May 4, 200520 yr Carl Everett B+ Paul Konerko C- Ross Gload C- Willie Harris B Tadahito Iguchi B+ Juan Uribe B- Joe Crede B A.J. Pierzinski C+ Chris widger C+ Scott Podsednik C+ Aaron Rowand D Jermaine Dye F Timo Perez D- Pablo Ozuna C Mark Buerhle A Freddy Garcia A Jose Contreras A- Orlando Hernandez A- Jon Garland A+ Cliff Polite B+ Neal Cotts B Luis Vizcaino C Damaso Marte B- Dustin Hermanson A Shingo Takatsu D (post your own grades) CODE Carl Everett Paul Konerko Ross Gload Willie Harris Tadahito Iguchi Juan Uribe Joe Crede A.J. Pierzinski Chris widger Scott Podsednik Aaron Rowand Jermaine Dye Timo Perez Pablo Ozuna Mark Buerhle Freddy Garcia Jose Contreras Orlando Hernandez Jon Garland Cliff Polite Neal Cotts Luis Vizcaino Damaso Marte Dustin Hermanson Shingo Takatsu Edited May 4, 200520 yr by rangercal
May 4, 200520 yr QUOTE(rangercal @ May 4, 2005 -> 11:04 AM) Carl Everett B+ Paul Konerko C- Ross Gload C- Willie Harris B Tadahito Iguchi B+ Juan Uribe B- Joe Crede B A.J. Pierzinski C+ Chris widger C+ Scott Podsednik C+ Aaron Rowand D Jermaine Dye F Timo Perez D- Pablo Ozuna C Mark Buerhle A Freddy Garcia A Jose Contreras A- Orlando Hernandez A- Jon Garland A+ Cliff Polite B+ Neal Cotts B Luis Vizcaino C Damaso Marte B- Dustin Hermanson A Shingo Takatsu D marte deserves a better grade than cotts
May 4, 200520 yr Author QUOTE(daa84 @ May 4, 2005 -> 11:08 AM) marte deserves a better grade than cotts Based on what I seen and I watched every game. Marte can do better.
May 4, 200520 yr QUOTE(rangercal @ May 4, 2005 -> 12:10 PM) Based on what I seen and I watched every game. Marte can do better. how's konerko get a C- and rowand get a D? They both should have D or D-.
May 4, 200520 yr Author QUOTE(TheBlackSox8 @ May 4, 2005 -> 11:11 AM) how's konerko get a C- and rowand get a D? They both should have D or D-. IF you take out the first 10 days of the year kong would get a F imo. The first 10 days He was a god on this board. It balances out to a c- IMO . He is pushing a D though.
May 4, 200520 yr QUOTE(rangercal @ May 4, 2005 -> 12:04 PM) Mark Buerhle A Buehrle doesn't deserve an A.
May 4, 200520 yr Author QUOTE(whitesoxfan99 @ May 4, 2005 -> 11:15 AM) Buehrle doesn't deserve an A. copy and paste and make your own grades. In my grades he gets an A.
May 4, 200520 yr QUOTE(rangercal @ May 4, 2005 -> 12:14 PM) IF you take out the first 10 days of the year kong would get a F imo. The first 10 days He was a god on this board. It balances out to a c- IMO . He is pushing a D though. well if you're going on a grade for now...then Kong would be F or D-, and Rowand would be D or D+. But i see that your grades are for total season..
May 4, 200520 yr Author lol I did not post my grades to get critiqued like this. Guys post your own personal grades.
May 4, 200520 yr Author QUOTE(TheBlackSox8 @ May 4, 2005 -> 11:18 AM) well if you're going on a grade for now...then Kong would be F or D-, and Rowand would be D or D+. But i see that your grades are for total season.. No, paul has won us a few games when he was hot. He is close to a D. Overall, I think he has not hurt us much as you may think.
May 4, 200520 yr QUOTE(rangercal @ May 4, 2005 -> 12:18 PM) lol I did not post my grades to get critiqued like this. Guys post your own personal grades. You've been here long enough to know how opinion's get picked apart. Suck it up..
