Everything posted by caulfield12
-
How Should Rick Hahn Fix The White Sox
QUOTE (greg775 @ Oct 3, 2013 -> 12:16 PM) Well the Sox better get some new bodies somewhere. Maybe get some journeymen like the Indians did and hope they pan out. Sox are going to have to pay for somebody unless they refuse to sign guys to big contracts after the Dunn/Rios fiascos. I wouldn't consider Michael Bourn to be a journeyman. Swisher was somewhere in between....he's in his early 30's now but had some decent seasons in NY, kind of like Granderson's status now. Declining, but a "name" player who will get a lot more money than he's actually worth from someone.
-
How Should Rick Hahn Fix The White Sox
QUOTE (witesoxfan @ Oct 3, 2013 -> 07:33 AM) If you look at the 2005-2006 and 2008-2009 offseasons, you'd find that most people thought the Sox would go on sustained periods of success. It's a fickle game. Adding Javy (the now questionable 6 starters strategy, with McCarthy eventually traded for Danks) and adding Viciedo (who seemed like he was pretty close to being a legit contributor at 3B in light of the ending of Crede's career and Uribe filling in to end 2008) were pretty logical moves. The Thome for Rowand one, in particular...perfect situation where we got back a ton of cash and ended up with a hitter not so far off his prime for most of the time he was with us. But Mackowiak...? Wish we could redo that one.
-
How Should Rick Hahn Fix The White Sox
If you look at the 2004-2005 and 2007-2008 offseasons, you'd find perhaps a majority of Sox fans thinking those teams were 3-5 years from contending for another division crown.
-
How Should Rick Hahn Fix The White Sox
QUOTE (greg775 @ Oct 2, 2013 -> 01:09 PM) It's pretty simple: Sign Abreu and McCann or AJP; McCann long term; AJ one year if can't get McCann. Then trade Hector and Beckham for a third baseman. Let Semien play second. Now you then sign Granderson or Choo while trading DeAza for whatever you can get for him. You now have better hitters in the lineup than this year: McCann, Grandy, Abreu, Semien and A. Garcia. That's a pretty fricking good upgrade and IT CAN BE ACCOMPLISHED. Granderson's not an everyday CF and won't stand up well against LHP...strikes out too much, we already have a cheaper version in DeAza. Choo will be way overpriced based on this year's results in the NL, and then he forces either himself or A. Garcia into CF, which is a big no-no. You might as well make it Hector Santiago and a bag of baseballs....at least Santiago's going to get you something back. I just worry when he's away from the White Sox he will come into his own, like Liriano has with the Pirates this season going with mostly 2 seam sinking fastballs and a much more strategic defensive positioning strategy than the White Sox currently possess. No to AJ....too late. His time has come and gone. Abreu, you better do your due diligence...and McCann makes sense if you are able to add 2-3 players together, but that's almost impossible to imagine the White Sox doing, which is committing to $100-150 million in new FA contracts for McCann, Abreu and one more player (Choo and Ellsbury are going to be too expensive). The problem is that adding just one of those three (catcher/1B/OF) doesn't really put us in a position to compete. So I think you have to sign two free agents and deal Santiago/Quintana for the highest possible return....or tread water and keep waiting for the right pieces to emerge at the right prices (like Dye or Thome, as mentioned earlier).
-
2016 Post-All Star Break White Sox
Once again, people are remembering too much what Markakis has done against the White Sox. He's a SOLID player, at least he was, but you want nothing to do with his declining years at over the top prices when he was never all that great to begin with.
-
2016 Post-All Star Break White Sox
Micah Johnson is miles away from being a projected major league starter. Biggest problem, even moreso than giving Rasmus that contract, is signing an over the hill one dimensional player in Markakis. If you took away his stats against us, he wouldn't be worth $6 million per year in his declining 30's.
-
One move...
I can just see it now...our big off-season headline acquisition is Sean Rodriguez.
-
Government Shutdown on the clock thread
QUOTE (Alpha Dog @ Oct 2, 2013 -> 11:34 AM) How about it ends with the government stop spending money it doesn't have? That would be a good place for it end up. Like when Bill Clinton was running budget surpluses three consecutive years? What happened after that?
-
Hahn:Ventura will return in 2014
QUOTE (southsider2k5 @ Oct 2, 2013 -> 11:31 AM) Health and contract are huge things. Since 2009 Reyes has missed 262 games, including 69 this year. Ramirez has missed 58 total. Not only are you going to be paying an outrageous amount for Reyes, you will also being looking for another SS on average 50+ games a year. actually I added another years worth of games to Ramirez. He has missed only 32 over the last five years. The other 26 were from 2008. Was he injured then? I think he was just sitting on the bench for most of the first two months of 2008.
