QUOTE (shipps @ Aug 14, 2015 -> 12:54 PM)
No content there for me? Did he delete it?
I don't know how well this will copy from facebook, but here goes.
Chris Rongey
22 hrs · Chicago, IL ·
This is a serious question, Herb Lawrence, and I think you're the one to answer it: How much hell would Robin Ventura and Don Cooper be catching right now for not teaching one of their starters how to hold runners?
Like Comment Share
Herb Lawrence and 19 others like this.
Ed Mlakar Why does it matter? Managers have nothing to do with how they play, right?
22 hrs · Like · 2
Chris Rongey That's kind of the point I'm making.
22 hrs · Like · 7
John Graces Apparently none. Abreu almost blew the game for us by not holding the runner to third in the ninth last night before completing the play
22 hrs · Edited · Like · 3
Jim Moskal Well all 3 White Sox fans in Chicago would be pissed off!
22 hrs · Like · 2
John Graces Excuse me, I take offense to that. There are four of us.
22 hrs · Like · 6
Jim Moskal Sorry
22 hrs · Like · 2
Ed Mlakar So you were thinking of me when you posted this? Lol what about guys who can't hit the cutoff man, who works with them on that?
22 hrs · Like
John Graces lol no problem
22 hrs · Like
Stephen Piff Remember when everybody used to run on AJ??
22 hrs · Like
Andrew James #FireRobin
22 hrs · Like · 2
Jon Greenberg "Listen chief..."
22 hrs · Like · 1
John Graces I think the point is that, unlike a sport like football, a manager in baseball has minimal affect on the play of his players on a play to play basis. That's why I keep saying that firing of managers is a move to appease a fan base more than anything else
22 hrs · Like · 4
Ed Mlakar That's bulls*** and Rongey knows its bulls*** too. I don't even know why he keeps up this argument lol
21 hrs · Like · 1
Chris Rongey Because I get it. And apparently you don't.
21 hrs · Like · 4
Herb Lawrence Managers are the scapegoat until the baseball media tell the public that they are smart. See Yost, Ned
21 hrs · Edited · Like · 9
Van Swanson I think the reaction is predictable if this one on the south side. I don't like it but I think at this point its something they needed to address in the off season and spring training.
21 hrs · Like
Chris Rongey The guy that was just in town (Scioscia) does the exact SAME kind of stuff Ventura does, yet he's regarded as a good manager. People are so full of s*** about this topic.
21 hrs · Like · 7
John Graces Exactly. How exactly does a manager take a player hitting .209, say something magical to him, and make him a .350 hitter? You can tell them to do this that or the other thing until you turn blue, and all it will do is make that hitter overthink. Same with defense.
21 hrs · Edited · Like
Chris Rongey He doesn't.
21 hrs · Like
Seán Walsh So, seriously then... I played HS baseball, I coached Little League, the double shift is not all that complicated. Why can't I manage in the Major League.
It clearly doesn't matter, right?
21 hrs · Like · 1
Ed Mlakar Chris, I get it. MLB teams pay managers to sit around and do nothing because they have money to burn, right?
By the way, you never answered my question. Who teaches players how to hit the cutoff man? If they haven't learned by the time they get to the big leagues, they aren't going to teach themselves
21 hrs · Like · 1
Eric Jozefowski Joe Maddon and Robin Ventura have nearly the exact same laid back style but Robin gets crushed and everyone crushes for Maddon
21 hrs · Like · 3
Van Swanson You answered your question Ed, they should have learned that stuff way before getting to the big leagues.
21 hrs · Like · 4
Ed Mlakar Ventura isn't Scoscia. Scoscia is bush league. Ventura isn't.
21 hrs · Like
John Graces Baseball is a game of reacting to a small ball moving at incredible speeds. Completely reactive. That's why a guy who gets a hit 1/3 of the time is considered a good hitter. That's part of why managers don't have much of an effect. Their bag of tricks ...See More
21 hrs · Like · 3
Ed Mlakar Van, I get that. But there are plenty of guys who are in the big leagues who haven't learned that skill. My point is, Rongey's attitude is that all mlb players know what they know and do what they do regardless of the manager. When he knows damn well that managers are there working with the players on stuff like that. That's why I don't get that logic
21 hrs · Like
Van Swanson Jon Lester cant throw to first so does that mean Boston, Oakland and the Cubs have coaches that all suck and should be fired? No, it means those teams deal with it and his stuff is good enough to get around it. No coach or manager can control what a player does once he has the ball or is in the batters box at that point its the players....
