Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Soxtalk.com

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

caulfield12

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by caulfield12

  1. There's more than one member? How many followers does Rongey have at twitter these days?
  2. QUOTE (Marty34 @ Aug 23, 2011 -> 09:08 AM) Yesterday you had problems with math. Today it's names. What will tomorrow bring? Well, not exactly. Your mathematics left our Frasor, Humber, Beckham and about 7 more first and second year players who will total around $8-12 million dollars. That's two of your Matt Thorntons (or one Matt Thornton, one Alexei Ramirez) you're trying to dump, so I wouldn't call it an insignificant amount. And there's still no "proof" yet about the 2 million in attendance subsidy. That would be quite the story....the State of Illinois renegotiating TWICE in order to give more public monies and free rent to billionaire baseball owners when the majority of the state is suffering from an intransigent recession. I'm not understanding why they would agree to raise the amount from 1.2 million to 1.5 million (already renegotiated once) and then all the way to 2 million. It wouldn't make any economic sense for the State of lllinois to buy 200-300,000 White Sox tickets. Or what? The White Sox would threaten to leave again? What leverage do the White Sox actually have to extract any more concessions?
  3. Knowing the way things have gone this season....they'd finally bench Dunn, ruining him forever (according to Rongey) and then Thome would go all Manny Ramirez 2010 on the White Sox.
  4. QUOTE (Steve9347 @ Aug 23, 2011 -> 07:30 AM) The title of this thread makes me want to self-mutilate. Would you feel less in a mood for self-immolation if it was "performing like Michael Morse?"
  5. Weren't we tied with the Indians as of last night? Who would be awarded the claim first? Did we have the same exact records, 63-63? Or was one team percentage points ahead or behind? With Hafner on the DL, the Indians definitely make some sense for the short-term.
  6. Here we go again, Marty/Joe. Yesterday, Ramirez...today, Matt Thornton. Never heard any of the rumors of who was actually offered for Matty. Who were they, albeit "rumors"?
  7. JD Drew Ortiz off and on for last 3-4 years Dice K Varitek Crawford The difference is that the Red Sox have that extra cushion and the minor league system to adsorb all those bad contracts, especially Lackey and Dice-K. And we've been able to cover the pitching issues with Peavy, more or less. The problem is we don't have Pedroia, Youkilis, Ortiz, Ellsbury and Adrian Gonzalez (who we could have had for Beckham). Instead we have Morel, Dunn, Rios, Beckham at those positions.
  8. www.ranyonroyals.com (Why the Frenchy deal for Royals makes less sense since Cain is blocked now and Cabrera shouldn't be in CF) Cain and Francoeur both bat right-handed, while Cabrera is a switch-hitter. If the Royals commit to Cain in center field and trade Cabrera, the Royals will have six right-handed bats in the lineup almost every day next year, with little hope that the ratio will balance out in the near future. (Incidentally, this is one of the main reasons why I think the Royals would be foolish to let go of switch-hitting Brayan Pena as their backup catcher.) Francoeur is the only one of the three who could neither play good defense in center field nor bat from the left side. The obvious solution for the Royals was to promote Cain, move Cabrera to right field (or possibly to left field, with Gordon switching corners), and to wave Francoeur good-bye. That would have upgraded their outfield defense while maintaining the platoon advantage in at least four spots in the lineup. By re-signing Francoeur, the Royals put themselves in a difficult decision. Maybe they are able to trade Cain for a starting pitcher, in which case they’re stuck with a bad defender in a crucial up-the-middle position. Maybe they can turn Cabrera into prospects, in which case they’re going to be eaten alive by tough right-handed pitching. But the Royals have created a situation where, no matter which way they go, they’ve left the 2012 team with a significant tactical weakness. Maybe the Royals get really creative here, and trade both Cain and Cabrera in order to open a spot for Jarrod Dyson (which honestly isn’t as crazy as it sounds). Or maybe they trade Butler and DH Cabrera (which is as crazy as it sounds, as I don’t think the Royals can get fair value for Butler). But as it stands now, bringing back Francoeur is the first domino in a chain reaction that, whichever way it goes, doesn’t end well for the Royals. I hope I’m wrong. I hope that, between now and Opening Day, the Royals come up with an outfield arrangement which maximizes their chances of winning in 2012. The problem is that they already had such an arrangement at their fingertips, and let it go rather than relinquish their precious Francoeur. Re-signing Frenchy certainly isn’t a crippling move along the lines of the Jose Guillen contract; it doesn’t clearly make the Royals worse like the Mike Jacobs trade did. But the Royals spent a fair amount of money on a player who doesn’t have a long track record of success, and who the Royals didn’t really need in the first place. There were better ways to spend that money. Love may be blind, but it ain’t cheap. If Dayton Moore’s love is requited, this contract won’t hurt the Royals. Unfortunately, “not hurting the Royals” is about the best we can hope for.
