1. Yes I am/was
2. So...? If he isn't good you don't force him into action because of his draft selection and age.
3. Of course but if they stink, I don't. Collins has been awful, granted a small sample size. If their goal is to win I'm not sure how him playing 5 nights a week over an All Star makes sense. If Collins was "can't miss" he would've went higher than 10. Every guy picked in really the first 2 rounds of every MLB draft were great players their whole lives. That doesn't mean they deserve MLB playing time. Look, I had high hopes for Collins too but he's been bad and this would've been the year for him to play a lot, but the FO and staff's decision to not make it a priority is telling.
BTW, Rutherford has shown next to no power and that stuff doesn't fly for a corner OF'er. Furthermore Rutherford was obtained for what turned out to be nothing. It's not like he was a main piece for Sale or something.