You stated Goodwin is a better fielder because of his sprint speed. My response was there is more to defense than speed, including routes, throwing, judgement. Goodwin has been God Awful, and his career stats fielding stats bare that out. It’s why a “turtle” has better fielding stats than the hare, the two primary defensive statistics available. Goodwin’s stats are for his whole career, and he is a below average LF as well as CF, because he does a lot of bad out there (at least four bad plays today alone).
The discussion can end at this point, as there is nothing more to be said, at least in my end. I hope Goodwin can at least hit during his remaining days on the team. Tony can swap in Hamilton for defense in close games with Leury unavailable due to Madrigal’s absence.