-
How Should Rick Hahn Fix The White Sox
Something like what the Indians have done is closer to what the Sox need. They missed with Reynolds, let's called it a toss-up whether Swisher has helped but Bourn helped change the overall complexion of that line-up. (Sort of what they tried to do with Juan Pierre, but not 5 years too late). It still all comes down to pitching. Unfortunately, we don't have a Jason Kipnis or bat like Carlos Santana on our roster or minor league depth chart. (Also taking into consideration they lost arguably their best everyday player in Choo, although quite a few would have picked Kipnis over Choo even after last season).
-
Hahn:Ventura will return in 2014
QUOTE (Jake @ Oct 2, 2013 -> 11:18 AM) Reyes is a better player than Alexei, but Reyes is a huge wildcard with injuries. If I had no shortstop, I might take that gamble...but I have a decent one and no immediate need to dump him and not much to gain from a modest increase in production at SS. And even the modest belief that Semien could give you league average production at that position, possibly as early as 2015 or 2016. So why not think about using the Ramirez money and reallocating it elsewhere and getting a B or B/C (two in a package) prospect? But taking on guys like Reyes or Upton for a team in the position where the White Sox are is dubious business. Even if we could have Buehrle back at half of his remaining contract value, it wouldn't make any sense for the Sox.
-
Hahn:Ventura will return in 2014
QUOTE (Dick Allen @ Oct 1, 2013 -> 06:54 PM) Let alone why would a team give up any reasonable prospect for BJUpton and a $30 million committment? He was Adam Dunn 2011 bad in 2013. I wouldn't trade Dunn for Upton. $15 million vs. $60 million. I think my idea at the beginning of the year was Dunn for Upton and $30 million.
-
Hahn:Ventura will return in 2014
Bad contract (Dunn) for bad contract (Upton) might have been feasible... But how many prospects could you argue were worth $30 million at age 18 or 19? Maybe Harper or Griffey, Jr.?
-
Wild Card Games thread
Where was this version of Liriano with Cooper last year? Seems the move to the 2 seam sinking fastball....in conjunction with infield defense/positioning/shifts, has worked wonders with his results.
-
Hahn:Ventura will return in 2014
Scary. This Upton for salary relief or Upton for Dunn (balancing salary relief) was one of my many ideas at the beginning of the season before I gave up. Now Marty's continuing to push it?
-
Government Shutdown on the clock thread
China and India are going to breeze past the US. We're making it FAR FAR too easy. Sad to watch from abroad...where the actual rubber is hitting the road (and dams/railways/subways/skyscrapers, massive construction and infrastructure projects from China to India and stretching into Africa). Wouldn't be surprised to see Indonesia's 240 million start to catch up soon, either. So it will be BRICS with the I "squared" for India and Indonesia. And the worst part of it is the senselessness and preventability of this whole thing. It's like we refuse to act until there's a REAL crisis and keep punting the ball (and crossbars) down the road to some future "point of no return" line.
-
2014 Outfield
To quote someone else here...."Alejandro DeAza will not be a part of the next White Sox playoff team." Viciedo's young and his upside is still pretty high...enough that he deserves all of next season. As far as Garcia goes, he's probably better suited for RF. Honestly, they need to go out and get a much better version of DeAza, someone who's a real/natural CFer and probably leadoff guy...they could have taken a shot at Michael Bourn, and they probably won't get very far with Ellsbury. FWIW, they're more than Jacoby away from having a productive offense. They would need at least two more pieces to legitimately be in contention. Adding Granderson doesn't really seem to be the ideal solution as he's not a leadoff guy anymore, questionable defense/arm and his platoon splits. Local hero/Chicago product angle aside, that's not going to put any butts in the seats if the team is struggling again going into early May. Choo isn't a natural CFer and will be too expensive to purchase based on his 2013 production.
-
2013 Films Thread
The Metallica 3D movie was pretty good.... Going to see RUSH tomorrow. Rush...one of the best couple of movies of the last six months, and a probable Oscar candidate if it can pick up enough steam. Gravity looks like it will definitely join Rush as Top 10 movies for 2013.
