It will be interesting to see how the OF situation plays itself out.
A couple of things that stick in the back of my mind:
Leury Garcia is finishing up his first year as an arb player, and it getting set to hit his second year. Garcia has never been able to muster playing more than 87 games in a season, primarily due to injuries in the last couple of years. He got paid just under $1.2 million this year, and may well be into the $2 to $3 million range for next year. Do they offer him a contract based on his inability to stay healthy and his escalating arb status?
Avi Garcia is finishing his 2nd year as an arb eligible player, having been paid $6.7 million this year to play about half of a season. Most of his numbers regressed pretty hard core this season, and he may well be looking at a $10 million pay out this year.
While the Sox have the money to pay both of these players, have we gotten to the point where the roster spots might be worth more to the team than anything else? We already know for a fact that even in a big time year like last year, the offers for Avi were never interesting enough for the White Sox to trade him after a career year. Now we are coming off of an injury filled year. I don't think you can even look at him as a possible trade asset anymore. Leury's best case scenario is as a utility guy, but he can't stay healthy long enough to attract interest.
Looking at 2019, if you leave out the dueling Garicas, that means you are looking to create an opening day OF between Engel, Delmonico, Palka, Tilson, LaMarre, Cordell, and maybe Jose Rondon as a wild card if he really does learn to play the OF respectably over the winter/spring.
Out of that group, I think you pencil in Adam Engel as the leader for CF and the most likely starter in the OF out of that group.
Palka is almost for sure on the roster somewhere, and in a scenario where Avi Garcia doesn't come back, he is probably the leading candidate for RF.
That leaves the rest of the mess to contend for two OF spots (1 starter in LF, and 1 bench), maybe 3.
In this scenario, I would have to handicap Nicky Delmonico as the leader for LF to start with, and probably Ryan LaMarre as the most likely back up OF because he has hit respectably, plus he can play CF when Engel needs a day off.
This would probably also be helped if Rondon did pick up some OF skills over the winter to become essentially what Leury was supposed to be coming into this year as a jack of all trades utility player who could back up OF and IF.
I think in pretty quick order Charlie Tilson is removed from the 40 man roster, based a lot on the fact he wasn't even recalled for September.
Then this all becomes really interesting in mid to late April when it is Eloy time and one more OF gets squeezed off of the roster. That might be when Nicky D goes back to the minors.
That is a pretty long way of saying, I think LaMarre sticks around, but others don't.