Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Soxtalk.com

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Chisoxfn

Admin

Everything posted by Chisoxfn

  1. QUOTE (Y2JImmy0 @ Mar 1, 2017 -> 08:41 AM) Jimmy has played 2 NFL games and was a Day 2 prospect out of an FCS school. I'd be stunned if they get the 1st round pick they are seeking. I believe that 4 QB's go in the first round as well. I'd rather take one of them then trade a boatload of picks for Jimmy and pay him. I am a Jimmy fan and would be fine with the move (as long as Bears obviously believed in him). I wouldn't give up anything but a late 1st (preferably a 2nd). The wild card is you obviously have to pay him which is a risk that doesn't exist with a QB. Part of it is, how safe / secure do Fox/Pace feel. If I feel safe/secure, I'll take the rookie QB and if I don't like him, I can find a veteran later...if I think I need to win sooner vs. later, I probably roll the dice on Jimmy G. A happy medium might be taking a QB in the 2nd and trading a 3rd for AJ McCarron.
  2. QUOTE (Y2JImmy0 @ Mar 1, 2017 -> 08:09 AM) That's total posturing. He's not worth a 1st. They aren't getting a 1st. They have no real leverage either. They can keep him next year but then he'll walk in free agency after the season. Patriots will receive a 2019 comp pick in that scenario. I'd call their bluff. Sam Bradford got a haul...Jimmy G has more upside then Bradford, imo. I think a lot of people tend to undervalue what it will ultimately take to get a QB. Just like I tend to think we'll see a run on QB's in the 1st round, despite all the current reports that there isn't one worth drafting in the top 10. We'll see.
  3. I presume this is the Patriots trying to drive leverage, that said, none of us know what their actual valuation of Jimmy is and what their plans are. They clearly could maximize value for him in a trade (to help them win now) or they could say, look, we need a QB and this is our guy and we need to find a way to keep him here two more years until Brady retires. For all they know next year Brady's arm will fall off and then what do they do if they move Jimmy (obviously they did draft a guy relatively early last year, but what is there long term view of him vs. Jimmy G, etc). I did note the Pats did not franchise Hightower and are going to let him test the market.
  4. QUOTE (shipps @ Feb 28, 2017 -> 02:26 PM) Maybe Hahns plan to get the top of the elite guys is flawed then? He should be trying to get quantity instead of quality? Thanks for making me doubt the whole damn rebuilding plan. Remember though...the not top 10 guys consistent of 90 guys, so higher bust rate. In general, I tend to view it as you want as many top 100 guys as possible (more elite better, but also remember, the ranking is a static ranking and variables can move relatively quickly, especially as guys can explode onto / off of the scene relatively quickly (especially if they have major flaws, etc). Prospect evaluation has a combination of art and science and it certainly isn't a definitive thing and there are a lot of variables, including the fact, that sometimes, people can just be flat lucky.
  5. I thought this was an interest read (dates back to 2014). Most curious was the 2007 list and who was listed as a bust (vs. say a Brandon Wood / Cameron Maybin). In general, always decent reality check looking at these type of lists and also even the other noteable guys from top 100 and often times it is the other people in top 100 who emerge better. http://www.sportsonearth.com/article/67202234/
  6. QUOTE (chitownsportsfan @ Feb 27, 2017 -> 09:36 PM) What he have, a whopping 20 PA at age 21 in MLB? Just a protip for Sox fans: we haven't had a position player prospect this highly rated by every service since probably...well, ever. Relax. Let the kid develop. His bat is gonna play. If he can make more plays like he did today at 2B he's a star. Probably since Joe Borchard (I think Borchard is the highest rate position prospect the Sox have had since Frank Thomas). Gordon Beckham probably would have gotten pretty high on lists if he hadn't gotten moved up so fast that he kind of lost "prospect" status before ever getting to take advantage of where he stood (but at his peak...he probably would have been top 10-15..again not where Moncada ranks). Pitching wise, I believe Jon Rauch was the highest rated pitching prospect the organization has had until Giolito (from a pure publication perspective).