18 hrs · Edited · Like · 1
John Graces No, Chris's argument is that, by the time a player reaches the majors, it's way too late to teach those skills. They have years and years of bad habits to overcome. Doubly for those from Latin American countries where they tend to come to the majors at a later age, thus with even longer periods of time doing things the wrong way.
21 hrs · Edited · Like
Seán Walsh @ Herb, you mean he gets smart when he wins a pennant?
21 hrs · Like · 1
Van Swanson If a team signs a latin player and rushes them the the bigs thats on them, again, they learn how to play around their shortcomings...
21 hrs · Like
Van Swanson If there is a player who keeps having brain cramps on the fundamentals then the manager has to make a choice whether to sit him or play him, that's why they call it managing and not teaching.
21 hrs · Like
Seán Walsh Let's quantify my aforementioned baseball knowledge at 35. Let's put the average major league manager at 90. Isn't it possible that some managers are 95+?
21 hrs · Edited · Like
TommyHawk Barger Next thing Herb Lawrence is going to explain how coach Beckman has no effect on how illinois is going to do this year
21 hrs · Like · 1
John Graces Van, sure, but what big contact guys ever really get benched or sent down. It's too expensive to do something like that. So that's one tool in the Manager's Utility Belt that he can almost never use on any but the most inexperienced players or those wh...See More
21 hrs · Edited · Like
Van Swanson Abreu play last night, I'm sure someone said something to him about it but that's all they can do, if he does it again, when does he become accountable, he had the ball, he made the choice....if Ventura pulls him in those type of games then he is bad for taking out their best bat.
21 hrs · Like
John Graces Exactly my point. You always hear people say to bench this player or that. Are you going to be the one to explain to upper management why the player being paid $7 million is sitting on the bench?
21 hrs · Like
Van Swanson John...then the front office or GM make the decision to move the player. They don't get sent down because likely are are out of options and not going to sit because their positives outweigh their negatives....
21 hrs · Like
Rob Mangiameli Why do you care Chris? Managers have no impact and neither does Robin.
21 hrs · Like · 2
Chris Rongey Read above.
21 hrs · Like
Joel Gadawski Why is this important, please tell us more!!!!!
21 hrs · Like
Rob Mangiameli So they should save the money and get rid of all the coaches.
21 hrs · Like
Jeff Mamola Coops time is up...Ventura should have been gone at the conclusion of last season..this season is a total loss...hopefully Reinsdorf is fed up with the whole operation and will make coaching changes asap...
21 hrs · Like · 1
Carl Jeppson Chris, who has a better offensive team the Cubs or Sox? The Cubs have 1 player who has hit well. 2 with Schwarber who is new. The rest of the team has hitters below .250
21 hrs · Like
Rob Mangiameli I bet Robin i here for at lest 2 more years
21 hrs · Like
Chris Rongey Carl, Sox and Cubs are similar in OPS but the Cubs have scored more runs.
21 hrs · Like
Rob Mangiameli Actually Cubs pitching has really carried them. Once they face the Cards it'll be finished quickly
21 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR Another argument could be made that you could be a general manager of a baseball team and have no baseball aback ground just really good degrees.
21 hrs · Like
Rob Mangiameli Like Hahn?
21 hrs · Like
Rob Mangiameli I do however want to see a bigger body of work before judging Hahn. I still don't believe he's his own man.
21 hrs · Like
Jeff Mamola Bring back Ozzie...at least for the rest of this terrible...maybe he would inject a little life in this dead team
21 hrs · Like
Carl Jeppson The run differential can be misleading. Before getting Tulo and Price, Toronto was 2nd in MLB in run differential. I think we have to admit that Arrieta has been as good this season as Sale. Lester over Shark... and give the advantage 3-5 to the Cubs pitching staff who I don't think are all that good..
