Why would the Cubs promote their 24-year-old top prospect OF Tyler Colvin to the major league team, when he has yet to even play in AAA, and will just sit on the bench behind Soriano, Bryd, Fukudome, and Nady?

 

Why would the Cubs promote their 24-year-old top prospect OF Tyler Colvin to the major league team, when he has yet to even play in AAA, and will just sit on the bench behind Soriano, Bryd, Fukudome, and Nady?

 

Nady cant even throw the ball so he is a pinch hitter for the first few months of the season and sounds like he will be filling in each position and will play at least 3-4 games a week.

That 0/12 BB:SO ratio should fit in perfectly for the Cubs not to mention lack of playing time on the bench.

Nady cant even throw the ball so he is a pinch hitter for the first few months of the season and sounds like he will be filling in each position and will play at least 3-4 games a week.

yes, for about $140m payroll it's amazing what their roster looks like

yes, for about $140m payroll it's amazing what their roster looks like

 

Sometimes I think the Cub bashing here gets too emotional but your comment is spot on and illustrates how bad a GM Hendry is. They may win the WS this year and make us all look like fools, but on paper this has to be one of the worst looking teams you can assemble at that price tag.

Nady cant even throw the ball so he is a pinch hitter for the first few months of the season and sounds like he will be filling in each position and will play at least 3-4 games a week.

 

3-4 non-linear days of baseball at 3 different positions is better than 6-7 games straight a week of playing 1 position? And not to mention that they don't think Colvin is a very good OF, and said he probably can't play CF. So that leaves LF and RF, unless they want to have a weak CF out there.

 

I can't find any way in which you have your 24-year-old top prospect completely skip AAA just for a bench role.

Edited March 29, 201016 yr by JoeCoolMan24

3-4 non-linear days of baseball at 3 different positions is better than 6-7 games straight a week of playing 1 position? And not to mention that they don't think Colvin is a very good OF, and said he probably can't play CF. So that leaves LF and RF, unless they want to have a weak CF out there.

 

I find any way in which you have your 24-year-old top prospect completely skip AAA just for a bench role.

 

As a backup, I doubt they really care that he doesn't play CF very well. I just don't think they really care at all about a lot of things.

I find any way in which you have your 24-year-old top prospect completely skip AAA just for a bench role.

 

The guy wasn't even that great in AA last season also. This is not even saying he was seriously overdrafted comming out of Clemson. (I remember saying the guy wasn't even a 1st round talent, yet alone a top 15 pick. He would had been a steal in the later rounds possibly 3rd-5th) The guy has serious flaws in his game (I mentioned his plate discipline being one), and putting him on the bench, possibly to get "something" out of him, is not good for his development.

Edited March 29, 201016 yr by SoxAce

The guy wasn't even that great in AA last season also. This is not even saying he was seriously overdrafted comming out of Clemson. (I remember saying the guy wasn't even a 1st round talent, yet alone a top 15 pick. He would had been a steal in the later rounds possibly 2nd-4th) The guy has serious flaws in his game (I mentioned his plate discipline being one), and putting him on the bench, possibly to get "something" out of him, is not good for his development.

 

I agree. After reading my quote, I realized I forgot the important word "can't" in my sentence. Hope that you didn't think I was advocating them brining him up to the MLB level already.

3-4 non-linear days of baseball at 3 different positions is better than 6-7 games straight a week of playing 1 position? And not to mention that they don't think Colvin is a very good OF, and said he probably can't play CF. So that leaves LF and RF, unless they want to have a weak CF out there.

 

I find any way in which you have your 24-year-old top prospect completely skip AAA just for a bench role.

Maybe it's because they don't consider him a top prospect? He's an incredibly underwhelming talent especially given where he was taken in the draft.

I agree. After reading my quote, I realized I forgot the important word "can't" in my sentence. Hope that you didn't think I was advocating them brining him up to the MLB level already.

 

Naw I got what you were sayin.

Maybe it's because they don't consider him a top prospect? He's an incredibly underwhelming talent especially given where he was taken in the draft.

BP didn't even have him in the Cubs top 15.

Maybe it's because they don't consider him a top prospect? He's an incredibly underwhelming talent especially given where he was taken in the draft.

 

Then they sure to talk about him a TON for someone they don't even value. All I ever hear if Castro, Vitters, and Colvin. I wish we were deep enough that a 23-year-old who hits .300 with 14 jacks, and 7 triples in 84 games in AA is not anyone significant to us.

This is a bad idea. This guy can't draw a walk to save his life.

 

Have real pitchers throw to him and he's going to hit .250 with a .280 OBP. Ugly.

Then they sure to talk about him a TON for someone they don't even value. All I ever hear if Castro, Vitters, and Colvin. I wish we were deep enough that a 23-year-old who hits .300 with 14 jacks, and 7 triples in 84 games in AA is not anyone significant to us.

 

The cubs never talk up all of their minor leaguers as if they were phenoms. He may be the next Corey Patterson or dare I say Felix Pie.

Then they sure to talk about him a TON for someone they don't even value. All I ever hear if Castro, Vitters, and Colvin. I wish we were deep enough that a 23-year-old who hits .300 with 14 jacks, and 7 triples in 84 games in AA is not anyone significant to us.

 

It was his 3rd trip to AA. I'd hope he would be able to hit it on his 3rd go around, and even then, it was only for a half a season.

I'm guessing they realize that hes not gonna be anything special, so they arent worried about ensuring that he gets as many at-bats as possible. He tore the cover off the ball in ST, and looked like the best option for 4th/5th OF, so lets bring em up. Don't have to worry about development cause theres very little developing left to be done.

The cubs have one of the worst bullpens ive seen them have in a long time.

The cubs have one of the worst bullpens ive seen them have in a long time.

Marmol (who has filthy stuff but walks a guy an inning) is their best guy. The rest are Marshall, Samardzjia, Grabow, Caridad, Berg and eventually Gorzellany when Lilly returns. That is ugly.

 

Rotation of Zambrano, Dempster, Wells, Silva and Gorzellany/Lilly. Not much prettier.

 

Marmol (who has filthy stuff but walks a guy an inning) is their best guy. The rest are Marshall, Samardzjia, Grabow, Caridad, Berg and eventually Gorzellany when Lilly returns. That is ugly.

 

Rotation of Zambrano, Dempster, Wells, Silva and Gorzellany/Lilly. Not much prettier.

if memory serves me correctly, their opening month or so of their schedule is a complete joke, so get ready for some of these guys to look OK and have Cubbie fever runnin' rampant!!

Marmol (who has filthy stuff but walks a guy an inning) is their best guy. The rest are Marshall, Samardzjia, Grabow, Caridad, Berg and eventually Gorzellany when Lilly returns. That is ugly.

 

Rotation of Zambrano, Dempster, Wells, Silva and Gorzellany/Lilly. Not much prettier.

 

Considering their payroll, they have one of the most horrific looking rosters I've seen in a while.

That bullpen is a joke. Unless the Cubs offense hit like they did in 2008, this is a .500 team at best.

BP didn't even have him in the Cubs top 15.

 

I guess having a Brian Anderson Spring Training allows you to jump AAA t sit on the pine.