  7. QUOTE (soxfan2014 @ Feb 28, 2017 -> 01:58 PM) I really wouldn't be opposed to Moncada getting a full year in Triple-A to be honest. Maybe a September call-up and then called up June 2018 (if he's producing) and then having him for the remainder of the year plus 6 years. If I was going to say any of those guys took a bit longer, I'd have pegged it to be Moncada. That said, I still say it would be dissapointing if they weren't all on the major league roster come the summer.
  8. QUOTE (Tony @ Feb 28, 2017 -> 01:31 PM) The really lame, but true answer is whenever they are ready. I know that isn't what you're totally asking, but my point is because the White Sox have come out and said this is going to be a longer process, this isn't a Jimmy Rollins/Tim Anderson thing where it's "Well if we can get three good months of out Rollins, maybe Anderson can come up by the deadline and we'll be in good shape.." I want to see these guys on the major league roster when they have very little left to prove in MiLB. If Moncada is just crushing in AAA by June, bring him up and start the process. If Giolito takes the entire year in AAA to work on things, I guess so be it. Certainly there will be some disappoint with some of these guys, but in my head, I don't have any estimated arrival dates for any of them. Lets see what happens in AA-AAA over the first three months of the year, then take a look at the bigger picture. All that said, I would be surprised / dissapointed if by the summer, Lopez / Giolito / Fullmer / Moncada were not on the major league roster. I agree with you, they shouldn't be up until they are ready, but I would expect, that given each of their time frames and existing minor league experience, that we would be targeting having those guys all up during the second half of this year.
  9. QUOTE (fathom @ Feb 28, 2017 -> 12:33 PM) Yep surprised by how many predicting 75 or more wins If we don't trade Q and Robertson....I think we win 75 or more.
  10. QUOTE (fathom @ Feb 28, 2017 -> 12:20 PM) Haha can't wait for people to freak out If people freak out about a guy who is 20 pitching in an early spring training game, they are nuts. No one expects Kopech to be even close to the big league roster at this point. If anything, I'd think people should be excited that he flashed some plus curves and obviously demonstrated that his velocity is real.
  11. QUOTE (KyYlE23 @ Feb 28, 2017 -> 08:09 AM) Alshon Jefferys injury history is extremely overblown. He had one year where he was consistently injured Yep. If it weren't for his suspension (and I realize, his suspension was an issue, but not injury related), he'd have played in every game in 3 of the last 4 seasons. Yes, he's had some injuries and had trouble practicing at times, but in general, the guy has played. I'm okay with the Bears deciding he isn't worth their resources, etc...what I'm not okay in is how they mismanaged the asset and ended up getting nothing for him. Alshon is too good of a player to just let walk (without at least getting a 3rd or 4th round pick).
  12. I figured you'd make a smartass Hawkeye comment in here since I presume they will be NIT bound.
  13. Chisoxfn replied to Texsox's topic in SLaM
    Is Tmobile doing for free again this year?
  14. Me too. I always liked Peavy.
  15. QUOTE (Jordan4life @ Feb 27, 2017 -> 12:28 PM) Rose is just a terrible player at this point. He's no longer starter caliber and hasn't been for a while. He'd probably be best suited in a 6-man type role, where he could come in and you just ask him to score (and he'd play hard those limited minutes). That said, probably too much to ask. I'm just glad he's another teams problem.
  16. Raptors have a good back-up though, which should help, as long as Lowry can get healthy before the playoffs.
  17. Interesting...in the report they talk about how bad his defense is. Yes...I agree...he become one of the worst defensive players in the entire league (like Doug McDermott bad). He is actually shooting at a pretty high clip (from 2 point range). His assist totals continue to be awful (not sure how he ever almost average 8 APG when you think back and look at how lousy of a passer he is).
  18. QUOTE (Dick Allen @ Feb 27, 2017 -> 12:19 PM) Rumor the Knicks will waive DRose Interesting. He's actually been better then he was last year (and largely healthy). I wonder why? Is this just a thing so they can suck even more? Or is Rose asking for it? Or is he that bad in the lockeroom (presume that isn't the case)?
