguing that Ramirez will be out of his prime by the time the team's competitive again. You could definitely shop him, but I doubt they want to go back to Beckham at SS, it would have to be Escobar or another prospect we acquire, and that severely puts a crimp in the offense. Jackson could get you something back in return, definitely. Floyd, as well. Buehrle, Konerko and Dunn, not so much. You're still left with all those contracts like Rios, Peavy, Pierre, Teahen, AJ, Crain, etc., that aren't going anywhere regardless, so the end result is just cosmetic and it's hard to totally rebuild even if you want to. Trading Sale, Santos or even Thornton (after his slow start)? None of those are logical moves, either.
-
The GREAT Daniel Hudson
QUOTE (Dick Allen @ Apr 23, 2011 -> 06:52 AM) I think with sabermetrics becoming more and more mainstream, a lot of people are just looking at stats to determine how guys in AA and AAA project. Jeremy Reed and Jeff Abbott had minor league hitting stats that would project them to be perennial all stars. It didn't happen. Josh Fields was going to be a star because of how he lit up some pitchers in some meaningless games, then the league realized they didn't have to throw him strikes. The biggest jump isn't from A to AA or AA to AAA its from any level to MLB. Personally, I would like the Sox as an organization to put some value on making contact. Its not like they are developing 40 homer guys or 30 homer guys or even 20 homer guys right now, and I'm not emphasizing small ball or bunting. I know contact all around baseball has be de-valued for a long while, although I laugh that a strikeout is just an out like any other out. Its OK some guys strike out a lot, but they should be run producers who also walk a lot. Not every hit is a rocket. If Jordan Danks struck out 80 times instead of 150 and made contact those other 70 ABs some of those 70 would find a hole even if they were weakly hit. Which was the essence of the problem with guys like Brian Anderson or even Getz K-ing like they were 30 homer guys. We can afford to have guys like Morel and Pierre and AJ, we're not going to have 7-8 twenty homer guys again in our line-up. However, if you start having Beckham, Rios and Ramirez K-ing 100+ times without making productive outs, the whole structure of the line-up becomes severely hamstrung. Outside of Quentin and Konerko, nobody's been hitting, so there are targets throughout the line-up for criticism. Not to parrot Rongey and DJ/Farmer and Hawk/Stone, but we've had a long string of facing some really good starting pitchers, since the beginning of the A's series. Farmer made an interesting comment about Morel not being the same since facing Jared Weaver, and Beckham and Rios both look totally lost. Dunn, you know, somehow ends up with his numbers, but hopefully he learns the league quickly and those are Albert Belle 1997 "meaningless" stats where the season's already been lost.
-
The GREAT Daniel Hudson
QUOTE (Quinarvy @ Apr 22, 2011 -> 07:00 PM) Please, give me a reason? Is it his numbers this season? Because then Chris Sale sucks too. Look, Hudson isn't a surefire Hall of Fame lock, but he should be a damn good number three starter for the Diamondbacks in the NL. I was indifferent towards the trade. I still think it was an overpay, but Jackson could very well be our ace this year so I accepted it. Threads like this are just to whip your dick out and yell "I WAS RIGHT!" and bait people into reacting. Right now, if I had one game, I'm taking E-Jax. If I'm planning for the future, it's Hudson. If we somehow resign EJax, get a good pitching prospect, or draft one with whatever picks we hopefully can get for him (I believe he is a Type-B FA right now) then we win the deal. If we don't, we lose, because Hudson represented value. It's like the Charlotte Bobcats pick for the Bulls, you could strike gold or you don't and Hudson looked like he had damn good value until we called him up, then got it back in Arizona. Had he bounced back like that here we'd have been talking about Chris Sale in the rotation and trading Hudson in a package for a closer, probably Heath Bell. The problem is that we'll never know if Hudson or McCarthy or anyone could have done the same things if they'd stayed here. Heck, you can add Kip Wells and Josh Fogg while you're at it. We only know what Jackson has done since the trade. I can't imagine a rotation of Danks-Floyd-Buehrle-Sale-Humber would be doing all that much better. You'd have to argue that Heath Bell would have been available straight up for Hudson AND that Sale could actually outpitch E-Jax this season. We can argue with Bell they would have had 3-4 less blown saves, but it's all murky conjecture. I don't think you can state either with anything close to certainty, especially the idea of Sale outpitching Jackson in 2011 as a starter.
