Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Soxtalk.com

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Chisoxfn

Admin
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Chisoxfn

  1. QUOTE(aboz56 @ Oct 13, 2005 -> 04:25 PM) Anything for Saturday? I wonder how quickly I could get a flight in and then back out. What's the closest airport that SWA has to Anaheim? Closest is John Wayne which is in Santa Ana/Orange County. However, Ontario and Los Angeles (neither are very far) away.
  2. QUOTE(aboz56 @ Oct 13, 2005 -> 04:25 PM) Anything for Saturday? I wonder how quickly I could get a flight in and then back out. Ya, just tell me relatively quickly otherwise my dad will unload them.
  3. QUOTE(CaliSoxFanViaSWside @ Oct 13, 2005 -> 04:16 PM) I'm going Friday have to get off work early. Will leave by 3:30 hopefully from Pasadena. Won't have too much time to party beforehand.But make something definite either in the Stadium or before or after the game or all 3 and I'll be there with another Soxtalk dude Oh by the way any of you So Cal Sox fans tell me here or PM me if you want to become a member of the So Cal Chapter of SoxTalk. Tannerfan & Ginger Kid and anyone else not on my list at the bottom of my post feel free to join in . Jason and Trevor (hi8is) are members already. My seats are section V537 Row N seats 9 & 10. Upperdeck rightfield foul pole extended. Jason can you pin this thread ? Ya, its pinned. I'm in 420...Rog G, Seats 7-10.
  4. If anyone wants 1 ticket for Friday's game I can help them out. Face value. Just PM me or make a post here.
  5. I'll be trying. Maybe some of us can work out some deals where if some get lucky we get 4 and cut them to other people who weren't so.
  6. Just got your message. I'll be there. Friday I'm assuming in the parking lot with some of my friends, so tell me the place and I'll meet you all. Saturday I probably won't get there till about an hr before the gamd and Sunday probably the same. Hi8is is gonna come down Saturday I think.
  7. Don't know about the rest of you, but I got a confirmation email today and my jersey has been shipped out. I should get it Monday or Tuesday.
  8. Hey Rex...just wanted to say. Really appreciate your insight on the issue. Same with you Krush...the two have you done a great job explaining both perspectives and each of your opinions.
  9. I'm just going to respond...a win is a win, is a win. I've already heard it from Angel fans and all I can say is that Escobar hung it and Crede bashed it. Its a brand new series.
  10. Chisoxfn replied to Heads22's topic in Pale Hose Talk
    QUOTE(NUKE_CLEVELAND @ Oct 12, 2005 -> 07:54 PM) No but he sure as hell came through tonight. from your worst critic on Soxtalk! I hope you took a shot for that double Nukie Man that was sweet. When it left the bat I was just yelling at the tv, stay fair, stay fair and when it did I went nuts.
  11. Tomorrows an off day and than on Friday the Sox are gonna have to come out and excecute and play good baseball. Come on White Sox...GO GO GO GO WHITE SOX....Chicago's proud of you
  12. QUOTE(WilliamTell @ Oct 12, 2005 -> 07:53 PM) Yeah I don't blame Josh Paul either. It was one of those things where he honestly thought he made the catch. Also look at Escobar. You have AJ running down to 1st and Escobar is watching him do so and the ball isn't that far from him. Erstad was there in case a throw was made (or at least relatively close). I think if I were a pitcher and saw AJ start running I'd have gotten out and started running towards the ball and at least given it a shot. I just know your taught to continue playing until you know the inning is over. Whether that was clearly called or not, who knows.
  13. QUOTE(Brian @ Oct 12, 2005 -> 08:22 PM) Too bad umps don't have press conferences. Umm...it was just on.
  14. The other umps seem to be backing the ump, but I guess that should be expected. I just find it intersting that ball said he heard the ump say something and AJ said he heard nothing.
  15. I think my argument is that Paul threw the ball out to the mound before the 2nd signal by the umpire. I think that right there is interesting, because had he waited I think they have a better argument. I hate the questions being asked. Some are so bias (on both sides) and I have yet to see any clear evidence for the it was clearly caught side, imo. Not that I'm 100% that it hit the dirt, but I'm hard pressed to believe that it wasn't trapped. We'll see though, the ump sounds relatively accurate and he had been doing the same strikeout call the entire game.
  16. Welcome aboard...the more Sox fans here the merrier
  17. QUOTE(CWSGuy406 @ Oct 12, 2005 -> 08:13 PM) THAT'S NOT WHAT THEY'RE ARGUING!!!!!! Sheesh. We don't know what was said, but it's absolutely pathetic seeing some people defend this call like they KNOW it was called correctly. We don't know what was said from the umpire. I'm sorry, I just think it's extremely pathetic to see some people act like they know it was the correct call (sorry for sounding like a broken record). I'm not saying they made the right call, or the wrong call, but GMAB... I think its indecisive. I see some saying it was 100% one way and others saying it was 100% another way. That right there tells me it was totally questionable. I don't think we'll know for sure, but I thought it hit the dirt. Now we can argue the umps stuff as much as possible.