  19. QUOTE (Jordan4life @ Feb 27, 2017 -> 12:09 PM) Embiid out indefinitely. He's not gonna make it. Damn shame. Losing Oden was bad enough but this guy has personality for days. Dario Saric will go down as one of the worst ROY winners in history. E: Kyle Lowry done for at least the regular season. Wrist surgery. LeBron's road just got a lot easier. Further emphasizes, that look at what "tanking" got the Sixers. One guy is down and out, another was widely available for trade but not dealt for a minimal package (Okafor) and a 3rd was sent to Dallas for a pretty minimal trade? The 4th is going to miss the entire season (albeit, he certainly has the most potential out of the group...not named the injured Embiid).
  20. QUOTE (KyYlE23 @ Feb 27, 2017 -> 12:03 PM) Bulls about to release a PG, seems MCW and Canaan are the likely candidates I presume it would be Canaan. I don't see why you would release MCW over the guy who never plays.
  21. QUOTE (bmags @ Feb 27, 2017 -> 10:55 AM) Well, maybe we'll finally get a comp pick and they think that would have beat what they'd have gotten on market. I still think this is dumb as hell. Can anyone confirm...do they look at comp picks in isolation (for losing a player)? Or do they look at the net gains / losses via free agency. So for example, if the Bears signed like 6 pretty good size free agents, but loss Alshon, would they consider the fact that we signed other guys when evaluating for whether we deserve a pick for losing Alshon? If the answer is no, then I could understand this as I would suspect we'd get a decent comp pick for him (maybe one of those end of 3rd round ones). That said, I thought they look at players lost and gained, in which case, I presume we'll get nothing, since we will likely be signing a good number of free agents.
  22. QUOTE (southsider2k5 @ Feb 27, 2017 -> 10:53 AM) LeBron isn't stupid. He recognizes that the team he has isn't going to beat the Warriors with Kevin Durant. Of course he wants more. But so does the rest of the NBA. Why do you think that the best team in the history of the NBA blew away cap spaces and players to make room for Kevin Durant? Every body is looking for more. Singling out James for wanting more is silly, especially since even now the Warriors are adding players too. What Lebron is doing, isn't forcing Cleveland to get better players (indirectly it might do a bit)...it is him trying to manage his legacy when he loses to Warriors in 5 games (hell...if he makes it to the Warriors). I don't love anyone in the east and Lebron is Lebron, but Cleveland just doesn't play that well together. Don't get me wrong, they are good, but they don't look like a championship team because the 3 guys on the team kind of neuter each other. I thought that would happen a bit with Golden State...but no...it didn't. KD is playing the best defense of his career.
  23. QUOTE (Steve9347 @ Feb 27, 2017 -> 10:46 AM) These are players who, while ineffective as starters, are fantastic bench players to come in and log effective minutes. I do agree that they should serve a solid purpose off the bench (but in many of these guys cases, they are on their last limbs, so what you are hoping for is that they can get themselves up for 10-15 minutes per playoff game where the roles fit). Bogut isn't great, but he can be a solid big body where necessary (that said, I don't see how he helps much against Golden State, for example).
  24. QUOTE (Jordan4life @ Feb 27, 2017 -> 10:12 AM) Then he should've kept his mouth shut and recognized that there was nothing Cleveland was going to be able to do to counter that. No, he did the exact opposite. He went public over and over and disrespected a legend along the way because he wanted more help. He wanted a playmaker. He got just that. He wanted a big after Birdman went down. He got a big. He got one of the best shooters in league history for free. No excuses. Most of those players are on the absolute downside of their careers. Miami isn't just dropping Derrick Williams if they thought he was really good. Could they help in the post-season, absolutely, but the difference between a healthy Cavs team and healthy Warriors team is pretty far apart, imo.
  25. QUOTE (southsider2k5 @ Feb 27, 2017 -> 10:16 AM) There is one writer out there that is throwing fuel on that fire on top of it with a rating of Tatis MUCH higher than anyone else. It will be interesting to see how the kid plays out. It is more then just one writer. I don't define success as being on a top 100 list, I define it more long-term, that said, in the near term, success is having positive reports come out and Tatis has been on the end of multiple positive reports over the past 12 months (not just from Keith Law). Many scouts have had positive things to say about his potential. He shouldn't be anywhere near a top 100 list because he is still very raw, but the tools are very much there to the fact that you could see him turning into a good asset in the long-term. I also was one of the most vocal people at the deadline regarding how bad it was to sell Tatis for Shields.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.