I listen to the score all day long and neither of those guys has labeled Mitch as awful. Inconsistent, yes, but never awful.
The awful takes are definitely coming from the bloggers that are charting every throw he makes. And even those guys are arguing with each other about how to evaluate him.
and I totally agree with @ptatc, facing this Bears defense is no joke. Roquan Smith is matching Cohen stride for stride out of the backfield