Everything posted by Chisoxfn
-
Market/Financial Thread
No - at this point - the whole keep buying game stop is a ponzi scheme - everyone in that who is late to the party is getting duped and is going to get burned. Period. You are buying nothing but a gigantically inflated asset. The only way to get out of that asset is to sell and at some point - people are going to sell. I can't imagine all of these people are going to keep owning gamestop for years to keep this up. Once the shorters lose - fine - they lost - but you still have all of this retail money in the stock - at some point the bubble is going to burst and valuations are going to be what they are and when that happens.....all those retail investors are going to get burned. The big shops - with diversified portfolios - they'll have a big loss here - but they'll survive with the diversification of their portfolios - but the little guy/gal - who went heavy into this play and overplayed their hand - they won't get it back and it will set many people back years. Note: Lets not pretend there aren't some people out there who had worked hard to save up $50K or $100K and decided to put a big chunk in this. Yeah - there will be some who do great and got out when the getting was good...but all they really did was take the money of the other mom and pop investors who played the hand and didn't get out in time. Hope everyone feels good - you think you are getting the hedge fund - and you might - but the collateral damage will be all the other mom and pop investors that got robbed when the bubble bursts (and yeah - those people who lose - well that is on them too - cause they are responsible for their actions).
-
NFL Thread 2020-2021
I'm with you on the cap stuff - its kind of why I think it will be pretty hard to have a really good team around Watson his first year here. And to be honest - even if I move Mack and Robinson - with Watson coming on - that is still a pretty decent team and the defense is still middle of the road. If Eddie Jackson were to bounce back (not betting on it) and Johnson were able to take a step forward (and before he got hurt - the advanced metrics on Johnson said he was an OUTSTANDING man corner - who struggled in zone - zone is way easier - so he should be able to improve with a regular offseason there and make a next step). A defense with Fuller and Johnson (if both play to their capabilities) will be pretty decent, especially with a Hicks/Goldman duo on the line - enabling them to not get destroyed in the rushing attack. Honestly - I think if you did the above - Bears are still potentially a playoff team - but highly unlikely they are a super bowl team.
-
NFL Thread 2020-2021
By the way - I still think the most likely scenario is the Bears drafting a young pick and grabbing a veteran FA QB. And while I think a lot of people assume Lions won't move Stafford to the Bears - I have a feeling the Lions are going to do Stafford a solid and move him wherever he wants to go. Mac Jones has apparently been crushing it at the senior bowl (although I think he rolled his ankle and won't play). He had massive talent around him - but made a lot of NFL type throws and seems to be a very good decision maker and accurate with the ball. Reality is in the new NFL - it is less about the elite arm strength and more about the mental game, accuracy and your ability to anticipate reads. And those last pieces can be so hard to evaluate in the college game when so many of the top qb's play on teams where they don't really have to throw the ball into a lot of tight windows and anticipate because they can wait until there guy is wide open. If I'm Pace/Nagy and want to save my job - as long as I find a young QB who shows promise - that alone probably buys you time (regardless of record - if the young QB shows hope/promise - that is all I think McCaskey will care about). For those reasons - the last thing I see Pace/Nagy doing is not drafting a young QB (or acquiring someone like Tua/D'Arnold); They might go after a Winston or something - but not alone - because if they get Winston and he stinks - they are dead. To me it is either a Watson or Stafford - where you are going all in on them. In Stafford's case - you are betting change of scenery and defense bounce back give your team hope (probably unlikely you get the ceiling you expect - but who knows). Or you are going all in on getting a young QB of some sort (whether a Tua/D'Arnold or a QB not named Wilson/Fields/Lawrence - but in the Trask/Jones/Lance bucket. Note: I don't think Matt Ryan, Derek Carr, Teddy Bridgewater types are going to move the needle at all. Also note - Matt Stafford is only 32 - kind of crazy when you think about it.
-
Market/Financial Thread
We are super aligned. I'm shocked at all the people who think what is happening is okay - everyone should recognize it is the regular person who is going to get crushed at the end of the day. What Gamestop - a brick and mortar gaming company (in a world of digital) - is going to maintain a $10B + market cap for the next how many years? Come on now - a ton of people are going to lose a lot of money in this. This is no different than a ponzi scheme where the early entrants will get rich and everyone else will be left holding the bag. I get the overall sentiment - and I'd agree there needs to be more evaluating on the shorters on the market and there is never any doubt to me that the big shops have an advantage (more data / more access / more scale which can drive momentum desired ways) - but I am just so anti what is happening right now - because literally - it is a bubble - and when it bursts - everyone still owning shares (which are going to be regular people) are going to end up losing big chunks of money.
