In the history of baseball an org has never said we have too much pitching. It always works itself out. The Dodgers might be the best org ever and what's the one thing they need? Pitching. I'm not saying the have to take back pitching but if that's the best teams are offering then they have to do it.
I don't think it's about being right. I think Robert is going to have a good season because he's actually going to be motivated but all it takes is one freak thing and they get nothing. He hurts his oblique on a swing, he slips on a base and pulls a hammy, he runs into a wall and hurts his shoulder. I think the risk is too great and getting nothing for two players who were supposed to bring back future players would set the org back further.