I thought this would be a nice topic, since Manning is the better QB IMO and Brady "win's more games". I would rather Manning.

 

Manning, even though he's never won anyting. Brady is a little over rated IMO. He did win a super bowl, but his career numbers aren't all that great.

Manning, but I don't overlook Brady. Brady is a very good quarterback and is a winner, but Manning is a winner too and he's really improved this year.

 

Thats not to say that Manning will win this Sunday, cause my pick is the Patriots.

Brady is a product of a good system, and has a great D to help him out. Manning is by far and away the better QB.

Brady all the way!

 

(Only because he is on the Patriots.)

for whatever reason brady proves he is a winner...i dont give a damn about his stats or how manning is the perfect QB...just win baby

 

ill take brady

Brady. Manning has more weapons and a better offense. Plus, before this year, Brady proved on winning this big names, and major comebacks. Manning, before this year, was awful in playoff games. Even though he's on fire now, dosent mean he can stay that way. Definitely Brady.

As a Colts fan, I have to go w/ Peyton Manning. He just established a new QB record by throwing for 25+ TDs in his 6th straight season. He's the only one to ever accomplish such a feat.

I vote Brady. He has only lost 12 games in his carrer.

I'm glad Brady makes up a team all his own--must really save the Pats on payroll.

 

Manning definetly is the better QB. Plus he is complimented by one of the best WR & RB in the game which helps his stock out alot.

But doesnt Brady have one of the best defenses in the league backing him up? The colts D sucks.

Talk is cheap. We'll see on Sunday who the better QB is.

for whatever reason brady proves he is a winner...i dont give a damn about his stats or how manning is the perfect QB...just win baby

 

ill take brady

I was hoping someone would say that.

 

If I had to take a QB to build a team around, there is absolutely no question I would take Peyton. However, the question is who would you rather have in a championship game. That's simple enough, Tom Brady has never lost a playoff game, Peyton Manning is 2-3 in the playoffs.

 

I'll take Brady, thank you very much.

I'd rather have Kordell Stewart...

I'd rather have Kordell Stewart...

Oh definately, he is double dangerous, with the run and pass.

Thats really a tough call but I have to give the not to Brady.

I'd rather have Kordell Stewart...

Not Funny!

 

 

This Sunday, Brady 'cause they'll win.

Week in week out probably Peyton Womaning.

After watching Manning the last two games, anyone who can honestly not pick him as the top QB in the league is insane. The Pats are going to dominate Sunday's game, but it won't be because they have the better QBs.

For one game, right now, I'd have to go with Brady. The dude just does whatever it takes to win.

Like SS2K said, I really doubt Brady would have put up anything close to respectable against a defense the caliber of NE's. Manning had his work cut out for him today, I'm not making any excuses for the loss. However, I don't think it's fair to put it all on this one game.

I dunno, Brady can really read and breakdown defenses. He's nowhere near as talented as Peyton, but its tough to compare them cause they are two entirely different quarterbacks.

Brady.

Brady. Manning has more weapons and a better offense. Plus, before this year, Brady proved on winning this big names, and major comebacks. Manning, before this year, was awful in playoff games. Even though he's on fire now, dosent mean he can stay that way. Definitely Brady.

Brady because he always seems to win even though he doesn't hav a good running back or many good receivers.

Pats hav 2 1st round picks this year to make their team even betta. If Kevin Jones or Stephen Jackson aren't drafted in the top 10, I think they'll trade up to take em.

Aren't we the smart ones