Everything posted by caulfield12
-
Tyler Flowers is your 2014 starting catcher
QUOTE (Eminor3rd @ Mar 21, 2014 -> 10:10 PM) You bolded the line in my quote that is the answer. They can buy young prospects, they cannot buy MLB breakout candidates. They got the guys they wanted. No one, anywhere, at all think the Sox lost any of the trades they made. Try to find one. I'm not sure that Eaton will end up better than Santiago, but they had no other choice...and this assumes that Quintana was always in their long-term plans for a contract extension and they weren't willing to part with him. Wait. They should have signed Erwin Santana and then bartered him at midseason for Eaton! DOH!!!
-
The Most Interesting Rebuilding Club in the AL
QUOTE (Eminor3rd @ Mar 21, 2014 -> 10:12 PM) I think you're forgetting how young Hawkins is. 2015 is his age 21 season. He's much more likely to get a cup of coffee in 2016 and really have a shot to stick in 2017. He could be there permanently for the first time in 2018 and still not be behind compared to average. Yes, I know all of that. We've been saying it about Trayce Thompson for 2-3 years and he's never really turned the corner to get to the other side. He could "make" the major leagues somehow...eventually...in the same way that Jared Mitchell might end up getting AB's if we lose or trade Jordan Danks, but not as anything resembling a real or true impact player.
-
Tyler Flowers is your 2014 starting catcher
QUOTE (scs787 @ Mar 21, 2014 -> 09:36 PM) Adam Eaton was the 48th ranked prospect last year, Davidson is the 78th ranked prospect this year, and Garcia was the 74th ranked prospect in 2012 (He would have ranked higher the next year had he not "graduated'). You act as though these "lesser" prospects are all, well, "lesser prospect", when in reality they are really good prospects. What did you expect them to get in return? Yes, they shortened the rebuild process, but it's still on going, this isn't a team that's a SP a way from contending. Let these youngsters get their feet wet this year, see where they are with guys like Beck and Bassit next year and if they feel they need a SP they'll have money to do so. You can't deny that they're at the very least moving in the right direction. All prospects not in the Top 25 are likely busts.
-
Tyler Flowers is your 2014 starting catcher
We could have traded our entire farm system for Buxton and Sano and we'd be a lot worse off than we are now with Eaton/Garcia/Abreu/Davidson/Hawkins... Some posters here constantly want to put all of our eggs in one basket with "swing and miss" free agents like Greinke, Pujols or Josh Hamilton just to pacify the fans. Or they want to turn around and do the opposite, which is take our one true superstar and turn him into 3-5 lottery tickets...the kind of trade that goes against you 8 or 9 times out of 10.
-
Tyler Flowers is your 2014 starting catcher
QUOTE (IowaSoxFan @ Mar 21, 2014 -> 01:50 PM) On the other side, Hahn has take a lot of risk out of his acquisitions by acquiring guys that are major league ready as they have at least ML level floors. He traded Peavy and received a ML ready talent in Garcia two lottery tickets in Montas a guy that projects as at least a high leverage reliever, and glove first SS and a third guy that has a chance to be a bullpen guy. He dumped almost $20M of Rios' deal for a super UT player. Not a great return, but it freed up money for Abreu. He turned a back end of the rotation starter and a guy that was going to be moved off the 40 man roster into a cost controlled lead off hitter that was a top 100 prospect before his injury last season. He turned a soon to be expensive closer into another top 100 prospect. He ran one of the best drafts in baseball last season as the Sox pulled in several guys (Engel, May, Mitchell, and Goldberg) who already showing good potential and the ability to move fast through the system. He signed the best power prospect in the international July 2 class. It would have been nice to grab Tanaka, but you can't financially hamstring the franchise to take a chance on a guy that has never played in the majors. I can not think of any really poor moves Hahn has made. He is setting up this team to produce its own talent, and when they are close to competing he has left the team the financial flexibility to fill in any gaps at that time. Santiago's going to be a lot better than Paulino/Rienzo/Surkamp, etc. I wouldn't define him as a 5 starter or Clayton Richard quite yet with his K/IP strikeout ability.
-
East Region
Iowa State was pulling away, then NC Central pulled to one down before Kane had a three point play and Hogue was left unattended on a putback. Looks like Kane was shaken up (hit his chin on someone's head?) but played through it near the end of the half.
-
The Most Interesting Rebuilding Club in the AL
QUOTE (oldsox @ Mar 21, 2014 -> 08:33 PM) "Extremely exciting" -- not just exciting, but extremely exciting. Just curious, what year are you talking about? Mid 2015, being very aggressive. I think Hawkins either explodes this season and we see him in 2015 or early 2016 or we never hear from again except from Buddy Bell testimonials/SoxFest/offseason puff pieces. Everything clicks and he becomes a star or he strikes out 175 times and never gets past Birmingham.
