Good Guys

I don't dislike the idea of adding Grandal. I would be happy to have him but I don't feel that catcher is a priority this offseason. That could change next year but right now we're bringing back a top 10 war player at catcher. The only other position player on the team that can boast that is Yoan at 3B. Also, if I'm building a team I would prefer to have great defense up the middle (CF, SS, 2B, and C) and get a lot of offensive production from the players down the the lines (LF, RF, 3B, and 1B). Therefore I'm okay if a catcher isn't the greatest hitter as long as they can field the position well and call a good game.

No mention of Adam Eaton in this thread? He's a free agent if Washington doesn't pick up the option, solid defensively in right field, and a left handed bat.

Tim Anderson has the ability to make some plays at SS that I'm sure even Omar Vizquel is impressed with but he also makes a lot of errors. What if this doesn't improve? He did lead the league in errors in 2019 and only played in 123 games. At what point would a change in position be considered? I know the White Sox front office thought about moving TA to CF last year to give Manny Machado his choice of 3B or SS. Instead of trying to find a RF in a down year for free agents at that position what if the Sox moved TA to CF or RF and signed someone like Didi Gregorius to play SS? That seems like it could be a better option defensively and maybe also offensively than signing a player like Ozuna to me.

Teams with good starting pitching usually make the playoffs and teams with the best two or three starters often go to the world series. The white sox scored 741 runs in 2005 and 868 in 2006. Their offense was much better in 2006. Starting pitching was the difference between winning the world series and finishing third in the division.

I agree with you but I find it frustrating because I feel like that's a losing philosophy. It's similar to a NBA team that avoids signing star players or a NFL team that won't invest in a quarterback. It makes winning really difficult.

I would make starting pitching a priority this offseason. Its something both the Nationals and Astros have invested a lot of resources in and look where they are now. If the White Sox are doing some bargain shopping I would be okay if that's in right field or DH as long as 1 or 2 quality starters have been acquired.

It was interesting to see that the Yankees will still be paying Alex Rodriguez $5 million in deferred salary in 2020.

It wouldn't surprise me to see the Yankess surpass the luxury tax threshold for a season or two but pressure will be on them to deliver a world series.

The Yankees might not have a lot of payroll flexibility this offseason if they care about staying under the luxury tax threshold. After arbitration they project to be around $200 million.

Marshall was at times one of the best relievers on the team in 2019 so for $1.3 million he's a no brainer.

Goins and Osich I'm not particularly attached to but not much risk at a salary of $1 million or less.

I would bring back everyone on that list for that price with the exception of yolmer. In 2016 the white sox were just below league average ($134 million) with a payroll of $129 million. They have been in the bottom 5 of payroll the last three years while rebuilding and saved a lot of money. League average in 2019 was $137 million and that's where I would expect the white sox to get back to if they are remotely serious about contending. They are currently dead last in pre arbitration payroll for 2020 with $23 million on the books. There is no reason to save and every reason to spend. I understand that the white sox will never spend like teams such as the Yankees, Dodgers, or Cubs and I don't expect them to. But I also don't think they should be that far off teams like the Mets and Angel's which both had $160 million payrolls in 2019 and are also considered to be the second teams in their respective cities.

I don't understand all the love on this board for Scooter Gennet. He's had 3 good seasons. He will turn 30 next May. We haven't had a great track record with players from Cincinnati. I don't think Great American is all that different from hitting at Coors Field. I understand buying low on a guy but I don't think he's going to give the White Sox a discount with Madrigal behind him and expected up in 2020.

The White Sox are in a great position to win a lot of games in the future. If they wanted to they have the flexibility to overpay, get both Cole and Strasburg, and still be an average team in terms of payroll in MLB. Will they do this? NO. But could they? I think It's possible. The question that remains is if and when they will spend to complete rebuild and how far they are willing to go. I don't mind that the White Sox save a lot of money and rebuild from time to time as long as they spend and invest in high caliber players when their teams are in a good position to win.

Fortunately, draft picks can't be traded. If the Sox ran the draft like they do signing international prospects they would trade their 1st round draft pick for cash and then trade their 2nd, 3rd, and 4th round picks to acquire as many picks in the 10th round as possible.

I wonder how much cash the white sox could get for prospects or current players? What kind of dollar figure would Robert, Moncado, or Giolito bring back in return? Might be a nice little bonus before selling the team.

Good post. Could not have said it better myself.

How dare you compare our prized draft pick to Jose Abreu. You should apologize!

Per Forbes, the White Sox are the 14th most valuable franchise in MLB. I can't find the article, but I believe I read somewhere that they were in the top 10 in profit margins for 2018. https://www-forbes-com.cdn.ampproject.org/v/s/www.forbes.com/sites/mikeozanian/2019/04/10/baseball-team-values-2019-yankees-lead-league-at-46-billion/amp/?amp_js_v=a2&amp_gsa=1&usqp=mq331AQEKAFwAQ%3D%3D#aoh=15671424665497&referrer=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.google.com&amp_tf=From %1%24s&ampshare=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.forbes.com%2Fsites%2Fmikeozanian%2F2019%2F04%2F10%2Fbaseball-team-values-2019-yankees-lead-league-at-46-billion%2F

Oh that's exactly what this is. I feel that he's a cheap owner that's more concerned with his team's profit margin than wins. I've been excited about this rebuild. At least the team was trying something different. But I'm concerned that not enough free agent spending will occur to make the rebuild a success.

Jose Abreu is terrible defensively but there's not that many guys out there that hit 25+ home runs and drive in 90+ runs as consistently as he does. It's about to be 5 times in 6 seasons and last year, the one season he failed to do so he was injured.

I feel like the only difference between James Dolan and Jerry Reinsdorf is Michael Jordan.

I hate to comment negativity about Collins because hasn't had much of a chance to prove himself but he is far from showing that he can be a 1 WAR first baseman.

Who is the worst owner in professional sports?

Yesterday the Ray's got shutout by the Blue Jay's and the Yankees won a competitive game against Baltimore in which the score was tied going into the 8th inning.