21 hrs · Like
Rob Mangiameli Jeff I doubt it. You'd never see a guy like Thompson or Rodon get a chance
21 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR And am not making this argument about Bringing anyone back
21 hrs · Like · 1
Rob Mangiameli he didn't like playing young guys
21 hrs · Like
Carl Jeppson Toronto has a ridiculous offense. They now have an ace to get them to the World Series
21 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR To be a GM I think you need have player development knowledge as well as scouting. Not just all contract negotiations skills
21 hrs · Like
Rob Mangiameli Ozzie JR you're old man will manage again. but I doubt with the Whie Sox. I think he's moved on and would serve better managing a veteran team
21 hrs · Like
Jeff Mamola At least there would be a spark of life..Ventura puts me (and obviously his team) asleep
21 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR I don't see white sox either I just don't as a fan
21 hrs · Like · 1
Ozzie Guillen JR And younger guys you are expected to loose and you have to make that the mind se
21 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR Set
21 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR He never had a young ties in Chciago
21 hrs · Like
Rob Mangiameli I think he'll end up in the N.L once again.
21 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR The fact Rongey compared robin to mike social is insane
21 hrs · Like · 1
Jeff Mamola No comparison the Angels manager
21 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR It's funny I don't ever remember post like this from him defending Ozzie or Greg walker.
21 hrs · Like · 1
Jeff Mamola to
21 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR Or anyone in the media saying managers don't matter
21 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR Does anyone else?
21 hrs · Like
Rob Mangiameli Mike Soscia has had success with less on the team, multiple playoff apearances
21 hrs · Like
Rob Mangiameli Robin right now has the legacy of being the worst manager in Sox history. That is a stone cold fact
21 hrs · Like
Tom Sheehan I actually thought Ozzie deflected pressure of "young" or inexperienced guys. They got to just play and people talked about ozzie.
21 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR If his name was bob walk would he still be the manager?
21 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR That's a question you should be asking?
21 hrs · Like
John Graces Rob, that is not a fact. Look at win percentages and there are plenty of managers in White Sox history with worse records
21 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR But hey baby hawk has all the answers
21 hrs · Like · 1
Tom Sheehan And by inexperienced I refer to not many guys on the sox played for good teams/playoff teams.
20 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR There has to be worst managers in sox history there has to be
20 hrs · Like
Rob Mangiameli Look it up Bevington has a better record Tanner had a better Record
20 hrs · Like
John Graces Of course there are. Someone it's letting their emotions get away from them. My argument has never been that managers don't matter, and if you're honest with yourself you can admit that neither has Rongey's. The argument is that, on a day to day basis ...See More
20 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR Comment like this is why the whole thing is insane. Sorry but it's delusional.
20 hrs · Like · 1
Ozzie Guillen JR "That three-game series against Kansas City, you could take us talent for talent, we're probably a little better than Kansas City. They execute better than we do. . .when they get a man on second, they get him over to third, and then they probably get him in. When they got a man on second and third and nobody out, they'll get at least one, and most of the time, two."
20 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR Those are the things that are said at games at its crazy
20 hrs · Like
Rob Mangiameli http://www.baseball-almanac.com/mgrtmcw.shtml
Chicago White Sox Managers (1904 - 2015) by Baseball Almanac
The Chicago White Sox managers with wins, losses, winning percentages, finishes and games behind the leader data.
baseball-almanac.com
20 hrs · Like
John Graces Fregosi is only better by six percentage points, Kessinger it's worse by 21 percentage. There are others that are even worse
20 hrs · Like
Rob Mangiameli Over a 4 year period no. Only Lou Fonseca comes close
20 hrs · Like
Steve Daly Rongey doesn't understand what is taught in the MILB level. The only reason I do is I have a nephew(and a lot of his HS and College teammates) playing in AA. These kids are not equipped with coaches that work individually with them on things they are s...See More
20 hrs · Like · 3
Ed Mlakar Jr, if your dad saw this thread, I think he'd wanna do a Mike North on Rongey lol
20 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR Steve good very good point.
20 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR Hey already those he named him baby hawk
20 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR Ozzie works for ESPN and they all lol at this theory
20 hrs · Like · 1
Ed Mlakar Absolutely right Steve
20 hrs · Like
Ed Mlakar Who's baby Hawk?
20 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR Chris Rongey is called baby hawk
20 hrs · Like · 2
Ozzie Guillen JR Was given that nickname
20 hrs · Like
Ed Mlakar Lol
20 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR In the Guillen house you say baby hawk it's Chris lol
20 hrs · Like · 1
Ozzie Guillen JR I follow the sox as a fan and dad does for work but to think his a fan deep down inside lol
20 hrs · Like
Ed Mlakar I wanna hear Chris talk White Sox next year assuming he's not defecting to WLS before I agree he is baby Hawk lol
20 hrs · Like
Ed Mlakar No matter what, I'm sure your dad will always be a fan on some level
20 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR Yes I agree just like me
20 hrs · Like · 1
Ozzie Guillen JR I don't root against them
20 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR Ever
20 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR But I get mad when stuff goes bad or not to the level its suppose to be.