-
NFL Thread 2020-2021
So I'll bite...even though I shouldn't. Have to give a presentation to like 100 people in a few hours - and just as much of a presentation as it is an open grilling session (good grilling - hopefully - but one where you got to be agile and nimble and know your "sh*t:", but this is a nice small distraction, hopefully to help clear my head. I'll caveat that I agree with whichever posted said trading the farm for Watson is going to make building a good team around him tough - at least in the near term - which is part of why my trading only works if the Bears can accumulate some extra assets this year so that really you are making a huge investment in Watson today - recognizing the step to greatness isn't going to happen overnight (because from a cap/asset perspective - they will have issues) - but having that true franchise QB is where you have to start. If Bears unequivocally believe Watson is that guy - than I think almost any price is worth it - because it isn't just about the next 1-2 years - it is about the 5-8 year window you have with an elite QB. I will also note - I don't see the Bears getting Watson by having the absolute strongest package - so at some point - Watson is going to have to tip the scales a bit in the Bears favor for this to work. The Bears will clearly not be the best team looking to acquire Watson - so for this to work - Bears are going to have to convince Watson (from ownership to GM to coach) that he is their guy and that they are going to build this entire franchise around him and make him a legend in Chicago and around the NFL. Endorsement deals - Love of the City - etc. But realistically - they are going to have to sell them on their commitment to do that over time - cause there is almost no scenario where I see Watson arriving and the Bears just being immediate superbowl contenders - unless instead of what I do below - the Bears sell like the next 4 years worth of draft picks - which I do not condone. Step 1: Move Mack - Get maximum value and my hope is you are talking at least 2 2nd round picks (ideally you get a 1st and a 2nd - even if one of those is a future pick - I don't care). And for those that say you can't get that - I don't believe it. All advance metrics still say Mack is a well above average pass-rusher and while his production dipped with the Bears - he's still widely viewed as an elite player and pass rushers (next to QB's) still have high value. This is a move that is necessary - as Bears need to find other assets - plus I think they need to move Mack for increased flexibility in terms of future cap usage (think 2022 & beyond). Note: I do this in almost any scenario if I were the Bears front office - because I think they need to find a way to develop their offense and I think Mack gets in the way. Although I would caveat this is something they could always do in another year (presuming Mack doesn't suffer a serious injury) and potentially under a new front office (depending on how 2021 goes). Step 2: Franchise and trade Allen Robinson - Get whatever you can for him - maybe it is a 2nd round pick - maybe it is a future 2nd round pick or 3rd round pick - but you can not fit Robinson's contract on the Bears. As much as I like Robinson - with the holes this club has - you can't afford paying Allen Robinson $20M per year; Note: I do not know whether the Bears can do what I outline above and still be in a cap position to fit Watson's contract under the books - but I'll leave that to another post who can verify or not. Step 3: Trade your 1st round pick, your 2nd round pick, the picks you acquired for Mack (1st round & future 2nd round) and next years 1st round and 2nd round pick - for Deshaun Watson. That would be 3 1st round picks (2 in this years draft; 1 next year) & 3 2nd round picks (1 this year & 2 next year (1 being the Bears & 1 being a pick you got from Robinson or the other Mack pick). I personally don't think that deal alone is going to be as good as what a team like Miami could offer - and maybe it isn't enough or I'm unrealistic in what I can get for Mack/Robinson (its possible). If that is the case - an alternative would be packaging Roquan Smith in the deal - although my preference would be to keep him as a young defender. In this scenario - Bears still potentially have a 2nd round pick and than the rest of their draft after 1st round and only essentially mortgaged next years 1st / 2nd rounders as well. None of the above is probably realistic - but hey - its a starting point. The thing I don't know is how much cap space / would they have cap space to do this?
-
The Wainwright to the Cards Thread
I still blame you for ruining my day 12 years ago. hahahaha.
-
NFL Thread 2020-2021
One thing about Watson - if you are Houston - despite the Jets and Dolphins having better chips - do you want to trade Deshaun within the conference or do you feel better sending him to the NFC. Would be great if Houston's ownership group had a view of keeping Deshaun out of their conference as that a number of the best suitors off the table (Colts, Jets, Dolphins). I saw somewhere, might have been ESPN - but basically someone suggested 3 way deal with Bears getting Tua for the 20th pick plus some future picks. While I don't love Tua - I wouldn't hate it either. If you are right - you quickly have shifted the franchise and if you are wrong - you take another swing in a year. In this case - you really haven't mortgaged the future (which is what it will take to get Deshaun and while I've always felt Deshaun is a bit on the over-rated side...I'd still be open to just doing it to get a young QB in his prime...even though you know they'll be in asset/cap trouble for at least 2 years).
