I personally think Beane is overrated. And I read Moneyball. I just don't take everything I read as gospel. The point that was made about the 3 stud pitchers is a valid one, but he's about to run out of time with those guys. They'll be hitting the arbitration-free agent years soon. Now, will Harden and Blanton be able to step in and fill those slots? That remains to be seen. People used to complain about KW's overseeing of the clubhouse and dugout. Well, Beane's and egotistical control freak based on what Moneyball portrayed him, if you read between the lines. Chad Bradford has been decent to very good over the course of his tenure with the A's, but Olivo has a chance to be the AL starting All-Star catcher for the next 5 years. I'll take that potential over what Bradford has accomplished with Oakland.
For the record, Moneyball was written by Michael Lewis (I think I have his name right) and not Billy Beane.