20 hrs · Like
Ed Mlakar I get you. Probably been mad alot the last few years lol
20 hrs · Like
Ed Mlakar I always believed that Reinsdorf was made to choose between KW and your dad. He chose wrong
20 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR He always chooses his GM
20 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR Did it with tony Larussa did it with Phil jackson
20 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR But everything was meant to be
20 hrs · Like
Ed Mlakar Wow. Never thought of it that way...
20 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR Everyone is happy
20 hrs · Like
Ed Mlakar Yup everything happens for a reason. Happy is all that matters...Sox fans aren't though lol
20 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR No we are not. Cubs are getting hot
20 hrs · Like · 1
Ozzie Guillen JR Not good
20 hrs · Like
John Graces I really never understood firing your dad. I mean, I know why it probably happened, but that doesn't mean I understand why he was undermined. I was always a fan since I was a kid going to Old Comiskey, but I also don't understand calling to fire Robin because it's not like the tools he's been given are all together that great
20 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR Well technically not fired but traded
20 hrs · Like · 1
Ozzie Guillen JR Lol
20 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR Or allowed to talk to another team
20 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR I don't say fire robin at all. I think someone should be responsible for giving him this team. Someone if not him someone else.
20 hrs · Like
John Graces That is true. Now, I can't speak for Rongey, but the way I see it, the baseball manager does not have the freedom to do what needs to be done to help a struggling team. A manager can't bench your free agent acquisition because then that's millions wast...See More
19 hrs · Like
John Graces I didn't say you did say fire Robin, just part of the overall conversation.
19 hrs · Like
John Graces Unfortunately in a game where pitches come at you regularly at speeds of 90mph, the biggest factor can become luck along with reflexes. Those are two things that can't be taught.
Ozzie Guillen JR That's not true a manager with pull and respected can bench who ever he wants hence I still critique my father for playing Adam over and over
19 hrs · Like · 1
John Graces There are very few managers in today's game with that type of pull.
19 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR I think overall it's crazy how no ones head roled look at Detroit they fired maybe one of the best GM on the decade
19 hrs · Like
Steve Daly John, RV has just done some basic things bad. Last night was the latest example... Not having LaRoach in for defense in the 9th was a example.
19 hrs · Like
John Graces Once again, a move done to appease the fan base. Gotta look like we're doing SOMETHING so lets fire someone
19 hrs · Like
Steve Daly The fact is RV as great a white sox as he always will be never should of been handed the top job without any experience what so ever.
19 hrs · Edited · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR But hey this might be the new wave of baseball and manager don't matter just like crazy number guys. Am out of the game. Am old schoonbecuase the way I was raised and watch the game. So maybe this is the new wave
19 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR Now am just another fan with a fantasy team and a scoring degree lol
19 hrs · Like
John Graces Exactly. Even just looking at the personalities of managers and you see they're all vanilla.
19 hrs · Edited · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR Siting at his desk listening to sports radio making the moves for that nights game
19 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR Players are vanilla lol. Soft anyone who thinks his team is Hard is nuts
19 hrs · Like
Steve Daly Junior.... How do you know the make up of this team? Are you around them enough to make that assumption
19 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR I say other then sale and shark
19 hrs · Like
John Graces By vanilla I mean soft spoken with very little personality. I loved Robin as a player but he has no passion. The manager position has been turned into a position with no teeth.
19 hrs · Like
John Graces That's across baseball. The era of a manager who could push a good team and make them into a great team has unfortunately passed.
19 hrs · Like
Steve Daly I don't know about that John.... What makes you think that? I'm not saying you're wrong...
19 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR Yes I agree that's what jim leyland and tony la Russa talked about at a dinner a few months back.
