WestEddy

This is sadly pathetic. When I got like this about the bears, I stopped following them.

Maybe it's just a negotiating tactic. "Oh, you want that much? Look!! This exciting, new candidate just became available!!

In case anyone's wondering....

I don't know if it's not being able to be coached, or bad clubhouse/field presence. It's just my opinion that if they have somebody who might top out at a 95 RC+, play him and save the $2.6 million Sheets will probably earn.

One of the admins here has a problem with joking about suicide. You should probably be mindful of that.

Is Colas bad? He seems to have put up numbers over time. Tanked 2024. My first thought was always to just slide Sosa over to 1st if he keeps hitting, but he's the same height as Vaughn. The 2025 1B may not even finish the year with the team. The only 1B I can squint and see in the pipeline is DJ Gladney. Struck out less than 25% of his PAs at AA (SSS, I know).

I think a take on him is that his back wasn't healed until September. He's just played 50% more baseball this season than he's ever played in his life.

If they can't get a league average hitting prospect as a 3rd or 4th piece of a Crochet or Robert trade, just platoon Elko and Sheets. Elko/Colas would probably be better.

From Keith Law's latest: https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/5852621/2024/10/18/afl-notes-tre-morgan-zyhir-hope-grant-taylor/ Maybe he's just cooked after a full season at AAA, then AFL. The Sox told him he's done for the year, so maybe they like where he's gotten to.

I'm sure every manager still in the running is "a LaRussa guy". Wasn't Manny Machado seen wearing a suit outside Comiskey when we didn't sign him?

Thanks.

And if it's a guy with any experience as a major league manager, he'll be a "retread".

Every team has a bench coach. Like I said.

Ho-hum. And this is actually a spot-on imitation of the dozen or so commenters who don't have an argument, and resort to mockery.

Oh, wow. You laughed at my mention of 6 innings with Atlanta. You're right that invalidates his entire career before that. Otherwise, I have no idea what you're talking about. What's PE? Getz grabbed up a bunch of veteran arms to build a bullpen. I'm sure he got some input from Bannister and Katz. Bannister's worked with a bunch of players who have responded to his coaching or methods. I don't see an issue with picking the guy's brain.

John Brebbia had a ceiling of a shut-down set-up man, which he has done before, and looked like in his 6 Atlanta innings after leaving. Declan Cronin hasn't looked like that since low-A. $4 million isn't a lot to pay a guy who could be a solid go-to bullpen arm. We're playing word games over pitching development. If we have a very good guy at the top of the development ladder, that is the goal.

Every team has a bench coach.

GETZ-LOVER!!! GETZ-LOVER!!!

Bannister doesn't have to be the best pitching developer ever. He just needs to develop our pitching. He is. The perception of "solid relievers" on another team isn't the same as solid relievers on the Sox. Many tears were shed for Declan Cronin, like he would have added 10 wins, and Cronin's numbers are basically the same as John Brebbia's.

I suppose it's fun to pretend that Getz set his own budget, and demanded Grifol not be fired. Hell, many here even think he ran the entire organization as the Director of Player Development. What we're seeing is Getz finally being able to clean house after people's contracts ran out, and the disgruntled, here, are desperately trying to reframe that as a bad thing, or as "praising" Chris Getz.

No, we don't know that. He put together a bad team on the fly. Is the Bannister hire a horrible decision? Multiple people have made the point that they're mad at how Getz was hired, so they're going to be especially impatient with every single move. That's fine. I'm not going to agree with the same nonsense everybody has decided to yell because they're mad.

"It's a bit early to call this move a failure" is not automatically praising Chris Getz. The fact that people interpret anything short of jumping on the dour wagon in full agreement as carrying water, or praising Getz is just weird.

I'll agree with you that Getz was a lazy hire on Reinsdorf's part. I also don't disagree that if Beane or Dombrowski were the GM of this mess, everyone would be making the same, disingenuous arguments.

I would imagine that very few FO hires in MLB are people nobody knows. It's a fun parlor game to pretend that every person Getz hires is bad because they're a "crony" hire, I guess.