QUOTE(White Sox Josh @ Sep 22, 2005 -> 05:34 PM)
than how come Josh Beckett was a nominated in 03 when he was 9-8 in the regular season.
Nominated for what? The only guys to recieve votes for Cy Young in '03 were Gagne, Schmidt, Prior and Russ Ortiz. Beckett won World Series MVP that year, but that's the only award he even recieved a vote for.
You're Beckett arguement doesn't hold up.