May 4, 200520 yr Too many players to grade, so I'll just do the best and worst: Hermanson A+ Iguchi A+ Garland A+ Dye D- Konerko D
May 4, 200520 yr Author QUOTE(Steff @ May 4, 2005 -> 11:25 AM) You've been here long enough to know how opinion's get picked apart. Suck it up.. LOL I didnt think I was going to get off that easy
May 4, 200520 yr QUOTE(rangercal @ May 4, 2005 -> 12:18 PM) lol I did not post my grades to get critiqued like this. Guys post your own personal grades. No, this is more fun...your grades suck.
May 4, 200520 yr QUOTE(rangercal @ May 4, 2005 -> 12:26 PM) LOL I didnt think I was going to get off that easy I got an Anger Management book as a gift a few weeks ago..
May 4, 200520 yr Author QUOTE(tonyho7476 @ May 4, 2005 -> 11:26 AM) No, this is more fun...your grades suck. yeah I think I set myself up for this
May 4, 200520 yr Author QUOTE(Steff @ May 4, 2005 -> 11:27 AM) I got an Anger Management book as a gift a few weeks ago.. A must read for any active poster at soxtalk
May 4, 200520 yr Here goes nothing! Carl Everett A Paul Konerko C- Ross Gload C Willie Harris B Tadahito Iguchi A+ Juan Uribe B Joe Crede B- A.J. Pierzinski C- Chris widger B Scott Podsednik B- Aaron Rowand C- Jermaine Dye E Timo Perez D Pablo Ozuna C Mark Buerhle B Freddy Garcia B+ Jose Contreras B- Orlando Hernandez A- Jon Garland A+ Cliff Polite B Neal Cotts C Luis Vizcaino C Damaso Marte B Dustin Hermanson A- Shingo Takatsu C-
May 4, 200520 yr I'll post my own grades Ranger. I ain't afraid The A's Jose Contreras Jon Garland Carl Everett Tadahito Iguchi Dustin Hermanson Cliff Politte Joe Crede (borderline to a B ) Chris Widger AJ Pierzynski The B's Willie Harris (should be an incomplete IMO) Damaso Marte Luis Vizcaino Neal Cotts Orlando Hernadez Freddy Garcia Scott Podsednik The C's Mark Buehrle Juan Uribe Pablo Ozuna The D's Ross Gload (could be an incomplete also) Paul Konerko Aaron Rowand Shingo Takatsu The F's Jermaine Dye Timo Perez
May 4, 200520 yr QUOTE(Steff @ May 4, 2005 -> 12:27 PM) I got an Anger Management book as a gift a few weeks ago.. She obviously hasn't read it yet...
May 4, 200520 yr QUOTE(southsider2k5 @ May 4, 2005 -> 11:40 AM) I'll post my own grades Ranger. I ain't afraid The A's Jose Contreras Jon Garland Carl Everett Tadahito Iguchi Dustin Hermanson Cliff Politte Joe Crede (borderline to a B) Chris Widger AJ Pierzynski The B's Willie Harris (should be an incomplete IMO) Damaso Marte Luis Vizcaino Neal Cotts Orlando Hernadez Freddy Garcia Scott Podsednik The C's Mark Buehrle Juan Uribe Pablo Ozuna The D's Ross Gload (could be an incomplete also) Paul Konerko Aaron Rowand Shingo Takatsu The F's Jermaine Dye Timo Perez Shingo Takatsu D Shingo has double D's eh? Edited May 4, 200520 yr by EvilJester99
May 4, 200520 yr Carl Everett B+ Paul Konerko D+ Ross Gload (Ive got nothing here) Willie Harris B Tadahito Iguchi B+ Juan Uribe B- Joe Crede B A.J. Pierzinski C+ Chris widger B+ Scott Podsednik B- Aaron Rowand C Jermaine Dye F Timo Perez D+ Pablo Ozuna C Mark Buerhle B+ Freddy Garcia A Jose Contreras A Orlando Hernandez A Jon Garland A+ Cliff Polite A Neal Cotts C+ Luis Vizcaino B (not gonna penalize him for the Clev. game) Damaso Marte B+ Dustin Hermanson A Shingo Takatsu D+ (better as of late)
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.