bmags

Is it fair to say your position would be you would support the mlb giving umpires some say in regulating on field celebrations if they also eliminated player retaliation measures in earnest?

Tim didn't do anything against the mlb rules though. Keller did. Personally I'd be more concerned about teaching kids that if someone does something that hurts their feelings, they can react violently and that's okay because of vague unwritten rules.

If you knew nothing else about baseball you would be so confused when you learn tim is talking about a controversial topic.

I already want to downvote my own comment but Tim Anderson and Bryce Harper on the same team would have been fun.

Let's continue the anderson discussion here since the game threads get confusing. Going to move some posts in

FYI, going to move this into an active thread.

Had Tim hit the home run and stared down the pitcher, or the catcher, then I get it a bit more. But the "not showing respect for the opponent" stuff is weak. Drawing attention to your accomplishment (demonstrative bat flip, cheering at teammates) should not be considered disrespectful. There could certainly be a line thats crossed, but so long as its in celebration and geared toward teammates, I think it is absolutely awful to justify doing something that could seriously injure. He was hit in the butt this time, but contrary to popular belief, pitchers aren't that accurate, and also routinely lose control of the ball. It's a dangerous, dumb act, one that's quite disrespectful to the game.

Weird, I thought I remembered reading some terrible larry article on SSS about how there wouldn't be a babip regression for Collins because he sucks (basically every larry article ever)

https://www.mlb.com/whitesox/prospects/stats/affiliates

Maybe this settles down a bit as pitchers get better with new ball, but crazy how big the home run jump was.

Yes. And people have to stop acting like the job of the announcing team is to flatter their own intellect.

Hasnt Collins consistently had very low babips?

A lot less fun so far. It's a big, big jump to both. They will adjust.

My take: The "act like you've been there before" mantra was created in response to the overly PC times of its day to protect the low self-esteem of players in its generation who could not take being embarrassed. This generation, with higher self esteem and ability to be offended without becoming violent, does not need this rule. Classic generational rift.

Yeah all of the sniping is ridiculous but Sox fans will love an us against them guy. But I suspect Grichuk got brainwashed while in St. Louis.

Damn that might start a riot

grrrb.

blech.

I wouldn't give mccann anything here

Rondon my boy.

Nice being able to throw rondon at it too this inning. He makes nice hard contact, could swing an xbh. Let's do this eloy.

Shame we don't have anyone to run for him.

dying for a walkoff.

woops wrong thread.