-
NFL Thread 2020-2021
The good news is - Bears could go to that well in a year anyway and if you landed a new QB this year and shifted to a new coach in a year, I guess the bright side is if you think the issue was the operator (Nagy) vs. the Reid Scheme - than going back to Eric B kind of embeds a bit more consistency for a QB not having to learn an entirely new scheme when the coaches change.
-
NFL Thread 2020-2021
TO this day - I don't think it is a bad move not to pay a wideout top dollar. I think from a pure roster construction move - it can be the right thing to do. The problem was - they didn't communciate with their star QB and the bigger issue was they got pennies on the dollar in terms of the value. When I look at the Bears - I know their WR corps is going to be brutal without Arob - that said - If they could franchise him but let him play the market and eventually flip him for a 2nd (or even a future 2nd round pick) - I would make that move because for the long haul I think it is the best play. Reality Watson's best play is Miami. THey have a good young defense and are probably the team that would be least decimated by trading up the assets. I don't know if Houston wants Tua - but if they didn't (and I really didn't like what I saw from Tua) - if I were the Bears I'd probably see if I could get Tua for pennies on the dollar and take a shot. With the COVID off-season and him recovering from his serious injury at Bama, maybe he just needs a bit more time. And if it doesn't work out - no harm / no foul.
-
Market/Financial Thread
Yeah - the gov wasn't doing a bunch of hedge fund bailouts that I recall. Nor do I see them getting bailed out in this scenario.
-
Market/Financial Thread
Southsider can correct me if I am wrong - but both are legitimate - while one has more downside risk then the other. The first scenario - where you are borrowing stock - you actually are at risk of having to put up more capital - to cover your losses, while on the option trade is a synthetic way - you are just at risk for what you investmed. My overly simplistic views of the first scenario (someone can correct me if I'm simplifying too much), which is presume is the bigger driver of this as I think most hedge fund in a short position are using this version vs. the synthetic version - although I'm sure the reddit day traders may be doing a lot more of both. Scenario 1 - you borrow $100 worth of stock and pay a price for it - great - you borrow it on margin and don't pay full price....but you are going to owe the stock back to who you borrowed it from at full price. If stock goes down, I borrowed $100 worth of stock and give it back to them at $90 and make $10. Depending your margin limit - you still need to put up collateral to short the stock (meaning you don't jus get the $100 for free - you need to put up real cash / collateral to borrow it). If the stock instead goes up - than you are going to have to continue to increase your collateral to cover the short position (thus you are putting more and more money in). There are limits to how much you can borrow (since ultimately you are getting credit). History lesson - but 1929's stock market crash that fueled the great depression was heavily driven by excess margins (and governors and limits were implemented post the 1929 crash).
-
2021 Hall of Fame Ballot
I kind of take the other view of put them all in (Raffy is an exception - he was always very good - but in my opinion was never the top / elite guy at his respective position). All the other names you mentioned were and they did it in an era where all the results are questionable. So with that in mind - I get making them sweat it out - but they were some of the most memorable players for a 10+ year era and all were elite in an era that has a lot of question marks - but no one can deny their eliteness in that era so to me - they are HOFers. Schilling is super borderline so I get the argument there - won't get into the politics of it because I don't think repub or democrat should matter - but lets all be honest here - his views are not mainstream...so lets not pretend this is a right vs. left thing.
-
Market/Financial Thread
I don't find that guy inspiring at all - he is going to stick it to a ton of people who are going to get bit when it all comes crashing down (which it will).
-
2021 Hall of Fame Ballot
I don’t remember anymore whether Jeff Kent was every actually hit by steroids, but as a player he was one of, if not the greatest offensive 2nd basemen of all time. Nearly 400 hrs, 50 plus WAR. Top at his position in the league for a long time - seems like a sure fire HOF to me.
-
Hector wrong. Again. - Cruz back with Min
Considering that Robert, Moncada, and Eloy should all get better and Tim should stay at or near his levels for a while - I'm not that worried about the drop off of the above guys. I have hope that a combination of Vaughn, Madrigal, Kopech, Croquet, and Cease can also elevate their games to levels that will make us not that worried about Abreu, Lynn, Grandal, and Keuchel's eventual drop-off or shifts out of the organization. Beyond that - there are probably people I am not thinking about as well, who might surprise in their development and while I'm sure there will be other less positive surprises - the org should still be capable - if they win as much as I think they will - to continue to invest in some moderate level of free agent moves and/or use assets not named to the left (or ones to the left) to enhance the team. So long story short - while I could gripe - I fall into the camp that on paper this team is so good I'm not super worried and am just excited to watch what should be another fun season of White Sox baseball and hopefully a rare opportunity for the club to have back to back playoff appearances (and hopefully even more).
