Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Soxtalk.com

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Chisoxfn

Admin
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Chisoxfn

  1. Or - maybe they need to put a better roster around Lavine. I mean just look at what happens late in games - the rest of the team completely disengages and forces it to be Lavine vs. the world. Odds are just pathetic. Also - if you are an opposing D - what would you do - you are going to totally squeeze and pressure Lavine. White is a train-wreck with the ball late in games and outside of Lauri / Porter Jr (both of whom are out hurt) everyone else is totally scared (White isn't scared - but he also isn't good - to your point - maybe he's a better shot than a triple teamed Lavine). Wasn't Lavine's most efficient game - but I have a hard time getting that upset at the guy who had 35 points on the night - albeit a less efficient 35 than the team has been used to. Put some real talent around him and just imagine how tough Lavine would be to stop in a late game situation where a team couldn't completely collapse on him (like it can with the current roster out there). When you put it that way - it is kind of incredible how efficient Lavine's season has been. PS: Not downplaying what a terrible loss this is - but just like past years - this roster can't stay healthy. You just can't build around the fragility of Lauri/WCJ. We all know Porter Jr. is super fragile too - so no surprise there and I expect none of those 3 will be part of the roster in a year, probably not even by the time we get to the trade deadline.
  2. One other data point I had forgotten about, but Derek Carr worked with DeFillipo his rookie year - so Defillipo has a connection to both Wentz and Carr. Technically I believe he also was the OC in Jacksonville when Minshew broke out as a rookie...but I won't put Minshew in the same sentence as the other guys.
  3. Reality is - the above scenario would be the Bears best chance at getting Watson, but also probably highly unlikely, because there is zero reason for Pace/Nagy to wait around and put their QB hopes on the dream of Watson. That would be foolish - which is where i have to imagine the longer it plays out, the more likely the Niners would be the destination in a late season move - because they can live with the guy they have, but aggressively upgrade if market made sense. With Carr - I don't know what the Raiders want to do. It seems like maybe there is enough momentum they'll make a move, but the same has been said for the past 2 years. I don't think Carr wants to be there, but he isn't going to make a stink and ask out either.
  4. That is fair - I just don't know what good the revisionist history that makes. Franchise is where it is at this point and the GM and Coach aren't in a position where they are going to blow things up. We can debate whether that was the right or wrong move to make - I was more in the camp of hit the reset - but I can respect the McCaskeys, who have worked with Pace a lot longer and closer than us, thinking they do have the right guy. And I 100% agree with what you said above...but I'll make one key distinction. I do not put a price on elite QB pay. So no, I will never blame Pace for going all in on a QB (like he did for Trubisky). I respect the heck out of his conviction and go back to the old adage, you can't steal 2nd and keep your foot on 1st. To get a QB - you need to take swings and he has done so. With Glennon - it was a calculated chance. Not a convicted risk the franchise chance. He took a - maybe there is an x% chance this works out type of deal, if not, we'll walk away at low risk. He did that. With Foles - I kind of think of that move the same way - although in that situation - I really think it had more to do with a solid floor if Mitch stinks - kind of a in case of emergency rip bandaid to ensure we keep our jobs type of maneuver. I didn't hate Foles - but always said he is what he was - which was extremely mediocre with no long term sustained success as a full time starter (other than his magical year with Chip Kelly). I hated giving up a 4th round pick though for Foles - that was terrible. I also didn't love tying up the 21 cap space with Foles. Not that his contract is terrible - it is fair for a back-up / low end starter - and maybe Pace figured worse case scenario Foles was a bridge to another young QB in 21 cap space wasn't an issue. I don't know - but I wouldn't have made the move. I'd also say - Bears didn't want to wait on QB last year - it turns out if they did, maybe Winston would have been better - but I don't think anyone had Winston sitting around as long as he did, nor did anyone have Cam sitting for as long as he did and signing as cheap as they did. I also don't know that Winston was coming to Chicago - he wanted to go play under Brees/Payton. Either way - even if they got Winston - when you think about COVID - the ability to get a brand new starter in and teach them the offense while trying to contend is a pretty tough sell. That isn't to say it isnt' doable - Herbert looked pretty good as a starter as did Burrow and they were rookies, let alone veterans - but Winston would have been sharing reps with Mitch - which would have made that dynamic tougher. Bottom line - it is what it is - and the one thing I give Pace a ton of credit for is his willingness to take swings at QB. I don't love the swings he took - but the only one I can really get that pissed over is picking Mitch over the other guys. I don't have any beef with showing conviction for you guys nor do I get that irritated over the Foles/Glennon moves. Those were stop-gap type measures - not swing big measures. I'd put Wentz in the bigger swing mold - because you are going to give up a substantial asset for him and get a guy with REAL upside, right there with Mitch & Jay as the 2 who had the most upside of any QB Bears have brought in over past 15+ years (Grossman is the only other guy in the equation). Why - because for 20 years the franchise literally didn't invest in any QB with upside, like none.
