I pulled this from my recap from whitesoxcentral.
"In 6 games this season, Garland has allowed 8 runs before the sixth inning. After the sixth inning, Garland has seen 11 runs pass the plate. However, in those six starts, Garland has pitched 30 innings to the sixth inning. When the sixth inning hits, he's lasted 13.2 innings afterwards. Therefore, Garlands RA (not ERA because not all of the runs calculated are earned) is 7.50 after the fifth inning and 2.40 before the fifth inning."
The math may be off a little, but it is still quite telling. Perhaps Manuel was right all along about this guy?