-
South Region
Don't do something stupid. Haha. 4 point play for SFA.....riding a 28 game winning streak, haven't lost a game since late November. And just survived a 24-3 run against them by VCU. Four missed free throws and a 3 point shot with a crazy foul...hit the free throw with 3.6 seconds remaining to tie. Amazing game, probably the best one of the tourney so far. Lumberjacks now have a two point lead coming down to the final seconds of OT. Haymon and Parker showing up huge. VCU barely misses a three at the end, just blew a 10 point lead late. Goodness gracious.
-
The Most Interesting Rebuilding Club in the AL
QUOTE (beautox @ Mar 21, 2014 -> 07:54 PM) Really well written piece. Eventually Beckham will be traded for scraps and hopefully Ramirez gets moved to the likes of the pirates or reds during the trade deadline and Sanchez and Semien take over the middle infield while Anderson and Johnson continue to develop. I have faith Hahn will address the catching situation this trade deadline or next offseason. I think we spend a lot of money going after the likes of Rasmus in the offseason. If Hawkins' season mirrors the 2nd half of 2013, then you can definitely see them throwing in the towel and buying an outfielder on the open market. But an outfield of Hawkins, Garcia and Eaton would be extremely exciting. Not quite ready to trust Rasmus yet. Would like to see him have a repeat of his 2012 success...and with that comes one of those $100+ million contracts that the White Sox have never given away, but contemplated with Tanaka (to go with the $68 million for Abreu). He didn't play under the media glare, in the heat of a pennant race last year. Would like to see how he handles the pressure of dealing with increased expectations and not flying under the radar.
-
South Region
QUOTE (Jenksismyb**** @ Mar 21, 2014 -> 08:46 AM) Didn't they crush Wisconsin on the road too? Iowa had a heartbreaking loss in Madison where McCaffrey flipped out with an ugly technical and they of course choked away at the end...had the lead in the final minute in Iowa City and lost that one too. Not sure about OSU.
-
South Region
24-3 run (13-0)/swing due to VCU's press. Finally broken by 2 free throws. Running SFA off the floor. VCU hasn't been getting a whole lot of attention from the national press this year, but it will turn up again now that the NCAA's are here. Now with the Marquette and BC jobs open, Smart's name will inevitably be mentioned over and over again as the courtship ritual repeats itself...Jim Calhoun, Hoffman from Mercer, Hoiberg, Greg Marshall, Amaker, Mark Few, etc.
-
Sox-Cubs today
QUOTE (JoshPR @ Mar 21, 2014 -> 03:31 PM) Hasn't walked once this spring. Would be interesting to look at the Texas high school kid, that throws around 100 Kolek. Hasn't allowed a hit yet this season, at least when that article was written. Hope he's not related to Colt Griffin or David Clyde. http://sports.yahoo.com/blogs/highschool-p...-170058989.html It's going to be an interesting debate. They're going to have to do their due diligence and make sure there's not a hint of steroid use or unusual physical growth, but this kid is huge and the comps to Clemens are natural. That said, there's always the Kris Honel/Jason Stumm argument against high school pitchers. The White Sox typically have taken the more polished, major league ready collegiate pitcher. This might be the first time they deviate from that pattern (or taking toolsy/KW-esque outfielders).
-
Who's your favorite cinderella team?
QUOTE (zenryan @ Mar 21, 2014 -> 06:58 PM) Mercer only because my friend played there about 10 years ago now and he's jealous that this team has surpassed what his team did back then. I've only been to Macon once, to see Andruw Jones play for the Braves in 1994 when he was a teenager. Also famous for Sherman's March to the Sea. Wow...what a show Cotton and the Friars are putting on!! The announcers saying Tokoto would have won the last two NBA dunk titles, haha. Stephen F. Austin threatening to knock off another Cinderella in VCU/Shaka Smart. Final thought, how good would Iowa or Iowa State have been with Marcus Paige and/or Harrison Barnes? Sigh.