  5. Some recent speculation the Bears might be leaking the Wentz stuff - more to put a bit more pressure on other teams. If you are the Texans or Raiders or Falcons looking to move your QB - you may not want to be the last one to the party. Or maybe you do - because you think there are still enough desperate teams out there...bu I have to imagine Bears are on higher end of "desperate". One name someone has mentioned is Bears really high on Derek Carr. I don't know about really high - because Carr is exactly who he is. A 10-15 overall QB. Not any better, probably not any worse. His last 2 years have been his best from a QBR perspective. He also has had good weapons around him past 2 years plus solid protection. Very durable though and his contract is pretty reasonable for anyone who gets it. I don't think he has the peak ability of Wentz - but probably a much better floor than Wentz.
  6. I don't have an issue with Winston - but Winston is probably going to get paid more than you think and have more cap consequences for whatever team acquires them - if they want to move on from him in the future (if he doesn't pan out). I may be wrong - but I don't see Winston signing a 1 year deal..but maybe you can get him with a Glennon type of 2 year deal where you pay him a lot extra. But that deal has its own issues - given you have Foles contract to still deal with. I'd also say - Winston has not shown the same ceiling Wentz has. Wentz has legitimately been amongst the league best over a 3 year window - he missed some games in that span - but from 2017-2019 he ranked much closer to a top 5 QB than a middle of the pack QB. I can't say the same thing about Winston. My point is - you swing and swing at QB time after time. The Bears have not done it enough - to me swinging for Mitch, if he was your guy was 100% the right move. Just like if you think there is a good chance Wentz is a back end top 10 QB (Which he absolutely was for 3 of the past 4 years) at the contract you would be getting - you do that 100% of the time (unless you are trading a bunch of future picks or extending him and putting a bunch of guarantees onto your books). The Cutler move was the only other time the Bears have done this - and while it didn't work - again - it was 100% the right move.
  7. Why would I do that? I don't understand? So I have cap space and non lottery draft picks? To do what - sign free agents or acquire a disgruntled star? How am I going to do that - when I don't have a decent team. If anything - if I were running a franchise - the sole goal should be to build a team that can make the playoffs with maximum roster, cap and draft asset flexibility so that I can consistently and agily pivot to attract super star x. Its why I don't sign Mark - that is a deal I probably can't move from. But Lavine - if I could I'd sign him - his contract is totally reasonable as a strong #2 in time and if somehow a better option opens up - I can move a guy like Lavine for something better or to pivot another way. No one is going to come to the Bulls as a big time signing if the Bulls aren't already a playoff team. Not going to happen, whether it is via trade or free agency.
  8. He's also not a #2 on any good team. Maybe a #3 though. But if Lauri is your robin to batman - you have big problems. He is a skilled big, but he is also flawed. His ability to stay on the court is another issue.
  9. It is a fair point - I said at the time they got Foles it was a TERRIBLE move. I couldn't stand it - cause he is totally mediocre at best. The only thing I could figure is with COVID they needed something serviceable - so they weren't fully invested in Trubisky - since there were enough doubts there.
  10. Is he specifically stating Bears fans? I saw someone quoting a deal involving Roquan Smith. I am just going to sit back and wait to see what actually happens. But I also have to admit - the rumors yesterday were so one-sided in terms of what the Bears would be giving up. It was like a total no-brainer. But no - I wouldn't support 2 1st round picks - unless Bears were getting like 2 2nd rounders back or something like that - than I could probably live with it - but wouldn't love it - knowing Wentz has an injury history and thus chance he gets hurt and the team is truly awful (with no QB).