-
Hector wrong. Again. - Cruz back with Min
The one big difference is - those teams didn't have well above average lineups and Michael Kopech / Crochet types waiting in the wings. But your point still remains solid. I mean - they aren't any thinner in the rotation this year than they were a year ago when they were one of the better teams in baseball...in fact they are deeper. So do they need a Wainright...one could argue no....that isn't to say I'm not in your camp where I'd much much prefer to have one. By the way - well played on the obscure Latos reference. Forgot all about his tenure with the Sox.
-
Hector wrong. Again. - Cruz back with Min
Once Vaughn is up - you have Leury and Eaton, one of which gets more AB's and the other can fill in for others in a pinch. I like Leury, other than fact he gets hurt. Add in Mazara and others and I'm not too worried. Moncada / Abreu's reversion to mean/respected regression should normalize and I suspect arrow only shooting up for Jimenez and Robert. Grandall, Anderson are solid bats to be around where they were (I recognize Timmy has been amazing so maybe some downside...but if he was a little worse than last year - that is still pretty awesome). Just in this mini paragraph that is 6 good to above average bats. Round it out with Vaughn, Eaton, Madrigal, Collins, and Leury and that is nothing to sneeze at. If Madrigal is just solid and Vaughn is anywhere close to as good as people say - that is an absurdly strong lineup. In the past I had to hope like 7 guys would have career years for the Sox to contend - now I'm just asking people to be somewhere in the barometer (up or down) of what they can be and/or have been - as long as they do that - this is going to be a good to great offense.
-
2020 NBA Regular Season Thread
He was bad - but he never started. As much as I'd like to knock Gar Pax, drafting players over their tenure was pretty low on the list of reasons to dislike them. And missing on the 29th overall draft pick is not such a big deal, especially when you think of the Butler/Taj picks. Obviously the fact that they ignored Thibs who wanted Draymond - that hurts.
-
Hector wrong. Again. - Cruz back with Min
I agree with you here - I was shocked they didn't go that route. Seemed like the perfect depth move for the team. I'd much rather have spent money on Q and completely ignored RF.
-
Hector wrong. Again. - Cruz back with Min
This.
-
Hector wrong. Again. - Cruz back with Min
The lineup has quite a bit of depth and you have Vaughn, Crochet, and Kopech waiting in the wings. I'd say there are teams with a lot less depth than the Sox - but I'd also say odds of the Sox having Dodger depth is just crazy talk given the payroll constraints they would always be under.
-
Hector wrong. Again. - Cruz back with Min
I'll correct you slightly - I think there were 2 needs - filling the closer spot (since Colome was a free agent) and rotational depth. RF was never a key need and much more of a nice to have. No team is going to have 9 studs in the lineup - so any resource spent on RF was a premium need in my mind vs. going dumpster diving, which is what they did in Eaton. And to be honest - if Mazara is coming in as well, with a full spring, I wouldn't be shocked at a bounce back campaign from Nomar either. But I'll live with the two of them and if it truly becomes a need - go acquire someone at the deadline. Rotational depth is critical though - and they certainly bolstered the top of the rotation and the depth by acquiring Lynn - they still have a ton of uncertainty in the backend of the rotation. Still - I'd be surprised if they don't add someone on a 1 year deal. I'm just really shocked it wasn't Q, but at this point I'll assume Wainright and to be honest - while I might have prefered one of Q/Richards/Wainright - the reality is which of the three will be better is probably a total crapshoot next year anyway. Although I tend to think Q has the highest floor of the group - when it comes to liklihood of being durable.
-
Hector wrong. Again. - Cruz back with Min
My assumption still is they look to extend Gio and Lynn. In which case - I get more on board with the off-season. Reality is the biggest acquisition of the off-season was Lynn. Hendricks was nice and the bigger price - but overall production wise (relative to 2020) he was pretty close to a wash vs. Colome (not saying Colome is better - just that last year there was a neglible difference between the 2 relative to White Sox W/L, etc). But Lance Lynn - the playoffs look a lot different if you got Lynn's production out of one of the spots in the rotation. Personally - I'm happy. My bigger worry is if they went all-in and dealt a ton of the future away. I like the squad currently constructed and appreciate that the team maintained flexibility and maintained projectable high upside assets who can help extend this teams window. But I'm more of a - build a team for an extended window of sustained winning vs. focus on a 2-3 year period where you go entirely all-in kind of guy.
-
Twins sign Simmons to 1-year/$10.5MM deal
I know where you are going - but he's pretty much been a .275+ hitter the last few years. He hasn't been that .220 guy since he went to the Angels. It is empty but he's been within a stone throw of .300 most of the past few years.
-
Hector wrong. Again. - Cruz back with Min
Is Spencer still in the organization?