Sunday at 03:24 PM2 days 58 minutes ago, southsider2k5 said:How is Mr 3000 doing?12 hits this year - based on his career thus far, he's on pace to get to 3000 in his age 100 season.
Monday at 10:03 PM1 day On 6/20/2026 at 1:18 PM, The Mighty Mite said:What would you hope to get in return?His
Monday at 10:08 PM1 day 2 minutes ago, pcintelligence said: 3 minutes ago, pcintelligence said: His value is not hi. He is a part timer.
Monday at 10:11 PM1 day 14 minutes ago, Falstaff said:I was drinking the Nick Madrigal cool aide in 2020, what happened ?He was physically maxed out and picked for his proximity to the majors. Then he ended up being perpetually injured and unable to get any better.
Monday at 10:23 PM1 day Author 11 minutes ago, southsider2k5 said:He was physically maxed out and picked for his proximity to the majors. Then he ended up being perpetually injured and unable to get any better.The most egregious part to me was how scouting reports described him as an elite defender when in reality he was far from it.
16 hours ago16 hr On 6/20/2026 at 9:14 PM, Bob Sacamano said:Madrigal went on to do nothing so not reallyThe problem wasnt what we gave up....the problem was the return.
15 hours ago15 hr I think the evidence points to Madrigal being a pretty strong defensive 2B despite some bonehead plays when he first came up to the Sox. That said, here's something I never understood: on draft day, the Sox announced him as a shortstop. He played his first rookie ball game at SS (and committed an error). Then he never played SS again. What the hell was that?
15 hours ago15 hr 5 minutes ago, Jake said:I think the evidence points to Madrigal being a pretty strong defensive 2B despite some bonehead plays when he first came up to the Sox. That said, here's something I never understood: on draft day, the Sox announced him as a shortstop. He played his first rookie ball game at SS (and committed an error). Then he never played SS again. What the hell was that?What’s the evidence? The Sox put him everywhere and none of it stuck
15 hours ago15 hr On 6/21/2026 at 10:02 AM, Jake said:As soon as we get a lineup with about 6 MLB-quality hitters, we want to trade oneMeidroth's a pro-level 2B. We're kind of beyond the period of trading everyone with value. He's your 2B until a superior option displaces him.
15 hours ago15 hr 9 minutes ago, Jake said:I think the evidence points to Madrigal being a pretty strong defensive 2B despite some bonehead plays when he first came up to the Sox. That said, here's something I never understood: on draft day, the Sox announced him as a shortstop. He played his first rookie ball game at SS (and committed an error). Then he never played SS again. What the hell was that?He graded out pretty below average as a 2B, why would they play him at SS, especially when there were much better players there everywhere he went?
15 hours ago15 hr 2 minutes ago, southsider2k5 said:He graded out pretty below average as a 2B, why would they play him at SS, especially when there were much better players there everywhere he went?All of those metrics have him above average at both 2B and 3B.At any rate, my point wasn't that the Sox should have made him a SS. It was that the Sox called him a SS, then played him there for his very first pro game, then suddenly shut that whole idea down. Everybody at the time, including me, expected him to be playing 2B. Then the Sox decided to try him out at SS but gave up after a one-game trial. I thought that was pretty weird and suggested something strange about the Sox decisionmaking at the time. Edited 15 hours ago15 hr by Jake
15 hours ago15 hr 1 minute ago, Jake said:All of those metrics have him above average at both 2B and SS.At any rate, my point wasn't that the Sox should have made him a SS. It was that the Sox called him a SS, then played him there for his very first pro game, then suddenly shut that whole idea down. Everybody at the time, including me, expected him to be playing 2B. Then the Sox decided to try him out at SS but gave up after a one-game trial. I thought that was pretty weird and suggested something strange about the Sox decisionmaking at the time.Below average range, UZR, and double plays as a 2B doesn't seem like good skills for a SS. We also know how awful his arm was, even though it didn't rate here.
15 hours ago15 hr 4 minutes ago, tray said:Stop with the attempted comparisons with Madrigal. Two different players,Chase has been worth 2.8 bWAR in 822 PAs.Nick was 3.7 in 992.Fwar is 2.7 for Chase, 2.9 for Nick
15 hours ago15 hr Meidroth is right in between Sox peak Madrigal and MVP vote receiving Dustin Pedroia...(well three weeks ago he was) That said, players with low 700s or high 600s ops are often thought to be replaceable unless they play GG level defense...especially at the four middle of the diamond positions. Edited 15 hours ago15 hr by caulfield12
13 hours ago13 hr Author 1 hour ago, joejoesox said:that savant page is a train wreck lolHe's going to come crashing down to earth. Trade him ASAP!
13 hours ago13 hr 2 hours ago, sin city sox fan said:The problem wasnt what we gave up....the problem was the return.Codi Heuer was looking good in 2020 and was so so with the Cubs in 2021 but then he got hurt. He is currently on Cleveland's 40 man and was on the active roster earlier this month.Craig Kimbrel was lights out with the Cubs but was an epic failure on the Southside.
8 hours ago8 hr On 6/22/2026 at 3:23 PM, ron883 said:The most egregious part to me was how scouting reports described him as an elite defender when in reality he was far from it.He was supposed to be fast too 🤣
.thumb.jpeg.80bf23436bcc9fc1d4b954272d2e0de5.jpeg)
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.