March 5, 20233 yr If you can plug in a guy like Billy who can make catches that are going for extra bases 90+% of the time, I’ll take that over having a marginally better but still below average bat. Honestly, I was on the fence but I just sold myself on Billy in the time since I started posting on this thread. What’s more valuable a guy who might put up a .675 OPS or the guy who can gut the competition by literally taking runs off the board?
March 5, 20233 yr Can someone explain to me what Alberto brings to the table? Dude has a career 54 wRC+ against RHP. I’m not sure how that works playing beyond Andrus & Timmy.
March 5, 20233 yr 4 minutes ago, Chicago White Sox said: Can someone explain to me what Alberto brings to the table? Dude has a career 54 wRC+ against RHP. I’m not sure how that works playing beyond Andrus & Timmy. Yeah, he’s kind of a weird fit. Harold Castro , a left-handed bat, probably would have made more sense on a minor league deal.
March 5, 20233 yr At least one guy on the bench has to be able to hit. 3 utility players would be ridiculous.
March 5, 20233 yr 9 minutes ago, GreenSox said: At least one guy on the bench has to be able to hit. 3 utility players would be ridiculous. Who are three utility players you are referring to?
March 5, 20233 yr 45 minutes ago, Chicago White Sox said: Who are three utility players you are referring to? I think he’s referring to if the bench was Romy, Leury, Alberto. With the way they talked about Romy, I’d be surprised if he didn’t make it. Although I could see Alberto making it over him, with another NRI making it as 4th OF.
March 5, 20233 yr 1 hour ago, Chicago White Sox said: Can someone explain to me what Alberto brings to the table? Dude has a career 54 wRC+ against RHP. I’m not sure how that works playing beyond Andrus & Timmy. Kansas City ties? I got nothing.
March 5, 20233 yr 1 hour ago, Chicago White Sox said: Can someone explain to me what Alberto brings to the table? Dude has a career 54 wRC+ against RHP. I’m not sure how that works playing beyond Andrus & Timmy. Not much. He rake against LHP, but most of the roster does. He’s a better IF defender than Romy and apparently an awesome clubhouse/culture guy. Grifol raves about him recently. I think Romy makes the roster over Alberto, but I wouldn’t be shocked to see it go the other way.
March 5, 20233 yr 8 minutes ago, ChiSox59 said: Not much. He rake against LHP, but most of the roster does. He’s a better IF defender than Romy and apparently an awesome clubhouse/culture guy. Grifol raves about him recently. I think Romy makes the roster over Alberto, but I wouldn’t be shocked to see it go the other way. Yeah, especially since Romy has options. Idk, if they feel Colas, Leury, or Romy can be options in CF when Robert needs a day off, maybe they’d take Alberto over Hamilton and Marisnick. Edited March 5, 20233 yr by Bob Sacamano
March 5, 20233 yr As others have said, it really depends on if Colas makes the OD roster. Hard to get a read on that only a week or so into spring games. Though I fully expect to see one of Eloy, Sheets, or Leury in RF far too often to start. White Sox are gonna White Sox after all. I will guess Seby, Leury, Alberto, and Burger with Sheets as the every day DH - assuming everyone is healthy. Not what I would do, but my guess as to what they will do.
March 5, 20233 yr 3 hours ago, FourEyesShottenhoffer said: I really wish mlb would expand the bench so there were more room for guys like Hamilton or for that matter Sheets. With four bench spots, there’s little room for any kind of specialists like you’d see back in the days of ten man pitching staffs. How would you fit a Jerry Hairston on a roster today? Having a bat like that on the bench was invaluable. It’d be nice to have a bat like Sheets but he simply isn’t versatile enough with the short benches. Rosters should be 28 minimum. Cheap owners. Very much needed.
March 5, 20233 yr 5 minutes ago, pcq said: Rosters should be 28 minimum. Cheap owners. Very much needed. Yeah, I kinda miss the days of 5-man benches.
March 5, 20233 yr 3 hours ago, FourEyesShottenhoffer said: I like that idea but I doubt Billy is quite ready to retire. Seems to me he is the type that would rather play at AAA and wait for the inevitable call up than retire. Can you imagine what he's thinking right now with larger bases and limited pickoffs? Great opportunity for him to stick around. All he needs now is to grant the ability to steal first base and he's golden.
March 5, 20233 yr 2 hours ago, GreenSox said: At least one guy on the bench has to be able to hit. 3 utility players would be ridiculous. Marisnick, Leury, Alberto, Romy, Haseley, et al. I'm lumping 5th outfielders with utility players. None of them can hit.
March 5, 20233 yr Marisnik has to make it. Need some OF defensive depth. Im not sure Leury makes it if Grifol has his way.
March 5, 20233 yr 17 minutes ago, Springfield Soxfan said: Marisnik has to make it. Need some OF defensive depth. Im not sure Leury makes it if Grifol has his way. Leury is going to make it. He might not survive the season if he falls flat on his face again, but he’s safe for now. There also isn’t really anyone to better fit that role. But hopefully he plays very sparingly.
March 5, 20233 yr 38 minutes ago, Springfield Soxfan said: Marisnik has to make it. Why? 23 minutes ago, ChiSox59 said: Leury is going to make it. He might not survive the season if he falls flat on his face again, but he’s safe for now. There also isn’t really anyone to better fit that role. But hopefully he plays very sparingly. How do you figure there is no one better to fill that role? Leury may have literally been the worst player in mlb last year
March 5, 20233 yr 1 minute ago, FourEyesShottenhoffer said: Why? How do you figure there is no one better to fill that role? Leury may have literally been the worst player in mlb last year Who on the 40 man is a better option for both IF/OF duty that won’t make it anyway?
March 5, 20233 yr Depends on the makeup of the entire bench. I’d go with a bench that includes Burger or Sheets, Alberto and either Reyes, Marisnick or Hamilton over any including Leury, for example
March 5, 20233 yr 56 minutes ago, FourEyesShottenhoffer said: Why? How do you figure there is no one better to fill that role? Leury may have literally been the worst player in mlb last year Need some OF defense and bench speed.
March 6, 20233 yr 1 hour ago, Springfield Soxfan said: Need some OF defense and bench speed. Yeah but why Marisnick in particular instead of Reyes or Hamilton
March 6, 20233 yr 2 minutes ago, FourEyesShottenhoffer said: Yeah but why Marisnick in particular instead of Reyes or Hamilton Reyes is an awful OF. Hamilton may as well hit with a pool noodle. I think Billy has a chance though. Reyes doesn’t.
March 6, 20233 yr 1 hour ago, FourEyesShottenhoffer said: Yeah but why Marisnick in particular instead of Reyes or Hamilton Least bad option of the three?
March 6, 20233 yr Zavala, Sheets, Burger and Romy (or Leury if the Sox don't have the gumption to DFA him). I like home runs and clutch hitting even more than I value good defense.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.