So you have to be the Rays, A’s or Guardians…or Dodgers/Mets on top of the scale.
But that doesn’t exactly explain Jose Ramirez, Mike Trout, Machado or Buxton…to name just a few who are performing on long extensions. Alvarez, Harper, Goldschmidt, JD Martinez, Betts, George Springer.
Devers is one of the few on a one year deal, like Judge and Trea Turner whose extension is ending. Contreras another one expiring, and at the top of the TDL want list for many teams.
Extension are perfectly fine for the true superstars, just not the next couple of tiers down.