bmags

QUOTE (ChiSox59 @ Jan 4, 2017 -> 04:52 PM) Hahn is taking what amounts to less than a half season of Chapman for Jose Quintana. Obviously, that not how it works, but he'll want much more. No, it isn't how it works. Torres was sold to yanks after a rough first half, he then recovered for a nice second half while being incredibly young, then tore up AFL. Has always had good discipline and then showed off the pop. Torres is a top 5 position prospect now.

QUOTE (Con te Giolito @ Jan 4, 2017 -> 04:43 PM) Yankees are desperate to downplay their involvement that it wouldn't shock me if they are the most interested team. "We don't want Quintana noooo why would we? BTW what's Jason Hammel up to did I mention NO QUINTANA let me tell you about how much I want Jose Qui-I mean don't want. Nope nope nope" NOT BUYING IT, Cashman. Not buying it one bit. I agree with this. Irrational fan opinion: Cashman wants to drop the Torres hammer and not have to give up much beyond it. He does not want to drop the Torres hammer and add considerably more after in competing with another team.

Hey new info

Oh god, impartiality with sports announcers, who cares. "Hey man, I'm impressionable, you can't tell me your opinion about a game let me form my own opinion so I can make crucial decisions off of it"

QUOTE (shipps @ Jan 4, 2017 -> 03:22 PM) For some reason reading about the Yankees valuing their prospects more than the big names made me think back to when I was a teenager and that was the complete opposite. Is it because of the metrics that have been established that teams are more confident in prospect success (more valued as future assets to the org) and there is less of a roll of the dice as it used to be when talent evaluators went off of a couple stats and did mostly everything by the eye test? Why havent I connected the dots with this before now?! I am an idiot! I think it's probably more their post 2009 slow decline of teixera, ellsbury, sabathia, etc that they just needed a change. That and we already know that yank fans have preordered harper jerseys. This is a temporary reset. If you want solace, the yanks in any other year would not have had the farm to even think about Quintana.

Smith's numbers for zips aren't as bad as I thought. Narvaez were.

I'm more forgiving of baseball announcers especially, who have so many more games, and so much less field action than others. Football announcers, announcing 3-4 games of the same teams per season? They should have a lot to talk about so what they choose to discuss matters. For baseball announcers? Suure, tell me about the sausage you ate.

There are no opinions I can relate to less than people's bizarre fixations on announcing. Vin Scully reincarnate could appear today as a new sox announcer and half the people would say he sucks. It's the hitting coach of baseball team media jobs.

Royals trade for Peter O'Brien, was kinda hoping we got him for DH. I think he was on waivers for a bit?

The last 4 years he's draft a lot of guys that are not very athletic, can't rebound or steal. Niko is athletic but can't shoot or defend.

From Merk's mailbag: LOL http://m.whitesox.mlb.com/news/article/212...ier-jose-abreu/

Just to be fair to the OP, his original point was using Rodon to take the "lesser" packages offered for Q. I think that's a fair question not to get lost in the "better offer than Q" posts. But also I still don't think Rodon is at a good sell point. Fully expect him gone .5 season before FA though.

QUOTE (ChiSox59 @ Jan 3, 2017 -> 02:04 PM) That would probably be their first choice. Look, Melky doesn't have much surplus value, but let's not act like the guy is a scrub. We all know you hate him - you crusaded against him more than anything I have ever seen on a message board in 2015. But the dude can flat out hit. He is still a very good bat, but one with some baggage. He's good, he'll probably out perform many inhouse options, but he's not good enough that teams aren't going to just squint at what they have and reason that they are better considering they don't cost 15 million + prospects.

QUOTE (chitownsportsfan @ Jan 3, 2017 -> 02:05 PM) One of these is not like the other. One is completely worth tanking for, the other is not. I've showed the graph time and time again: expected WAR of the first 2-3 picks is much, much greater than the rest of the 1st round. You need to suck hard to get the potential superstars. Yes, they don't always pan out, but more often than not if you draft top 3 you get at least an average MLB player eventually. It's a bit simplistic, but had we had the same position in 2015 that we had in 2014, we could have selected Brendan Rodgers (current Q target, top ten prospect), Kyle Tucker (current Q target, top 50 prospect), and Andrew Benintendi (self explanatory).

Going to be weird to have a top ten without any C+ players

He just lifted up SiX Chris Sales (how much WAR is that worth?)

QUOTE (maggsmaggs @ Jan 3, 2017 -> 09:36 AM) A = Moncada A-= Giolito B+ = Kopech, Lopez, Collins and Fulmer I am not as familiar with Sickels but judging by him keeping Glasnow as the Pirates #1 despite his showing I think you are right 3 Bs - Basabe, Adams, Hansen?

QUOTE (KyYlE23 @ Jan 3, 2017 -> 11:56 AM) I wish this sort of thing happened last month when the NC republicans cut off the incoming democrat governors nuts before he came into office. Problem is few NC state congressman are in at-risk districts after their gerrymandering of 10.

I don't want to be too pessimistic as any rumor is welcome but I don't trust that Phil Rogers in a series of tweets that starts with "Idle Thought" necessarily means that he has heard sox want meadows vs. him actually saying "sox WOULD want Meadows". Not saying he would be wrong in assessment but from way he usually tweets I just am skeptical he is actually sourced on that info.

QUOTE (Dick Allen @ Jan 3, 2017 -> 11:57 AM) It's a Catch 22. You want this to come to a head, but then you have a draft, and minor league or reclamation project signings for another year or 2. Nothing earthshattering. Although it will be interesting to see what the plan is at C. I find it hard to believe the plan is Narvaez and Smith. The thing is we are talking about only a few months before we are already probably watching 2-3 of these guys at MLB club. When sox are contending, everything for me is output related. I just want to win no matter how we are doing it. When we are rebuilding, I'm just concerned about inputs. How is ta playing the game? How is rodon throwing. Each enjoyable if they are not sucking themselves.

once again we see that calls to congressman matter a great deal.

QUOTE (Dick Allen @ Jan 3, 2017 -> 11:37 AM) My point was many are fixated on a Q trade. Once he goes, and maybe a couple of lesser deals, there will be nothing. If you are bored to tears right now, it's going to last a while after something happens in the next few weeks. Next offseason will be about as boring for a Sox fan as it can get. I have had this mindset but even I am beginning to be bored waiting for Q trade as I have basically now gone through every combination of players from 5 different teams in my head and now I just want closure.

QUOTE (southsider2k5 @ Jan 3, 2017 -> 10:19 AM) The question is getting players that will be on your next playoff team. If they aren't players that will be on that team, the next thing you worry about is valuation. The next question is who is more likely to put up big numbers, Tyler Saladino or Todd Frazier to turn into a trade that will next you something? The answer to that question is who you will play. That's not a question. Todd Frazier will get traded, and his market isn't much different now than deadline.

QUOTE (southsider2k5 @ Jan 3, 2017 -> 09:30 AM) Tyler Saladino is not going to be a major contributor in two to three years. We are going to give lots of playing time to people who may not be around in a few years. But you do that because sometimes players surprise you, see Odubel Herrera. Saladino could well be a great bench bat we use across three positions in 3 years, and that has value too. That would mean we don't have to give players like bonifacio time.

Developing talent isn't a waste of our time, it should be our entire purpose for the next few years. There is going to be a major contributor on our team in 2-3 years that we cannot plan on or have no idea about and it will be because we gave lots of chances to lots of different players. If Saladino can become a league average bat, then he is a multipositional player with plus defense at 2 out of 3 positions. That could be valuable.