-
2011 AL Central Catch-All Thread
QUOTE (iamshack @ Apr 23, 2011 -> 03:06 AM) I believe it is the home team. And they probably would rather play it later in the season when the weather is better and they can draw more at the gate. And Morneau, Mauer and Nathan are healthy and Cuddyer's not hitting for about the same OPS as Gordon Beckham. With their luck, another Liriano, Pavano or Duensing will have already popped up from the minors (Kyle Gibson?) and they'll sweep right through the Indians in a second-half make-up game. http://www.startribune.com/sports/twins/120519229.html Game won't be made up until July or September. Morneau and Young expected back for today, would have both been out last night.
-
Sick of the negativity
Ummmm, okay. I sure hope you're right and they come back from Detroit and New York still within 5-6 games of first place.
-
Rongey is My New Idol
QUOTE (witesoxfan @ Apr 23, 2011 -> 04:09 AM) I've always seen that he's generally regarded as a better defensive outfielder, especially in CF, and he's probably a bit better offensively too (though he seems to be a guy that, at least at one time and perhaps still today, was really overrated offensively). He developed that reputation with Indians early in his career and is still riding on those coat-tails, to some extent. Because he's one of those "Sox killer" guys, he tends to get overrated just a bit, but he's a legit starter on about 8-10 MLB teams.
-
Rongey is My New Idol
I think they're going with Crisp because he's a better top-of-the-order "igniter" and has the veteran track record, but the dude's been injury prone for most of the last five years. Sweeney probably has about the same amount of speed (as Crisp) and is a pretty good athlete in his own right, but he's not the basestealer that Crisp is...and his career OPS is a rather pedestrian .728. Maybe, just maybe, that's good enough for CF, but not for one of the corners, at least in USCF. I guess now the argument is whether you see more upside down the road in a Sweeney, who has a fairly limited ceiling, as you acknowledged (albeit pretty consistent in his numbers) or someone like a Milledge or Viciedo. Many have seen Sweeney as the type of player who's just not quite good enough offensively for KW to believe in him, a little bit of the Aaron Rowand syndrome, where he had to prove himself year after year in order to become the starter. I always liked him more than Reed or Cunningham, but the jury's still out.
-
Rongey is My New Idol
It actually changed quite a bit after a 1 for 8 performance the last couple of games. Poor Chris, it was only a one point difference between his career average and 2011 earlier when I check it this week. Career .636 2011 .621 So he's regressed a bit with the Royals, ha. So much for the Greg Walker ruins all hitters theory.
-
This year will end before the trade deadline with a firesale
An NL GM (Sandy Alderson) who's not much of a believer in the bunt...we know this won't be Ozzie's next landing spot now Which brings us to Wednesday night’s game, when catcher Josh Thole bunted with none out and Jose Reyes aboard in the ninth. Alderson dislikes bunts. They waste the game’s most precious commodity: an out. Here, the Mets gave up two outs when Thole popped into a double play. “I think if you probably talk to Terry, he’ll tell you the same thing,” Alderson said. “That wasn’t necessarily a standard approach for him in that situation. Alderson did not feel it was necessary to talk to manager Terry Collins about the decision. He believes those under him deserve latitude. If an over-reliance on bunting occurred — i.e. a leadoff single regularly followed by a bunt from a position player — then he would intervene. One incident did not alarm him. “I try to not to express it in the context of a play that didn’t go well, immediately afterward,” Alderson said. R.A. Dickey sparked something resembling a brush fire Wednesday night, when he said that his team needed to stop grousing about how much talent they had and begin making changes. Alderson had no problem with that sentiment. “I think that was very candid and heartfelt,” Alderson said. “I was happy to hear it coming from a player.” www.nj.com/sports
-
White Sox at Detroit Tigers
Kila Ka'aihue will be available soon if he keeps hitting so poorly. Not that we need any more 1B/3B/DH types.
-
White Sox at Detroit Tigers
QUOTE (Jordan4life @ Apr 22, 2011 -> 08:39 PM) Has Coop done jack s*** with a reliever since Thornton? Santos? Sale?
-
White Sox at Detroit Tigers
QUOTE (DukeofChicago88 @ Apr 22, 2011 -> 08:37 PM) Yes leave Pena in Ozzie. Totally the right call no doubt. Who would you have brought it there? Crain? With a 3 or 4 run deficit? Really? Ohman?