-
Jacob Turner
QUOTE (Stan Bahnsen @ Mar 21, 2014 -> 11:34 AM) If an 80 speed rating doesn't describe a burner, I'm not sure what does. That's Callis' take. http://mlb.mlb.com/mlb/prospects/watch/y20...=mm_mlb_players Hamilton's one of the fastest ever. Micah may well be the better hitter. I'm just going on everything I've read about him...and from those who have seen him play in person. Their argument is that 75% of his basestealing success has based upon technique, which will be exploited as he gets to the upper levels of the minors or the majors leagues as they start to "game plan" against him. I would just estimate he's going to end up a 25-35 steals type of guy at the next level, which means his defense has to improve or he's going to hit with 725+ OPS pop to really be a difference maker if he can't stick at 2B. The real question with Semien, Sanchez and Johnson is whether any of them are going to be legit everyday players. They all project to be better than Leury Garcia, but you don't have a surefire major league All-Star unless you could combine the attributes of all four of those guys. Johnson had a breakout start to 2013 by stealing bases at a mind-blowing rate. His unusual basestealing technique, which involves a walking leadoff, helped him steal 61 bases in 80 attempts in 77 games with Kannapolis in the first half of 2013. Lost in the hysteria around those numbers was the fact that he also hit .342 with a .419 on-base percentage and 34 extra base hits. It's impossible to nitpick the actual production, but he was 22 in Low-A. His July promotion to High-A Winston-Salem set him on a better track in terms of playing at an age appropriate level. Johnson's stolen bases are more a product of his ability to read pitchers and get good jumps than having top line speed. Johnson has good speed, but not the staggering plus-plus speed that typically goes with gaudy stolen base numbers. The key to his future will be his defense. He had 21 errors with the Intimidators, which isn't necessarily a red flag but something to watch as he progresses through the minors. http://www.chicagonow.com/future-sox/micah-johnson/
-
The Most Interesting Rebuilding Club in the AL
I would feel a lot better if Courtney Hawkins was back again as a legit prospect. We can survive without him making it, but it's the same kind of blow (if he flops) that Borchard was. It's not only one player failing...if you look at the Borchard situation, depriving the offense of a legit LH bat led to the eventual trade for Jim Thome (partially) and then later on down the line to Adam Dunn. Or letting Thome go, and the decision to go with Kotsay/Jones, which then led to 2010 and the signing of Dunn. Whatever happens, we have to be right as rain with that #3 pick this June, like we were with Chris Sale and not Beckham. It is worth noting that Santiago was drafted in the 30th round, Reed in the 3rd, Peavy was a salary dump for the Padres and Quintana cost us only a waiver claim...and those three guys turned into Eaton/Davidson/Garcia, a nice ROI, to go along with Abreu and Sale. Finally, it would be nice if the Viciedo of 2012 or the last few months of 2013 showed up.
-
South Region
QUOTE (LittleHurt05 @ Mar 21, 2014 -> 08:20 AM) That has absolutely zero bearing on seeding and rightfully so. See 2013 Kentucky. Pretty much completely different comparison here. The Cardinals were the #3 team in the USA Today Coaches preseason poll and picked to win American conference by the media and the coaches. The Cardinals returned 7 of 9 players from a team that won the 2013 NCAA Championship and both Big East regular season and tournament championships.[1] The team is lead by captains, All-American Russ Smith, 2013 Final Four MOP Luke Hancock and Montrezl Harrell.[2] [3]
-
Jacob Turner
QUOTE (GreenSox @ Mar 21, 2014 -> 08:10 AM) But a 22 year old who is in his 3rd stint in the majors. He's not pitching like a stud, so you don't pay that kind of price, imo. Boras client; near arb eligibile. That's certainly not who I would look for for Semien or Johnson - their value figures to go up a lot this season anyway. Pitching is always worth more than middle infielders...unless those MI's are 1) Gold Glovers, 2) capable of putting up 20+ homers or 3) going to steal 70-100 bases. Let's just put it this way. Billy Hamilton is ranked what, 64th, as a top prospect? Micah Johnson doesn't have nearly that type of burst, and it's likely his SB numbers will fall quite a bit from here on out. Nobody has ever characterized him as a burner. In fact, Avisail Garcia supposedly is just as fast to 1B. And the jury's far from back in about how well he profiles defensively at 2B or LF/CF.
-
Who's your favorite cinderella team?
QUOTE (Rowand44 @ Mar 21, 2014 -> 07:48 AM) Usually there's a couple lower seeds that I really root for but this year I'm just all in on the Shockers. It's strange, but yeah, they're a 1 seed but most don't even think they'll make Sweet 16 , predicting Kentucky will knock them out (assuming UK survives KState), and if they make it there, are predicting Louisville, Duke or Michigan will knock them off.
-
South Region
QUOTE (RockRaines @ Mar 21, 2014 -> 07:59 AM) For their ranking, sure. But the seeding is based on RPI, SOS and wins against top 100 teams. OSU was a clear favorite to get upset (which I picked) but the resume is what gave them the seeding. You have to disconnect ranking from seeding. Lou was a top 5 RANKED team seeded 4th in a region based on that math. Yeah, I get that. Ohio State was seeded where they ended up in the polls. Louisville got screwed, pretty inexplicably. Many had (and still do have) them winning the whole thing again. If they want to punish the conference fine, but to seed a team that won the preceding national championship at #4 is ludicrous with how they've played the last month.
