QUOTE(CWSGuy406 @ May 11, 2005 -> 01:41 PM)
Dotel was the best deadline closer last season, right? Am I missing someone?
Who did Oakland give up? Teahan? Who else...?
I know Teahan is a good prospect, but he certainly isn't a top prospect. They didn't have to give up their Brian Anderson (Nick Swisher) for Dotel, yet we should give up Anderson to get Wagner?
And I realize that Wagner is better than Dotel, don't get me wrong. But I don't see the need in giving up Anderson/Sweeney/McCarthy...
As far as the Astros were concerned, they got some guy named Beltran for the price of the Great John Buck and Dotel.
Billy Beane kicked in Mike Wood and Teahan to sweeten the pot and take Dotel.
Beltran, not Dotel, was the big name in that trade. Especially because Houston had Lidge ready to step up.