  11. Howie roseman sounds like a disaster and I can't tell if Pederson kind of had success get to him or just couldn't stomp it out. But I certainly am not going to say Wentz is perfect either - he does sound like he has some Cutler in him - in the sense that he is going to maybe stick to his small circles when he feels uncomfortable / pushed. But that is when he's been pushed / not feeling trust - it sounds like when he is in a good place - he can be and has shown to be a pretty dynamic leader...which Jay never did (he was always the more reserved guy who was obviously not the natural leader most people think of when they think of QB's). I just think the above negative narrative has been way overplayed like you said so elegantly - his former coaches seems to think otherwise.
  12. Thibs is loyal to his former Bulls. He's done a nice job with Knicks - #6 rated defense and some semblance of a real basketball squad. Thibs has his issues - but he is an excellent head coach. Sustainable HC - maybe debatable - but from a pure x's & o's & overall coaching perspective....he's so darn good.
  13. Everyone knows where I stand on Wentz - but don't you find it interesting - that the reported teams showing the most interest are the Bears & Colts. We all know the Bears have a desperate front office / coaching staff - so we can discount that. But they also have the QB coach (Defillipo) who worked with Wentz at his best and nothing about that experience has been enough of a red flag. Similarly - the Colts have Reich as HC - who worked with Wentz at his best and they seem to be aggressively working towards Wentz. Now - I have no idea why if I'm Wentz I'd choose the Bears of Colts - so at some point - if Eagles give Wentz any consideration - I would think Wentz would lean to Colts over Bears - since Reich is HC and on pretty sturdy ground. However - the lure of a major market could be a big deal too - plus maybe staying in NFC and sticking it to the Eagles. I don't know how Wentz is motivated - but if he has any of that Rodgers edge to him - I could see him being a MONSTER next year (in as good a way as possible).
  14. Your last point is spot on - he literally didn't look like he was there. Whole 2nd half - he just kind of looked like a malfunctioning robot.
  15. This entirely - I don't want a bunch of lottery protected late round 1sts. Not helpful / not useful. Not for someone of Lavine's caliber. No thank you.
  16. I thought Bmags post in the other thread was absolutely perfect. Everyone asking the Bears to do nothing - well - that isn't what is going to happen. The front office brought back Pace/Nagy for at least another year. So recognize the fact that they aren't going to just blow it all up. It isn't happening. I recognize that for most on this board - that is the only outcome that is acceptable - but you know what - it isn't happening this year. And instead of rooting for pure misery next year - I'll root the opposite and hope that the defense refinds its way to top 10, with Goldman coming back and maybe a bit better scheme. And I'll hope the franchise can maybe find a guy who can be a top 10 QB in this league at a reasonable deal - without mortgaging the future.
  17. Geeze - rip. Gomez news came out of nowhere.
  18. Yeah - i kept telling people during the week - those oline injuries were potential game changing. The backups were abused against the Bucs strong pass rush. Didn’t help that Bucs had big lead and Mahomes was forced to pass on literally every play.
  19. That was a tough catch - Mahomes was pretty darn bad tonight. Pressure got to him - and he didn’t help things. Held on to ball way too long and was just a bit out of control all night. My wife kept saying he didn’t mentally look right - I agree. Easily the worst game of Mahomes career. And damn - Brady and that whole offense was fantastic as was the defense. Total domination.
  20. I'm not going to lie - I am in total shock. I could have seen the Bucs win - especially with some of the Chiefs injuries - but never did i see the Chiefs look this poor offensively for 3 quarters. I want to see a game - so hopefully they score a TD here and see something interesting.
  21. Really? All I saw was a bunch of Chiefs DB's holding and committing penalties on literally every possession. It was pathetic defense and incredibly undisciplined.
  22. I just expect iowa bball will choke - it is what they do best. Last year was the time they didn’t and of course the tourney never happened. The long layoffs messed with their funk - and they have lost to good squads - but just sucks.
  23. Lavine with a stud performance last night - Williams had back to back real good games as well (which was nice to see). Williams really passes my eye test.
  24. The question is - is the fact the Eagles are leaking this - them trying to drive up the price for another team - or is this just a bunch of crap.
  25. This is so not going to happen. I know I am a huge outlier - but I am so giddy at the though - especially in a scenario where Bears are basically just trading back from 1st to 2nd round. For anyone who can ignore 2020 (which is just 1 year). This is Wentz from 2017-2020. Yes - I would sign up any day for the Bears to get a QB who can rank like that over a 3 year span. Its also that INT% - which he consistently barely threw - that makes me kind of ignore the 15 he threw with a horrendous oline and no WR this past year. 4th in TD% 3rd in INT% 5th in QBR 9th in YPG 8th in Wins

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.