Everything posted by caulfield12
-
Where is Phegley?
QUOTE (southsider2k5 @ May 29, 2013 -> 09:45 AM) Look at what Toronto did this winter, I could believe it. But isn't the flip side (from the Marlins/Dodgers' records so far) a rising concern and fear that building teams by adding expensive veteran pieces... going to have more than its fair share of detractors as a philosophy going forward? Those two teams have to be in GM/manager firing modes, not to mention the Angels and Royals. Or look at the Shields for Myers/Odorizzi move. Trying to add that one player to put you over the top when your team is still at least one or two years away can be a career-killer. Just can't believe that someone's going to keep giving up their top young position prospects, when all is said and done. And yes, one realizes you just need ONE team to bite, one Arte Moreno or Illitch who "wants to go for it all," but it just doesn't seem like the type of move the St. Louis Cardinals or really smart organizations (Giants, for example) would make.
-
Where is Phegley?
QUOTE (Dick Allen @ May 29, 2013 -> 09:43 AM) What is the fascination posters have with downgrading the SS position? How does dumping Ramirez for zilch like Marty suggests or getting Hechavarria make the White Sox better now or in the long run? If you can get a consensus Top 50 raw prospect back like Hechavarria for Alexei Ramirez, and the White Sox are 8-9-10 games back on July 15, I don't think any GM in the game wouldn't at least consider it. Otherwise, I would agree that it's better to stand pat at that position and play it out longer with Peavy/Rios...or until Carlos Sanchez has become a legitimate replacement (or not) at 2B/SS. Finally, Gordon Beckham needs the next 2-3 months to show what he can do, too, so they can make a final determination on him.
-
Rebuild: So Far Better Than Could Have Hoped For
QUOTE (Dick Allen @ May 29, 2013 -> 09:31 AM) If the Sox aren't that far away, why trade guys like Peavy and Rios for prospects who are farther away, if they even get there at all? Even Marty said the rotation is shaping up. How long do rotations stay together? The time to try to win is while Sale's elbow and shoulder are intact. Then what players have "Youkilis-esque" contracts that are that unique combination of 1/2 year commitments, where the veteran player is blocking a youngster and/or that veteran is having a hard time with his current manager and it's best for the team to part ways....almost, to give him away to kill 2 birds with one stone? Because I haven't seen anyone on here advocate trading, let's say, Erik Johnson, to fix the three biggest problems for the current team, which are catcher, Dunn/Konerko/offense from the middle of the line-up, and the bullpen (and that's assuming there's a "smooth" transition to Gordon at 2B and he doesn't hit in the high 500's OPS-wise coming back from that wrist problem) Other than taking on salary, or making Liriano trades that don't affect the core (Escobar/Pedro Hernandez...which would be trading Axelrod, and even many consider him more valuable to the Sox than as someone who could fetch a trade return)...how do you intend to do that? It seems the only way would be to trade either Johnson or Santiago. Are you willing to take that risk? If you look at it from another perspective, we "went for it" last year at mid-season and still came up short. We didn't have a player (Escobar) who could have entered 2013 as the starting 3B, so we he had to overpay on Keppinger...which isn't a HUGE contract, but it was brought about, once again, because of lack of minor league depth. (And, no, we can't say that ANYONE would have predicted Gillaspie could be the starter against both LHP and RHP before the season). Are we honestly going to be closer to getting to the playoffs this year than last year? How can you make that case, if we're 5 games back, let's say, rather than 3-5 games ahead?
-
Where is Phegley?
QUOTE (witesoxfan @ May 29, 2013 -> 07:52 AM) Ramirez has a very team friendly contract at this point in time. $7 mill this year, $9 mill next year, $10 mill in '15, $10 mill team option or a $1 mill buy out in 2016. He still has a ton of value, and if the Sox think that they will need to tear the team apart, he is going to be one of the most valuable trade pieces they have. They wouldn't "unload" that contract because there would be a ton of teams lining up to trade for him. I strongly doubt they will tear the team apart, and I don't foresee Alexei playing elsewhere any time soon. Let's say Reyes to the Blue Jays didn't materialize...you really believe they would have taken Alexei's contract obligations on and given us, let's say, Hechavarria straight up for him? Just looking at his year over year declining OPS numbers (especially homers and XB hits), his age...his high error totals this year (part of that's on Ventura and by association, Hahn, for not being able to rest him), I just don't see that as being a sure thing that he's going to fetch a consensus Top 50 player back. Cardinals, same thing...do you believe we could actually get Carpenter/Adams, etc., or would we be speculating on minor league pieces (and not one of their top cadre of minor league pitchers)?
-
Nate Jones is a poor relief pitcher
http://www.chicagotribune.com/sports/baseb...0,1915154.story Jones not going down to the minors anytime soon. Cooper has a HUGE face in that video, haha. A bit scary.
-
Where is Phegley?
