I dont know what position is worst, Wisconsin QB's or Wisconsin's DBs. Not only have they be beaten a lot, they are horrible at playing the ball in the air.

I hope we get Alabama vs Ohio State and Mariota vs Jameis. That'd be awesome.

No matter who wins, I think it's obvious FSU is not one of the best 5 teams in the country

 

Still think the non conference will keep OSU behind TCU, but who knows at this point

TCUs non conference is garbage. Their overall opponents are 61-70 while OSUs are 84-60.

Edited December 7, 201411 yr by RockRaines

TCUs non conference is garbage. Their overall opponents are 61-70 while OSUs are 84-60.

 

TCU didn't lose in the non conference to a 6-6 team. Given what the committee has said, it seems like that matters, even though OSU is rolling right now.

 

TCU didn't lose in the non conference to a 6-6 team. Given what the committee has said, it seems like that matters, even though OSU is rolling right now.

And that's the only thing they have. OSU has SOS better wins including on the road and an extra conference title game which was a beat down.

All I wanted was to get that title back. Fantastic.

TCU should be out of the conversation. It's between Baylor and OSU. The nice thing about this committee is that they do seem to judge on a week by week basis and not "because you win, you stay ahead" bs.

Personally, I think Baylor should make it ahead of Ohio St. Baylor lost to a better team on the road than Ohio St. did, and Baylor also beat a top 6 team in TCU. It's too bad both Baylor and Ohio St. can't make it, as Ohio St. is playing like a top 3 team right now.

Personally, I think Baylor should make it ahead of Ohio St. Baylor lost to a better team on the road than Ohio St. did, and Baylor also beat a top 6 team in TCU. It's too bad both Baylor and Ohio St. can't make it, as Ohio St. is playing like a top 3 team right now.

Depends if you think 12-1 with a better SOS is better than 11-1 with a "better" loss.

If this were 2013, what would we be arguing? FSU would be a lock #1 because they are undefeated, so it would be Alabama or Oregon? Given the SEC bias, it would be FSU vs. Alabama with little argument. This system is way better.

If this were 2013, what would we be arguing? FSU would be a lock #1 because they are undefeated, so it would be Alabama or Oregon? Given the SEC bias, it would be FSU vs. Alabama with little argument. This system is way better.

 

 

 

heard on radio that the BCS projection wouldve been #1 Alabama vs FSU

So Gordon is like Tevin Coleman light right?

So Gordon is like Tevin Coleman light right?

 

Well Drake Johnson > Melvin Gordon...obviously.

I'm really ok with any of Baylor, OSU or TCU getting in, I think they all have pretty decent arguments. That said, I think it's going to be the Buckeyes.

Edited December 7, 201411 yr by Rowand44

It would just be pure awesomeness if they left FSU out

I'm really ok with any of Baylor, OSU or TCU getting in, I think they all have pretty decent arguments. That said, I think it's going to be the Buckeyes.

 

Baylor has no chance IMO. The committee hasn't liked them from day one, I doubt a home win over Kansas State suddenly changes everything. Years ago they set a non conference schedule without a BCS opponent and that's gonna cost them this year

Baylor has no chance IMO. The committee hasn't liked them from day one, I doubt a home win over Kansas State suddenly changes everything. Years ago they set a non conference schedule without a BCS opponent and that's gonna cost them this year

No argument, I'm just saying personally I'd have no problem with any of the 3 getting in.

 

 

You can make any argument against the Big 12 teams that you want, I still don't think the whole conference championship game thing should factor in. And if it does, the committee should say that they are penalizing the Big 12 for not playing an extra game.

 

Grilling the whole "One True Champion" phrasing as why the Big 12 might miss the playoff seems to make the argument that the committee is full of idiots.

 

"They said they have one true champion, but they gave out TWO trophies!!! How do we evaluate them?"

To that end, I completely think that Ohio State is one of the top 4 teams in the nation. I do not think Florida State is, but there is close to zero chance they are left out.

Hopefully this year leads to an 8 team playoff. I realize you then have a debate over the 9th best team being led off but if you give automatic bids to the ACC, Big 10, Big 12, Pac 12, and SEC champions a bid and then have 3 at large spots it will be incredibly rare for a championship caliber team to be left out.

Cole Cubelic ‏@colecubelic 4h4 hours ago

 

Overall record of opponents defeated: Alabama 81-63 FSU 83-73 Ohio St 80-63 Oregon 63-70 Baylor 61-70 TCU 61-71

Cole Cubelic ‏@colecubelic 4h4 hours ago

 

Overall record of opponents defeated: Alabama 81-63 FSU 83-73 Ohio St 80-63 Oregon 63-70 Baylor 61-70 TCU 61-71

 

Big 12 will inherently have more losses than conferences that only play 8 conference games.

Urban cant hide from Saban now

Like I was saying...

TCU should be out of the conversation. It's between Baylor and OSU. The nice thing about this committee is that they do seem to judge on a week by week basis and not "because you win, you stay ahead" bs.

Bing bing bing

 

 

 

Playoff committee got it right.