Now Ryan Wagner is the perfect guy to acquire. He's still young (23), has a lot of talent and potential, still has options left so he could be stashed at Charlotte, and he might come cheap because the Reds seem to be down on him. Acquire him, let him pitch at Charlotte, and he could make a great midseason callup if he succeeds at AAA. He also could be a great addition for next season -- McCarthy will probably be in our rotation, Hermanson will probably be retiring, and Politte will be a free agent.
I don't know much at all about Wagner but it looks like he barely pitched in the minors.
http://www.thebaseballcube.com/players/W/ryan-wagner.shtml
Did the Reds screw up with him? Probably.