-
Hahn speaks on '14
“There’s no pressure whatsoever to hire a big-name manager,” Epstein said. “We want to hire the right manager. We’re at a critical point in our building process where our very best prospects are soon going to be young big-league players. “It’s absolutely imperative that we create the best environment possible for young players to come up here, continue to learn, continue to develop and thrive at the big-league level – and win, ultimately.” Winning has been an afterthought at the big-league level, but the Cubs feel like elite prospects Javier Baez and Kris Bryant will keep moving fast through the system. As Starlin Castro, Anthony Rizzo and Darwin Barney struggled to make adjustments this season, Sveum, the hitting coaches and the front office got their wires crossed. “We need to hire a manager and ultimately hire a staff that presents a unified message to young players,” Epstein said, “because the big leagues are hard enough. It’s confusing enough. We need to help them along that way and not get in their way at times.” Epstein swung and missed on his first managerial hire here. One hundred and ninety-seven losses later, the Cubs have collected dozens of interesting prospects. But inevitably there will be questions about the guys picking the players, whether it’s investing $100 million in Castro and Rizzo or giving Edwin Jackson $52 million or trading for and re-signing Ian Stewart. lots of lessons to be taken away from the Sveum experience for the Cubs... what about the Ventura/Bell/Hahn experience for the White Sox? http://chicago.cubs.mlb.com/news/article/c...p;vkey=news_chc
-
Hahn speaks on '14
QUOTE (GreatScott82 @ Sep 30, 2013 -> 09:00 PM) After reading this article, it sounds as if Hahn plans on spending big this winter. Upgrade the catcher position? YES please. How about 3b, CF and a 1B replacement for Pauly as well? How about finding a new home for Dunn? How about putting together a package involving Ramirez in attempt to upgrade the SS position? Do we stick it out with Viciedo out in LF? SOOOOO many questions need to be answered... there are ALOT of holes on this roster. IMO the only safe starting position players are Beckham 2b and Avi Garcia RF. Everything else can change at this point. I wish you well Hahn... time to get creative. Beckham was a huge part of the problem, too. If you're cleaning house, Viciedo is "owed" at least one more year if you believe that Beckham's earned the starting role for 2014, especially with Semien lurking. There is nobody in our minor league system pushing Viciedo at LF or 1B.
-
Puig-Mania Thread
http://espn.go.com/blog/new-york/mets/post...-jersey-sellers Puig #3 jersey amongst 2nd half sales, Mo Rivera #1 and Matt Harvey #2 Cespedes was in Top 10 still/somehow, Ryu from the Dodgers must be selling a ton among Dodgers/Korean fans
-
Ventura wants to stay
QUOTE (Chicago White Sox @ Sep 25, 2013 -> 06:12 PM) I don't get the not working on fundamentals in spring training argument. Our defense has been bad all year, that would be one hell of a spring training carry over effect to explain the majority of the change in fielding percentage between 2012 & 2013. Maybe not accountable for all going in the "tank" defensively. Flowers regressed. Viciedo, too. Ramirez and Beckham weren't as good as in the past, particularly Alexei. DeAza continues to be an enigma. Rios wasn't as sharp as well with fundamentals, hitting cut-off men, etc. We all know Dunn/Konerko and their limitations. About the only pleasant surprise was Conor, who was merely decent/adequate. Phegley was as promised. Keppinger was never very good in the first place, was overexposed and his lack of ability to D up contributed to problems that snowballed all over the infield IMO.
-
2013 Films Thread
2 Guns was pretty darned entertaining.
-
2013 White Sox Grades
QUOTE (fathom @ Sep 25, 2013 -> 04:09 PM) Since it seems unlikely anything could happen this week that would significantly change these grades, here it is: C. Sale-A J. Crain-A J. Quintana- A- H. Santiago- B+ J. Peavy- B M. Lindstrom- B A. Garcia- B A. Rios- B A. Reed- B- M. Thornton- B- A. Ramirez- B- N. Jones- C+ C. Gillaspie- C+ A. De Aza- C+ D. Viciedo- C G. Beckham- C A. Rienzo- C A. Dunn- C D. Veal- C- J. Keppinger- D J. Phegley- D T. Flowers- D P. Konerko- D D. Axelrod- D R. Ventura- D D. Cooper- B- J. Manto- D Too hard on Gillaspie, too easy on Veal... Maybe Viciedo can be a C+ considering he was fighting injuries for part of the way, but then does that excuse Konerko? Not really. What about your impression of Leury Garcia so far?
-
Favorite non-star White Sox players
QUOTE (ptatc @ Sep 25, 2013 -> 03:09 PM) Ivan Calderon, Dave Gallagher and SALOME BAROJAS!!!!!! You just jinxed Dave Gallagher. He's not dead yet, is he? Or maybe I was thinking of Joe DeSa or one of the other relievers of that time period, Ernesto Escarrega or something was his name?