The Wall by Roger Waters was the best concert Ive ever been too. The Wall was one of my least favorite Pink Floyd albums, but after seeing it live I think Comfortably Numb may be one of my favorites. The only bad part was that it just wasnt the same without Gilmour playing the guitar. Generally my favorite album was Animals, with Three Pigs being normally my favorite song.

Pink Floyd isnt for everyone though.

This.

Very interesting 'bracket' here. I agree with a good bit of it, but...U2 as a 1 over The Who, man I don't know.

 

And just me, but the Eagles are fairly overrated. I really don't care for them at all. Everything I hear from them sounds the same.

 

Eagles at a 2, and Queen way down at a 5? Uh, no.

No one has mentioned GNR a #3 while Metallica is a #4??? I mean Use Your Illusion did rock, but the Black Album & Metallica's longevity easily deserve a higher seed.

No one has mentioned GNR a #3 while Metallica is a #4??? I mean Use Your Illusion did rock, but the Black Album & Metallica's longevity easily deserve a higher seed.

 

Coma >>>>>>>>>> Metallica's entire catalog.

Coma >>>>>>>>>> Metallica's entire catalog.

Get the hell out of here with that!

 

I've never even heard of Coma; and I doubt that very many people have.

 

The first three albums by Metallica are what every thrash metal band looks to achieve.

 

I'd say that even Justice... and the Black album are good as well.

Get the hell out of here with that!

 

I've never even heard of Coma; and I doubt that very many people have.

 

The first three albums by Metallica are what every thrash metal band looks to achieve.

 

I'd say that even Justice... and the Black album are good as well.

 

Yeah, Metallica should be a 1.. its not even close

Get the hell out of here with that!

 

I've never even heard of Coma; and I doubt that very many people have.

 

The first three albums by Metallica are what every thrash metal band looks to achieve.

 

I'd say that even Justice... and the Black album are good as well.

 

Coma is GNR's longest song and on UYI I. It's also the song that got me through some hard times, so its's my favorite, so I'm biased.

 

As for Metallica, I rank their albums like this:

 

...AJFA: Not a bad song, One is the weakest on the album, which says a lot.

MOP: Also really good, Hammet got to showcase his writing ability here.

RTL: Still really good.

KEA: Really raw, but lots of good in here, especially Four Horsemen (Sorry Mustaine)

Black Album: A few bits are ok.

Death Magnetic: See Black Album.

Everything else drags Metallica down.

Coma is GNR's longest song and on UYI I. It's also the song that got me through some hard times, so its's my favorite, so I'm biased.

 

As for Metallica, I rank their albums like this:

 

...AJFA: Not a bad song, One is the weakest on the album, which says a lot.

MOP: Also really good, Hammet got to showcase his writing ability here.

RTL: Still really good.

KEA: Really raw, but lots of good in here, especially Four Horsemen (Sorry Mustaine)

Black Album: A few bits are ok.

Death Magnetic: See Black Album.

Everything else drags Metallica down.

I agree. I thought that you were talking about the Polish band named "Coma."

 

That's why you got the stick.

I agree. I thought that you were talking about the Polish band named "Coma."

 

That's why you got the stick.

 

Nope, this.

 

As far as the seeds what would a March Madness spoof be without a few upsets? And it has been a while since he was on the radio here, but doesn't he talk about "Old Guy R&R"?

I mean Use Your Illusion did rock.

Appetite for Destruction was way better. G&R - terrible in concert.

Metallica isnt a 1 seed.

 

And as long as they dont lose to Rush, they should get a chance to face Led Zeppelin.

 

Unfortunately its at that point their dreams will be over.

Looks like round two is up.

 

 

I like Blood Sugar Sex Magik as much as the next guy, but there's absolutely no reason RHCP should have beaten Black Sabbath.

 

Basically, this whole thing is a sham and waste of time.

I like Blood Sugar Sex Magik as much as the next guy, but there's absolutely no reason RHCP should have beaten Black Sabbath.

 

Basically, this whole thing is a sham and waste of time.

That's my biggest gripe so far with it.

That's my biggest gripe so far with it.

 

There is like, twenty things wrong with that.

 

Holding out for Rush and GNR now.

I'd like to add this talent lyricist to the bracket.

 

 

I'd like to add this talent lyricist to the bracket.

 

haha i posted that in the music thread, it is now my ringtone/motivational morning drive to school song

haha i posted that in the music thread, it is now my ringtone/motivational morning drive to school song

The best part is the girl in your avatar, words cannot describe how awkward she is.

The best part is the girl in your avatar, words cannot describe how awkward she is.

 

its amazing that this atrocity can be bought on itunes now. i guess the tommy wiseau formula for making something so bad that its good, works

haha i posted that in the music thread, it is now my ringtone/motivational morning drive to school song

Tosh got this girl 6 million hits on youtube, thats astounding.

Wow. That song is the most amazingly awful thing I have ever heard!

Next round is up.

 

Looks like almost "chalk."

 

Queen needs more votes.

Next round is up.

 

Looks like almost "chalk."

 

Queen needs more votes.

 

What?

What?

A "chalk" bracket is a bracket with no upsets.