-
Jacob Turner
QUOTE (IowaSoxFan @ Mar 21, 2014 -> 07:57 AM) Definitely worth a flier at the right price. Mariners need another OF to go with Yelich and Stanton until Marisnic is ready and depth in the bullpen. A De Aza+Petricka package may work for them. The just signed Garret Jones to man 1B, so I am not sure they are going to be willing to trade for a replacement already. Why would Petricka be worth anything to them? I'm not even convinced they'd trade Turner for Semien and Micah Johnson. Would anything they've done in the last two years suggest they would want to take on DeAza's contract? The fact that they let him go for nothing...would point to the fact that there's no way they're going to be embarassed a second time and pay through the teeth to bring him back when he's no longer a cheap option.
-
South Region
QUOTE (RockRaines @ Mar 21, 2014 -> 07:50 AM) Ohio State had that seeding because of what they did in the regular season including RPI and top 100 wins. "Rating" would be their AP ranking prior to the tournament starting which is now already moot. Iowa lived off upsetting Ohio State in Columbus because at the time it seemed like a huge win. In fact, they lived off that win, at home against Michigan and a lot of close losses all the way until the last week of the season...when they were STILL ranked 24th despite losing two road games at Indiana and Minnesota. OSU was just living off Matta's reputation and Craft and the fact that they've been so good for so long now you just expect them to be in the Top 25...but it was obvious by some of their head-scratching losses they just didn't have the horses to go very far this year.
-
South Region
QUOTE (RockRaines @ Mar 21, 2014 -> 07:46 AM) Seeding isnt based on what happens in the tourney, its based on the regular season. Losing in the tourney doesnt say anything about the seeds it just says that team lost to another team. And more than 90% of Dayton fans are also OSU fans. Many of my friends who went to UD dont understand why everyone is treating them like some bulls*** cinderella, they've always though more of their program than that. I don't think this is 100% accurate. Iowa went from a 7-8-9 seed all the way down to 10 and then actually 11/play-in when they lost to Northwestern, largely because of NU's 150+ RPI. Nebraska was in the play-in game in a lot of brackets but moved off due to their play against WI and the B10 tourney, despite losing an 18 point lead.
-
South Region
QUOTE (HickoryHuskers @ Mar 21, 2014 -> 07:44 AM) The selection committee is supposed to put Dayton in the play-in games if they feel that's where they belong. If they chose not to do so because of Dayton being the host, then they weren't following instructions. Well...it's definitely interesting to see them paired with another school from the same state in the first round. Obviously, Ohio State was overrated, but I'm not sure how fair that was. Then again, if they couldn't beat a good but not great Dayton team, they probably don't deserve to continue playing regardless. I'm just thinking if I was an Iowa/ISU fan and we had UNI/Drake...or let's say the Univ of Illinois and we had to play someone like Illinois State, UIC or Southern Illinois, it would feel like a no-win situation.
-
South Region
QUOTE (farmteam @ Mar 21, 2014 -> 07:33 AM) It's pretty ironic they were passed over for the play-in game because of the fact that Dayton was the host site. A ton of "expert" brackets had them in one of the two play-in games, along with BYU/SMU/Providence/Stanford/Xavier/S.Miss/LaTech/Minnesota/Nebraska...especially after they lost to St. Joseph's in the A-10 conference tourney. It's pretty clear they didn't seed Colorado/Pitt and BYU correctly.
-
Tyler Flowers is your 2014 starting catcher
QUOTE (witesoxfan @ Mar 21, 2014 -> 07:23 AM) Is this a question or what. See, I can do it too. I mean, for fudge's sake, what evidence do you think I want? I'm a numbers guy. Maybe try and show why they are crater sized holes in the rotation. Be forewarned - you better be prepared as s***, because I consider a crater-sized hole in a rotation about the size of Jamie Navarro, and the Sox really haven't had one of those in about 15 years, even including the rotating "Mike Porzio" 5th starter days. AND THIS IS WHAT I WAS TALKING ABOUT. You are putting stock into Spring Training numbers. Randy Johnson almost consistently had an ERA of over 9 in Spring Training. If pitchers show velocity, control, and command, then managers and coaches do not care. Quit using Spring numbers to justify your argument because Spring numbers are f***ing meaningless. Scrooge McDuck swimming in his piles of gold, goddamn him. I prefer the dragon Smaug as the image...