I think I'm probably in the vast minority, but I'd trade Q for Bruce straight up. That's assuming Bruce is back to 100%. I think he'd bring more to the Sox than Quintana. I know people mention his contract but 17 mill, or whatever he's scheduled to make, doesn't seem all that bad when the Sox just gave 12.5 mill to a 35 year old part time DH. Maybe I overrate Bruce, but a 27 year old who has put up his kind of numbers is the type of guy that can be a major building block.

 

You overrate Bruce, and vastly underrate Q and his worth. If this trade was straight up, the Sox would be robbed. If Q goes in a trade with Cincy, there better be more coming with Bruce

I think I'm probably in the vast minority, but I'd trade Q for Bruce straight up. That's assuming Bruce is back to 100%. I think he'd bring more to the Sox than Quintana. I know people mention his contract but 17 mill, or whatever he's scheduled to make, doesn't seem all that bad when the Sox just gave 12.5 mill to a 35 year old part time DH. Maybe I overrate Bruce, but a 27 year old who has put up his kind of numbers is the type of guy that can be a major building block.

Q is a better pitcher than Bruce is a position player (even using his pre 2014 numbers). Bruce is Carlos Lee without being a pure clown defensively. He's good, not great. What is that worth?

Edited November 23, 201411 yr by GreenSox

Q is a better pitcher than Bruce is a position player (even using his pre 2014 numbers). Bruce is Carlos Lee without being a pure clown defensively. He's good, not great. What is that worth?

Scott Podsednik + Luis Vizcaino.

Glad to see at least some people are now coming out and appreciating Q's worth.

I also think Q is pretty much untouchable. In reagrds to Lester, his 3-0 w a sub.50 ERA in 2 World Series puts him pretty much at the top of the food chain. He may be as good as any lefthander not named Sale in baseball. Lester will get more than $100 Mil. My guess is $130-140 for 5-6 years.

 

Or Kershaw. Or Bumgarner.

Scott Podsednik + Luis Vizcaino.

How did the Sox win in 05? Seriously.

How did the Sox win in 05? Seriously.

Freak pitching and homers

Freak pitching and homers

Freak pitching = Quintana

http://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2014/11/quic...ft-capuano.html

 

Read the part for Bruce (obviously). I think if Sox were to acquire Bruce, it would have to be a 3 way deal.

 

i wonder if they will bite on a rtn of C Beck, T Thompson, M Davidson.

 

they are ready to take the next step in the majors.

 

 

i wonder if they will bite on a rtn of C Beck, T Thompson, M Davidson.

 

they are ready to take the next step in the majors.

 

I doubt it, they have no need for Davidson because they have Votto at first and Frazier at third. Plus, I think thats giving up on Davidson to early. He had one bad year like Bruce, he'll figure it out and still could be this teams third baseman of the future.

I doubt it, they have no need for Davidson because they have Votto at first and Frazier at third. Plus, I think thats giving up on Davidson to early. He had one bad year like Bruce, he'll figure it out and still could be this teams third baseman of the future.

 

then that should be a sweet carrot to make it work.

 

put him in the outfield.

then that should be a sweet carrot to make it work.

 

put him in the outfield.

 

He has never played the OF, he played SS before the OF.

I doubt it, they have no need for Davidson because they have Votto at first and Frazier at third. Plus, I think thats giving up on Davidson to early. He had one bad year like Bruce, he'll figure it out and still could be this teams third baseman of the future.

 

Note the green text, friend

So a new Star Wars trailer came out today.

 

And no to Jay Bruce, if I want anyone from the Reds it's Joey Cueto.

So a new Star Wars trailer came out today.

 

And no to Jay Bruce, if I want anyone from the Reds it's Joey Cueto.

Votto would be pretty nice.

Votto would be pretty nice.

 

Not at 9/$200m for ages 32-41 coming off an injury-riddled season.

Not at 9/$200m for ages 32-41 coming off an injury-riddled season.

I would take him in a heartbeat.

I would take him in a heartbeat.

 

I realize that this is already a hypothetical that will never happen, but the Sox have two 1B/DH already under contract for the next two years.

I realize that this is already a hypothetical that will never happen, but the Sox have two 1B/DH already under contract for the next two years.

Obviously, although Boston was thinking about trying to make Abreu a third baseman.

Obviously, although Boston was thinking about trying to make Abreu a third baseman.

 

That would be pretty bad. I would guess LaRoche would fare better at 3B than Abreu or Votto.

That would be pretty bad. I would guess LaRoche would fare better at 3B than Abreu or Votto.

He'd be like Mike Squires. LH 3B.

I would take him in a heartbeat.

 

Obviously, although Boston was thinking about trying to make Abreu a third baseman.

 

I wouldn't have done it, but that was the story. If the Sox were even thinking about getting Votto, they wouldn't have signed LaRoche obviously. But Votto hitting 3rd with Abreu 4th would be quite a dynamic duo. That's all I'm saying.

I wouldn't have done it, but that was the story. If the Sox were even thinking about getting Votto, they wouldn't have signed LaRoche obviously. But Votto hitting 3rd with Abreu 4th would be quite a dynamic duo. That's all I'm saying.

 

the now time, that will be a great combo.

 

however from age 36-41 that contract would be almost a hangman noose. esp

if he looses his hitting.

 

i wonder if Trout can be had.

Edited November 28, 201411 yr by LDF