Chimpton

So he has rebuilt well but then you say the rest of his tenure has been bad, are you talking about before the rebuild?

Hahn has provided most of the parts necessary for a successful team during the rebuild, he has not managed them, so sacking him at this point would be harsh in my opinion. TLR was brought in (by Jerry) to win postseason games, so far he has shown no more ability to do that than Ricky R.

Oh I agree, it seemed strange and unnecessary at the time and looked worse as the season went on and last night well that just took the biscuit!

What do people think will it be: A) a glorious 3-2 comeback win for the Sox B) 3-2 Astros after the Sox win both their home games. C) 3-1 Astros Or D) a 3-0 sweep?

Hindsight is a beautiful country! But yes it does look dumber now than it did at the time!

Well at least it was nice spending the season talking about the post season, just a pity that it is unlikely to go beyond 3 games in 4 days. ?

Nah, just lulling them into a false sense of security!

And to think I got my hopes up in the top of the innings. I should have known better.

That's what I like, never satisfied! ?

They are just waiting for us to load the bases first to really get us excited then hit a DP.

I won't get too excited at a leadoff hit with the Sox ability to hit double plays or find bizarre ways to get out

Will we manage a base runner this innings or a quick 1,2,3 innings?

At this rate Kimbrel and Hendricks won't be needed all series.

What a f@cking joke

Relax? They need to f**king wake up and start to do the basics.

This is another hard watch. I have a worrying feeling we may have seen the only Sox run of the game!

If we played like game 1 at home we would have still lost

Hopefully the Sox will wake up before this series is over, the game 1 performance was like game 1 of Spring Training not the post season. Some of the at bats today were simply awful.

With the state of our bats yesterday he will still get a loss even if he limits them to 1 run ☹️

If we are mentioning bad trades the Jeff Samardzija trade that gave away Semien was the one I remember!

The analysis is looking at the players in the current squad of players, not every trade done by Hahn, every club makes bad trades but all I am saying is that in assembling this team that has made the post season back to back for the first time ever Hahn has done a good job on the free agents and trades. As for the trades being a 'net loss' that is what I meant when I said stats can be used to prove anything, as most of those trades were of MLB talent like Sale for prospects then the WAR would be a net loss initially but I am sure that even you would admit that Cease and Eloy for Quintana has been a good trade no matter what the current WAR net exchange looks like. Even the Sale trade, whilst looking one sided looking at the WAR that is because Kopech is not yet at his full potential and Moncada may yet develop the talent that is undoubtedly there even further if his bat can return to 2019 levels to go along with his improved defence.

Really interesting that despite the grief we routinely give the front office on here (some of it deserved) that trades and free agent signings have provided us with the biggest bWAR contributions. I know stats can be used to prove many things but in my opinion Hahn can't be all that bad at his job looking at those figures. And no I am not related to him or any member of the front office ?

As long as it is when the team has a big lead or is losing already by a big score.

You pose a difficult question because both Garcia and Hernandez are routinely slated on here. But for what it is worth I would go with Garcia as the man in form, and a man who will always give 100%

Being sensible and logical will get you nowhere on here! ☺️