June 19, 20196 yr After giving extended looks to Cordell and Tilson, it appears neither is particularly Major League Caliber. Cordell fell off to .220 BA and .611 OPS in May, and is having a Palka-like June with zero power and a .214 OPS. Tilson had a decent May, but has fallen off the last few games. Do we give these two more time? Option one for Palka? Think about calling anyone else up? Could Robert be here in September?? What's the best thing to do here?
June 19, 20196 yr Cordell should be sent down. I think Tilson deserves a bit longer look. Jay coming up is kind of a drag because I'd like to see Palka get another shot before next year. I don't think we see Robert this year, if we do maybe the last couple weeks of the season if he just rakes.
June 19, 20196 yr I would probably keep playing Tilson. I'm sure we will see some Jon Jay in RF soon.
June 19, 20196 yr Author I forgot about Jon Jay: The Phantom Menace Like the movie, he's definitely the worst and there's no plot or hero worth rooting for
June 19, 20196 yr 5 minutes ago, Greg Hibbard said: I forgot about Jon Jay: The Phantom Menace Like the movie, he's definitely the worst and there's no plot or hero worth rooting for Who is Jar Jar Binks in this scenario...Alonso?
June 19, 20196 yr Author Just now, wegner said: Who is Jar Jar Binks in this scenario...Alonso? Accurate. Has a big role and was supposed to be a main character but is just too ridiculously bad to pass muster.
June 19, 20196 yr Is Brandon Guyer still in the organization? He should at least be a capable MLB bat. Plus he has one of the best nicknames, "La Pinata" for his propensity for getting hit by pitch in his career.
June 19, 20196 yr 2 minutes ago, Harold's Leg Lift said: Short term- keep the status quo Long term- Trade for Michael Conforto Or Nimmo
June 19, 20196 yr Jay or maybe take a look at Goins who is batting .321 in AAA. Tilson should be playing for now especially vs. righties. Cordel just cant get it going. Edited June 19, 20196 yr by Chisox378
June 19, 20196 yr 58 minutes ago, Hatchetman said: This situation is mind-numbing. How hard is it to find a replacement level RF'er? Tilson has 0.5 fWAR, just FYI. That is above replacement level.
June 19, 20196 yr Conforto is 26 years old and a stud. Would have to give up a boatload to get him. Love him as a player, but really don’t see Hahn doing it. Edited June 19, 20196 yr by PolishPrince34
June 19, 20196 yr Jay is most certainly going to take the RF at bats once he comes up, until he is likely traded for the ultimate lottery ticket in late July. I don't really see how Tilson and Jay coexist on the roster, so I think Tilson is the one to get demoted. If Jay plays RF against RHP, when exactly is Tilson going to play?
June 19, 20196 yr 8 minutes ago, ChiSox59 said: Jay is most certainly going to take the RF at bats once he comes up, until he is likely traded for the ultimate lottery ticket in late July. I don't really see how Tilson and Jay coexist on the roster, so I think Tilson is the one to get demoted. If Jay plays RF against RHP, when exactly is Tilson going to play? Jay is solid against lefties so a platoon of Tilson against righties and Jay against lefties works.
June 19, 20196 yr 2 minutes ago, soxfan2014 said: Jay is solid against lefties so a platoon of Tilson against righties and Jay against lefties works. Meh. Jay's lifetime OPS+ against RHP is 103, 91 against LHP. He has hit .280 against LHP in his career and definitely takes his walks, so he is definitely solid against LHP, but I don't see the Sox reverse platooning him - that would be bizarre. I suspect he'll be in RF most days regardless once he arrives.
June 19, 20196 yr 8 minutes ago, ChiSox59 said: Meh. Jay's lifetime OPS+ against RHP is 103, 91 against LHP. He has hit .280 against LHP in his career and definitely takes his walks, so he is definitely solid against LHP, but I don't see the Sox reverse platooning him - that would be bizarre. I suspect he'll be in RF most days regardless once he arrives. I don't believe they would either. Just pointing it out. Unfortunately, Jay seems to be the best option for RF right now since people are souring on Tilson and Cordell. Which is bizarre because this is what people have been wanting.
June 19, 20196 yr Author 6 minutes ago, soxfan2014 said: I don't believe they would either. Just pointing it out. Unfortunately, Jay seems to be the best option for RF right now since people are souring on Tilson and Cordell. Which is bizarre because this is what people have been wanting. Why is it bizarre? Tilson and Cordell were the right move at the time, but are what we thought they were. Neither were particularly highly touted and both are looking like replacement pieces. I've liked the contributions from both, but after the initial burst, pitchers made the adjustment. It's time to see what else we might have.
June 19, 20196 yr 1 hour ago, Hatchetman said: This situation is mind-numbing. How hard is it to find a replacement level RF'er? Very hard apparently for the Sox who went years and couldn't find a center fielder. Bad minor league system will do that to you. You just play the hand you've got the rest of this year and maybe get a power hitting outfielder in the off season via trade or free agency although I think the Sox have to concentrate on pitching first.
June 19, 20196 yr 51 minutes ago, PolishPrince34 said: Conforto is 26 years old and a stud. Would have to give up a boatload to get him. Love him as a player, but really don’t see Hahn doing it. Would something like Madrigal, Dunning, and a lotto ticket be enough for Conforto? Sox could sign a guy like Schoop or Gennet to play second.
June 19, 20196 yr 1 hour ago, Greg Hibbard said: Why is it bizarre? Tilson and Cordell were the right move at the time, but are what we thought they were. Neither were particularly highly touted and both are looking like replacement pieces. I've liked the contributions from both, but after the initial burst, pitchers made the adjustment. It's time to see what else we might have. This is kind of the problem. There is no one else. And you would like to give the player more of a sample size to see if they can adjust back.
June 19, 20196 yr Author 40 minutes ago, soxfan2014 said: This is kind of the problem. There is no one else. And you would like to give the player more of a sample size to see if they can adjust back. Basabe? Adolfo?
June 19, 20196 yr 1 minute ago, Greg Hibbard said: Are both out with injuries? Adolfo is out the rest of the year. Also looks like Basabe is out.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.