  9. Except it makes KW and Ozzie look look "double idiots" for letting Thome go to the Twins in the first place after 2009, then signing Dunn for 2011 simply because Kotsay/Jones platoon was never a feasible long-term solution but rather a band-aid...I can't imagine Williams doing it solely for ego reasons. And then some of the comments Thome has made and a little back and forth sniping, mostly on the Sox part. The homer off Thornton last year didn't help matters (unless you like to see KW and Ozzie being made to look like idiots). Still, it will be interesting to see if other teams ahead in the pecking order would take him or let him get to the Indians (mostly for sentimental reasons) or eventually the Phils. Definitely not a monetary issue for most clubs that are legitimately interested in him.
  10. Who's more likely to make it as a 4th/5th outfielder...Short or Martinez?
  11. Maybe he was thinking of LEIF Garrett instead? It would be yet more fun if someone started a "I remember Katie Upton or Mrs. Teahen" one and they posted a response. Or Mark Teahen's dogs. Or Oney.
  12. If Hahn's greatest strength is negotiations....and Danks leaving is basically already a foregone conclusion...that's not the most helpful trait. Other than Mark Buehrle this offseason, we might be 2-3 years from ever having another big free agent signing with the White Sox after the Dunn/Rios/Peavy debacle. Ramirez already signed his extension. That's done. We have Floyd for two more years. And we don't allocate a lot of money for draft picks, so this is all a bit scary, if scouting is his biggest weakness and we arguably have one of the weakest scouting systems in the game already. That doesn't bode well at all for trades maximizing the value of Danks/Floyd, Quentin, Thornton, Ramirez and possibly Frasor or Crain.
  13. He'd be, at best, league average if he played there everyday. Next to Kubel and Delmon Young, he looks decent comparatively. They've moved him all over the place the last couple of years. Everywhere but SS, I think, and C...maybe not CF either. As pointed out above, arm strength is his biggest asset.
  14. Gilmore Jose Martinez Kuhn Phegley Santos Rodriguez Rienzo Reed Infante Mitchell Saladino Silverio You'd have to think that might be at least 4-5 of their picks, from a list similar to that. If Walker had absolutely torn apart A ball, they might have considered pushing him, but absolutely no way now.
  15. Really impressed the Indians have been fighting to the last moment...claimed Harden on waivers but couldn't work out a deal with Beane. Wonder what happened since the Red Sox deal for him blew up over his assorted health issues?
  16. I wouldn't sign Greg, Ozzie and Juan Pierre to the Juan Pierre Dodgers' deal. Joking Greg. Went to the Royals/Red Sox game in KC Thursday night, btw. Really impressed with all the changes in the outfield bleachers and concourses. Wish they would bury those Tide/Bounce detergent signs around the entrances in the upper deck, though, makes it look like a cheesy minor league stadium in those sections.
  17. It's very well possible this team could play much better if they did eat 75% of Rios' contract. Unfortunately, that will never happen. But there's no way to put a dollar value on getting a "benched" or sulking Rios out of that clubhouse. And DeAza has definitely been producing as well or better than anyone expected.
  18. Just wait for the AL to make its first adjustment to him. See Gordon Beckham (late 2009/early 2010). Then we'll see how he does combatting their book against him.
  19. QUOTE (Rowand44 @ Aug 22, 2011 -> 04:04 PM) Remember Jeff Leifer? He really seemed like one of the biggest pricks I've ever met to wear a White Sox uniform. Everyone says the same about Rauch, but he was really cool to the fans at 2001 Spring Training.
  20. QUOTE (southsider2k5 @ Aug 22, 2011 -> 03:32 PM) The title of this thread reminds me of a Caulfield style post. Then I would make it "Lillibridge Performing Like A Rock Star (Party Like It's LilliBOMB's Birthday)"
  21. Greg, you're crazy. He would get $40-60 million more on the open market, and probably an additional year.
  22. Except Floyd's value with team-friendly contracts for 2 years might even be more valuable than Danks for just one. You could make arguments either way. There are just too many question marks with Sale, Humber, Peavy and Stewart to do that if you really want to compete for the AL Central in 2012.
  23. But if you want to ensure future Cubs' "fan faith" (and they definitely showed up in droves at Wrigley this past week...and 132,000 in DET).....then you need a big-name manager and GM for that job.
  24. QUOTE (Balta1701 @ Aug 22, 2011 -> 01:57 PM) Caulfireld, almost everyone you mention there except Frasor is a minimum contract guy. He gets himself to legitimately $95 million if he signs buehrle but trades away the 4 he wants to move. But aren't Beckham and Humber different situations? Free Agent: 2012 / Unrestricted....that's not right for Humber, but what exactly will happen? He will have 2+ years of service, they can't just offer him what amounts to a minimum contract after his 2011 season, can they? Only $750,000? Is Gordon eligible for salary arbitration for 2012?
  25. QUOTE (Balta1701 @ Aug 22, 2011 -> 01:54 PM) Actually his numbers for 2011 are pretty close, because he's subtracted Quentin, Danks, Ramirez, and Thornton, and that's nearly $30 million between them. He's missing about $5-7 million from minimum contract guys and the $3.5 mil for Frasor. Yeah, I figured it out (see above). Can the White Sox decline Frasor's option and still offer arbitration? Not saying they would do that, but could they? Or is it all or nothing, accept or decline the $3.75 million club option. He stays or becomes a FA? He's Type B? But I still don't see how they sell letting Danks and Ramirez go to the fanbase and claiming to be "All In" still... They can't. Impossible. Even if KW/Hahn pulled off a Sizemore/Lee/Phillips haul, it wouldn't be until 2013-2014 that some of the fans started to come back on board.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.