  18. QUOTE(S720 @ Oct 12, 2005 -> 08:05 PM) Chisoxfn, what do make of the umpire's clenching his fist? Why did he do that if it wasn't an out? I know the ball was trapped. My question is in regard to the umpire's motion. I cna't say for sure. Only the ump knows what he was thinking. Umps sometimes make different signals...that was the case and I definately can see the Angels perspective of it. At the same time, I saw Paul already throw the ball out to the mound before the strikeout sign was given so what does it matter. Its not like Paul was motivated based on that call, imo. I should add, this is a judgement thing, so by no means am i necessarily right. Just my 2 cents on the issue and I agree with Kruk and Reynolds.
  19. QUOTE(Linnwood @ Oct 12, 2005 -> 08:04 PM) Josh Paul is on Comcast right now insisting that he caught it. He just said that the Ump said "No catch" If he said no catch, doesn't that mean that it wasn't caught.
  20. QUOTE(kapkomet @ Oct 12, 2005 -> 07:55 PM) JUst win three more focking games this series, and it all doesn't matter. s***, what a momentum changer. Its big for the Sox, but at the same time, Mike is an awesome manager and he's gonna have these guys ready to play. Big came on Friday...and I can't wait for it. It will be the first time in my life I get to see the Sox in the playoffs in person
  21. QUOTE(redandwhite @ Oct 12, 2005 -> 07:58 PM) Boards of all teams are criticizing the call and with good reason. It was a terrible call. You can diagnose this for hours but the fact remains, the White Sox and Angels are tied at 1. If it hit the dirt, it wasn't a horrid call. There was no he's out (not a definitive one) there was no anything (either way) that indicated that the Angels should have stopped and threw the ball back. I vehemently disagree with this idea, imo. The ball hit the dirt and its a players job to keep playing until something is ruled final. Plus how can it be a horrible call when no replay shows that the ball clearly went into his mitt. In fact I think most replays show that there is a pretty likely chance that it did hit the dirt.
  22. QUOTE(Soxbadger @ Oct 12, 2005 -> 07:56 PM) I said this right off the bat. There is a clear change in direction of the ball, it bounces up. Now it is possible that it bounces in the lower part of the mitt and goes to the upper part, but it shows that there is no certainty about the call. It was a judgement call, and even with the high tech equipment there is no absolute answer. I believe the reason we got the call is that the White Sox showed hussle on the play, where as the Angels were just taking the strike out for granted. SB Plus if you look you see the ball bounce up and if it didn't hit the ground, it wouldn't have went up higher into the mitt. I think its the right call.
  23. QUOTE(IlliniKrush @ Oct 12, 2005 -> 07:52 PM) Jas- It's different because you dictate how players react on a call like that. That's one of the immediate calls you have to make so the catcher knows if he needs to throw or not. Let's say there is a runner on 3rd or something...if he throws for s***s when the ump knows he's out but is slow on the call and throws it down the line and a run scores...that's on the ump. If the home plate umpire rules out, he's out. He could ask for help before calling him out, or signal to an umpire he needs help (or more so a base umpire will show a closed fist for yes, it was a catch or open hand for no, it hit dirt. Then the ump can make a call. But lets say a runners on 2nd base and the ball is ruled a trap...he has to stay half way and than run back to 2nd instead of head to 3rd because its originally called out. Doesn't that in fact dictate what a player does, yet it can still be changed. I've seen umps have all kinds of different strike out calls. I also think a lot of umps make that similar call (which is what he claims) where you do the strike 3 call with an out sign. That said, I long said if I were Sciosc, I'd be mad at the umps signaling because I still think that ball hit the ground. I have yet to see any conclusive evidence to tell me it didn't. I also never heard any footage of the ump saying it was caught clean or saying it wasn't caught clean. Sure the ump could have done a better job about being loud, but at the same time, its the catchers job to make the tag and I think the one case you can make from the Sox side is that Paul threw the ball back to the mound before the ump even made his next signal (because AJ had turned around) and than ran back.
  24. QUOTE(redandwhite @ Oct 12, 2005 -> 07:35 PM) Exactly. Although his rebut right now on ESPN is that he makes the out fist when a player strikes out swinging at all times. And the replays will show that, imo. You can make the calls he made. His explanation makes sense. The debatable fact is whether or not the ball hit the ground, imo.
  25. QUOTE(IlliniKrush @ Oct 12, 2005 -> 07:42 PM) I'm not an expert on protests, but i'm pretty sure nothing can happen as far as an official protest goes. It's similar to a safe/out call, etc. They can't appeal whether the ball hit the ground, they could only appeal something based off Eddings mechanics behind the plate. And i don't even know if that is possible. Ya, because there is no official way to call outs (I don't think) and he can say my way is to signal once for no contact, 2nd time that it was a strike. Its basically his word and you can't change anything. And the only thing you can protest is that, you can't protest whether it was in the dirt or not. Not 100% on that, but 99.9% on it.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.