-
White Sox at Detroit Tigers
Thanks for eliminating all doubts in this game, Pena. 87 MPH batting practice fastball. I think it's time for him to be released. Unfortunately, he's our only insurance for an injury in the starting rotation.
-
White Sox at Detroit Tigers
Quentin on fire. The rest of the White Sox offense torched by Verlander. Typical Buehrle the last 2-3 years. Brent Morel and Beckham sacrificed by Guillen to the baseball gods. Wow, the Royals just scored five against Derek Holland, highlighted by a Brayan Pena homer to tie it.
-
White Sox at Detroit Tigers
I think I'd rather see the Miller Genuine Draft commercial where the guy buys a round of bikinis for the girls...or is that only a radio ad?
-
White Sox at Detroit Tigers
Verlander is an absolute freak. He's still throwing 98-99 MPH in this weather after well over 100 pitches. Not sure how good that is for his career longevity, Leyland. Well, so much for ever being able to trade away Alex Rios.
-
White Sox at Detroit Tigers
Sox deciding to make it a game finally.
-
White Sox at Detroit Tigers
Trade Quentin now. Just kidding, sort of.
-
White Sox at Detroit Tigers
Typical Friday night Sox never in it game thread. Under 10 pages. Ugly as the weather. Not unexpected though, when Verlander is going good.
-
The GREAT Daniel Hudson
QUOTE (lostfan @ Apr 22, 2011 -> 04:49 PM) I lol'd at this $14.29 trillion or ZERO in the case of a default. Maybe we can split the difference and value Danksie at $7.1 trillion.
-
MLB Attendance problem? (KC, CLE, Cubs, NY teams)
QUOTE (High Mileage @ Apr 22, 2011 -> 05:47 PM) Yep, right around the time John Schuerholz left to take over the Braves, "leading" them to a 94-68 record and an NL pennant a year after they went 65-97. You're pretty much dead on. Kauffman brought baseball back to KC (after the A's moved to Oakland) and was very big in the community/region. Glass and family are rarely seen at Royals games, and they don't even keep a home in the area (well, in Arkansas they do). Glass either couldn't or wouldn't spend his first few years of ownership. The best thing he's done for the organization was hiring Dayton Moore and staying out of actual baseball decisions. Obviously the results have been limited on the field, but he has funded our Draft (we've spent more than anybody since '06) and International Scouting (we've spent more than everybody except the Pirates since '06, IIRC) as well as front office expansion. Out of sight, out of mind. Just keep writing the checks, Old Man... I'll give Glass credit for trying to establish some "legitimacy" in the FA market by going after Meche. And give Meche credit for retiring when he could have just continued to collect a paycheck. But the last couple of years, blending in the Guillens and Ankiels and Podsedniks, it just hasn't worked. On the other hand, they had to throw some journeymen out there to protect the youngsters from being overexposed before they were ready for the major league team. Even spending on Willie Bloomquist, Juan Cruz and Kyle Farnsworth....those are the kind of players who are complementary on a playoff contending team, but a waste of payroll for the Royals. I still remember how enthusiastic Posnanski tried to be when they brought in Hillman from Japan. Well, maybe they'll get it straightened out eventually.
-
White Sox at Detroit Tigers
Wonder if Beckham's going to move down permanently to 8th or 7th now? When Vizquel returns to the bench, does Ramirez stay up at #2? LOL at Ozzie bringing back Morel from the bench to face Verlander in the worst weather possible after his "mental health break", but resting Ramirez. In all fairness, Alexei hasn't done much against Verlander, but you might as well leave Teahen in there one more game and hope he catches fire. Morel's going to be completely overmatched by Verlander. Six losses in a row to the Tigers. Well, we'd beaten the Angels 7 games consectively and that didn't turn out so well.
-
Rongey is My New Idol
Chris Getz is a consistent .636/.637 OPS no matter where he plays. Fields and Anderson? Don't think so. Ryan Sweeney finally ended up losing his starting job in Oakland for a lot of the same reasons he wasn't believed to project as more than a 4th OF in Chicago. Chris Young and Greg Walker don't have anything in common. Even C. Carter has turned out to be a big bust (based on early returns), and the verdict's a bit discouraging on B. Allen. We all know about Jeremy Reed and Michael Morse. Basically, we've simply sucked at developing position prospects since Durham, Ordonez, C-Lee, Crede and Rowand.