Moore said a demotion to AAA Omaha is not in the offing for Moustakas (although for our purposes, it might as well be Tyler Flowers). For now, anyway. “There are three basic processes that I challenge myself with when sending a player down,” Moore said. “Is this struggling player staying positive and working hard? Does the coaching staff remain positive in this struggling player? And do his teammates continue to rally around this struggling player? “As long as those three things are occurring, it’s very difficult as a general manager to make a change. You’ve got to trust the people that you’ve hired to help this player get through it. “But no doubt — there comes a point in time if a player continues to struggle and we think we need a mental break and one of those processes breaks down that you have to evaluate it. And then you want to next look at what’s the alternative.” Read more here: http://www.kansascity.com/2013/05/28/42612...l#storylink=cpy
-
Build a bullpen from our minor leaguers with the most potential
QUOTE (danman31 @ May 28, 2013 -> 10:44 PM) Age appropriate K/9 above 9 at AA while maintaining a decent walk rate. Why isn't he still starting this season? Numbers game? Because he's perceived to be behind Thompson, Snodgress and Beck? What is his repertoire? Maybe relieving is a faster path to the big leagues in his case, with a logjam in Chicago/AAA, but that's usually not the prime consideration when positioning a player as a reliever or starter in the lower minors.
-
Build a bullpen from our minor leaguers with the most potential
QUOTE (danman31 @ May 28, 2013 -> 09:35 PM) Griffith was a second round pick that had Tommy John. He had big upside once upon a time. My list: Webb Petricka Vance Salvador Sanchez (seriously 18 K against 0 BB) Don't care after that Why Vance? Know he was a starter last season, and pretty sure he's from UConn. What would make him a standout reliever?
-
Sox vs Cubs
http://www.thebaseballcube.com/players/pro...?P=Jason-Grilli Ironic that he got caught up in a numbers game with the Sox (with the additions of Contreras and Garcia) and ended up with the Tigers in 2005/06/07/08. Amazing that a guy coming into the season at age 36 with 5 career saves is now 21/21. Story of the year...along with the Dodgers, Angels and Blue Jays not exactly buying their way into the playoffs quite yet.
-
Sox vs Cubs
Grilli is just dominating with that slider. Wiped out Cabrera and Hunter with that pitch. Still throwing 93-94-95 MPH with the heater at age 36. FWIW, Don Cooper really helped Grilli out a lot, too. He just wasn't destined to make it as a starter from the time he was drafted by the SF Giants. Struck out the side....got Fielder on a ball out of the zone. Wow. Sox still only 2 behind the Indians, 4 1/2 behind DET. Got lucky tonight with the rain-out.
-
The next month, and possible "false positives"
In the end, if Illitch can win a World Series, he'll inevitably argue all those contracts (Verlander and Fielder, in particular) were worth it.
-
Sox vs Cubs
QUOTE (Noonskadoodle @ May 28, 2013 -> 09:02 PM) That entire bullpen has been money. I believe they are towards the top in MLB.....seem to be really overachieving when going through the names in the pen. We actually brought Jason Grilli back from the dead about a decade ago when he was a busted prospect. Can't believe he's STILL around. Shows you everything you need to know about bullpens...like Cotts/Politte in 2005, or Veal's success last year. You're always going to need a little luck. And Melancon's a former closer. Neil Walker homer in top of the 11th reminiscent of Geoff Blum in Game 3 of the 2005 World Series...kind of came out of nowhere. 1-0 Pirates. Grilli 20/20 in converting save opportunities 1/3rd of the way through the season. That's almost unbelievable.
-
Sox vs Cubs
This Wilson kid pitching for the Pirates (against the Tiggers) out of the pen now is quite impressive. He just threw a 93 MPH slider/cutter. He's Matt Thornton in his prime, easy motion...failed starter, very similar. 0-0 going to the 10th inning. Pirates' starter was former Indian Jeanmar Gomez.
-
Where is Phegley?
QUOTE (southsider2k5 @ May 28, 2013 -> 08:23 PM) Which is the biggest reason no one should be freaking out about him now. If he didn't have enough to make this organizations top 25 list before this season (and we all know how easy that was), there really isn't anything he could have changed in two months that would have turned him into a starting MLB caliber catcher, short of meeting Barry Bonds trainer. He does have two arguments in his favor. Relatively high draft pick, and the freakish illness...that sidelined him early in his career. And 25 isn't too old for a catcher who was drafted from university, it's probably more or less the average (24-26). With the illnesses and injuries, just like Jared Mitchell, it would take a LOT for fans to have much faith in those guys again. So Phegley really has had to overcome a ton of skepticism to get back to "prospect" (not suspect) status.
-
Sox vs Cubs
Have they announced if they're going to stay with their normal rotation order or move Sale up a day or two to rest another starter?
-
Sox vs Cubs
QUOTE (fathom @ May 28, 2013 -> 08:17 PM) Basically, this game never happened. Someone correct me if I'm wrong. Only if they got past 5 1/2 innings and it was tied or an official game...this game is GONE.
