JUSTgottaBELIEVE

Why do you keep saying that?

I’d say he’s already there

Just because a team has more talent on paper doesn’t mean it translates to wins on the field. Happens all the time. I just listed 5/10 of the World Series champs in the 2010s. None of those 5 teams were even top 5 in betting odds to win the World Series before the season started. In fact, most of those five teams had very similar preseason odds as the 2005 White Sox. You’re framing the 2005 White Sox as some type of anomaly but they weren’t. Those types of teams win the World Series on a regular basis in the modern era.

Thankfully that all changes today against old friend Brad Keller! Too bad TA is out

Anything short of a World Series title is a failure. But that also means 29 other teams fail every season. Thankfully, we’re only 4.3% of the way finished with this regular season so there’s still a LONG way to go before we find out if this season is a success or if it is a failure for the 2021 Chicago White Sox.

So we’re giving champs more credit for looking good on paper before the season starts? Might as well crown the Dodgers now then. Why even bother playing the games? And define “rare”. Were the 2019 Nationals, 2015 Royals, and 2010/2012/2014 Giants also “rare”? Because, on paper, no one expected them to win the World Series in those seasons. This isn’t the NBA. Unexpected teams win the World Series often.

By “getting away” you mean possibly down 0-2 in the series. Certainly not a great position to be in but many more teams have come back from 0-2 deficits than say 1-3 deficits. That shows just how dominant they were in the playoffs in 2005 that you have to point to the middle of game 2 of a 7 game series as their most vulnerable position.

Cubs winning the World Series in 2016 was an anomaly. How many teams trailing 3-1 in the World Series have won it? They had no business winning it at that point but baseball is full of anomalies. The 2005 White Sox were about the surest thing you can find start to finish in baseball. First place all season long and never faced a win or go home game in the playoffs (not even close to one). That’s called dominance over 162 + 12 games.

Now you’re comparing the 83 win Cardinals to the 2005 White Sox? Lol. Ok, think we’re done here.

Doesn’t mean the 2005 team wasn’t great. Can’t argue with the results. Best regular season record in the AL and tied for the best postseason run in modern playoff format history.

No, I don’t know it. The White Sox were the best team in baseball that year. They absolutely deserved to win the World Series.

Every team that wins a World Series requires some luck along the way. They won 99 games (best record in AL, 1 win shy of best in MLB) and then went 11-1 in the playoffs. Doesn’t seem lucky to me, seems dominant.

They were 6-7 in Oakland, Anaheim, and Seattle during the 2005 regular season. 99 wins and a world championship later, I’d say that was a truly great team.

Have you seen the Indians lineup this year?

They’re much better than the Cubs, not saying much I know https://mobile.twitter.com/MLBRandomStats/status/1379875643786199041

At least Hendriks looks good

Before the season started I figured 3-4 on this trip. They always struggle on the west coast. The fact that they played about as bad as they could possibly play and still won 3/7 out there is a small success in my book.

.581 is the Cubs apparently, not the Mariners

.581?!? Lol, it’s like they’re putting out a lineup full of pitchers hitting.

Both Kopech and Crochet could very well post 2.5-3.0 fWAR this season if they throw between 80-100 innings, and in high leverage situations no less. That’s extremely valuable production for two guys that are still rookies. I’d love their current roles to carry over into this year’s playoffs, where these high leverage relief roles become even more important.

So is this going to be another season in which the Sox backup catcher outproduces Grandal? Lol

It’s almost like people think it’s a 60 game season again. 162 games is a a marathon. Tough series but they were in every game despite shitty defense, lack of timely hitting, and the starters not going deep in games. As long as the team stays relatively healthy from here, they’ll be fine.

SSS last season or least we better hope it was

Did I say that? Does it matter that Robert is still flailing at pitches low and away? Does it matter that Vaughn will likely go through growing pains this year? Does it matter that Cease will likely have another volatile season? I’m not sure what your point is. When your team is built largely around young, still developing players, you live with the good and the bad and hope they improve. If they don’t, this team is headed for another early playoff exit anyway.

Not sure what you’re getting at but most shortstops that move to second base perform much better there. Shortstop and second base are more similar than shortstop and third base. My point is some guys struggle initially adjusting to the big leagues but are capable of making improvements in short order. I’m not making any broad generalizations about Madrigal’s defense after 33 games.