-
How can Ventura bat Dunn cleanup every day?
QUOTE (VAfan @ May 28, 2013 -> 07:18 PM) The point I would make about Dunn is that his power production is just as useful at the bottom of the lineup, because HRs by necessity score runs. But his strike outs just kill any chance of putting together innings where you get a couple of hits, perhaps steal a base, and drive runs in that way. Dunn is next to useless in that capacity, esp. since his walk rate is down. Give me Rios, Viciedo and Gillaspie back to back to back and you've got a chance to score. But what Ventura has done has isolated Rios from anyone behind him who can actually move him over or in with something less than a HR. I would generally agree, however, with the sentiment that the Sox aren't going to be able to compete with Dunn and Konerko not hitting like valuable 4-5 guys. Still, that doesn't excuse the person I blame most in this post -- Robin Ventura. If you think about it, Konerko certainly has no future with the Sox, and once his contract is over, neither does Dunn. So why not move Viciedo and Gillaspie into bigger roles, since they likely have a future with the team that goes beyond this season? As I said, he's playing names, not the players he has before him in 2013. And THAT's BAD MANAGEMENT. It's bad enough, that if he did it all season, I think I'd start looking for someone else to take the helm. We had the same debate in 2011 when you could argue that Lillibridge or Viciedo could take AB's from Dunn...where the season felt lost and yet Ozzie kept trotting him out there. The difference back then was the 3 1/2 years left on his contract, vs. 1 1/2 seasons now. At some point, it's just a sunk cost and loss and you move on without worrying about protecting him, his feelings, his being a veteran or trying to build up ANY kind of trade value to get something back in return. And yes, right now, Rios/Viciedo/Gillaspie are the three most consistently dangerous hitters in the line-up. In fact, I remember Greg775 starting lots of conversations defending Ozzie (and Rongey) for leaving Dunn in the middle of line-up no matter what your eyes were telling you (which is that he was completely lost for the season).
-
Rebuild: So Far Better Than Could Have Hoped For
QUOTE (Marty34 @ May 28, 2013 -> 07:22 PM) It's really not. That's what's so bizarre. What do you think is the likely outcome of having 19 of the final 76 games versus the Tigers. Think the pitching staff won't be stressed beyond its limits? When that happens all hell is going to break loose. Not really. Apathy will set in. People will stop caring or switch their interest to the football season. If you can't get fans excited about Cubs/Sox this year, I find it hard to imagine a fan uprising about the pitching staff going south in the 2nd half when everyone expects it based on the workload from 2012 anyway.
-
Where is Phegley?
QUOTE (Marty34 @ May 28, 2013 -> 07:55 PM) Can I have the players ages? Well, Robin Ventura was probably the most famous collegiate player selected in that draft...because of Oklahoma State's program, exposure from the College World Series, his long long hitting streak, high first rounder, etc. It's hard to compare him to Phegley, who I'm sure about 85-90% of the White Sox fan-base doesn't even know exists yet unless they're paying close attention to Harrelson when he talks about the minor league results.
-
5/28 Games
I guess Molina being injury-prone is karma for Sirotka and Santos. Almost wouldn't be fair if he went on to become a stud for the Sox.
-
Sox vs Cubs
One thing that's not encouraging tonight. If Porcello finally gets it together (shut out in the late innings with 10 K's against a good Pirates team), then you can forget chasing down the Tigers in the 2nd half. And the Royals have to be THIS close to firing Ned Yost...down to the Cardinals again. 2 more at StL, then going to the weekend to face the Rangers. Perfect storm.
-
Sox vs Cubs
I would guess, if they do finish it, this would be the least well-attended game in Sox/Cubs history since 1997...
-
5/28 Games
QUOTE (fathom @ May 28, 2013 -> 05:42 PM) Phegley doubles in his first AB Stop stirring things up, haha. I bet he and his family would enjoy reading through all the threads at SoxTalk today.
-
Nate Jones is a poor relief pitcher
QUOTE (southsider2k5 @ May 28, 2013 -> 05:15 PM) Getting bent out of shape about a sixth inning reliever does tell me a lot. In fairness, that's been a critical spot in some of our losses, with starters like Quintana, Axelrod and Santiago often unable to get out of the 5th or 6th. If it's Santiago to be used there (when we have leads and not in mop up mode), that's one thing. But there's always going to be a hole in the pen if we're simply relying on Jones to turn things around, or Lindstrom/Thornton/Crain to pitch multiple innings to get to the 9th. Stretching Reed into multiple innings saves isn't the best idea, either.
-
Rebuild: So Far Better Than Could Have Hoped For
QUOTE (balfanman @ May 28, 2013 -> 03:13 PM) If we would of gotten Chavez there is a good chance that Gillaspie would be elsewhere. I would rather see what Gillaspie has to offer for a whole season. So far, so good. Good point. Or he'd be in AAA as additional depth with Morel and we wouldn't know what we have yet....since Eric Chavez clearly is a "win now" player, and not part of the future.