19 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR It's crazy
19 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR I watch enough games and know enough guys and my overall guess. There are a few guys in this team who are all about eye wash
19 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR Abreu is a hell of a player but I think being a leader has been hard language barrier
19 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR I had this team winning 74 games 80 at best
19 hrs · Like
John Graces A manager that can push a team to become significantly better needs to have the personality of someone who people can follow (not necessarily boisterous) and the knowledge of the game to back it up. More and more, partially because of General Managers ...See More
19 hrs · Like
Steve Daly Jose shouldn't be in the spot to be a leader because of his limited time in the USA. I think the skip sets the tone up and down the roster starting 2nd week of Feb. That's what your pop Was so good at for the 1st 4 or 5 years. The last 2 were a abortion
19 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR Ozzie senior had them way way higher so lol
19 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR I put this season more on the GM and the marketing department then on robin and coaches
19 hrs · Like · 1
Steve Daly That's up with the dumbest things I've heard to say Junior
19 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR This team was over hyped from day one maybe robin did not have the talent to compete
19 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR Just like Ozzie two lost teams
19 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR Difference he new it and showed got his ass traded lol
Ozzie Guillen JR I think kW is a great baseball mind I am still waiting for Rick to shine or fall and see what he has. So far not a good start
19 hrs · Like
Steve Daly Look at this way...the white sox are still in it... Do I think they will make it. No. But there have been at least 4 games that the bench has blown on top of the 15 or so the players pissed away
19 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR They are still in what?
19 hrs · Like
John Graces I agree with the GM portion to a point. A team is only as good as the players the team can get or develop, and our issue is one of development. We're starting to see a shift with players now coming up through the farm system, but for too long we'd spen...See More
19 hrs · Like · 1
Steve Daly The 2nd WC
19 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR I would have missed with Dunn to
19 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR But why singed Adam eaton to multiple years?
19 hrs · Like
John Graces Ozzie, unfortunately some people are still under the delusion that we can get that wild card spot. Yeah, it looks like it's right there, but we have to be consistently good while too many teams play consistently badly to even have a chance.
19 hrs · Like
Steve Daly I got a good idea... Because Eaton is a real good ball player
19 hrs · Like
Steve Daly His slow start killed us, but he's going to be real good
19 hrs · Like
John Graces And Eaton is part of the reason we've played better in the last month, but it's not enough with a back end of the order that seems to be decorative.
19 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR They have no chance at that. That extra game wild card is such a mirage that is so hard to get. No chance to many teams involved
19 hrs · Like · 2
John Graces We got lulled into a sense of confidence because we got seven wins against two of the four worst teams in the AL.
19 hrs · Like
Steve Daly I wouldn't say no chance at all... it's baseball and things go one way or another quickly. We all know that. I doubt they can dig out of the hole the dug, but who knows.
19 hrs · Like
John Graces Yes we've had some decent showings against some better teams, but we can't beat KC and the Angels are a team in freefall
19 hrs · Like
John Graces Well, maybe not freefall, but they're on their way down the standings
19 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR Hope your right now a fan.
19 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR I just can't stand Cubs fan thinks they clinched the playoffs already
19 hrs · Like
Steve Daly JR I'm sure your ''eye wash" comment was directed at our CF.... I disagree 110% if it was. I see him being a difference maker on this team for some time to come
19 hrs · Like
John Graces I will always be a fan, but honestly I've reached a point where I have stopped paying any attention to the team that pays in that toilet on Addison
19 hrs · Like
Steve Daly I don't hold any hard feeling toward the Cubbie fans. They are on a run and they should be having fun with it. That being said, I'm looking forward to whatever curse like situation ends their season
19 hrs · Like
John Graces It's too much work to care about what the Cubs do. I'll just care about what my team does from now on. Yeah, I don't want the Scrubs to win the World Series, but otherwise I think about them very little
19 hrs · Edited · Like · 1
Ozzie Guillen JR I agree on that. And let's hope Adam probes me wrong and that eye Wash was for a few guys.
18 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR If he turns out to be good like he has shown lights off I will be the first one to say good singed even if I taking his tiring. Lol
18 hrs · Like · 1
Steve Daly I think the biggest move that Hahn has pulled off since the season has started is getting Doug Laumann out of the big seat in the scouting department. I hope the new kid is more up to speed with today's game.
18 hrs · Like
Van Swanson Wait....you want Adam to probe you wrong?
18 hrs · Edited · Like · 1
John Graces lol sorry Ozzie, but that's hilarious
18 hrs · Like · 1
Ozzie Guillen JR Eaton why is it hilarious?
18 hrs · Like · 1
Ozzie Guillen JR Steve right on point finally
18 hrs · Like
John Graces The probe joke
18 hrs · Like · 1
Ozzie Guillen JR Typos on the iPhone get you but yes
18 hrs · Like
Ozzie Guillen JR Prove sorry the other way sounded way to creepy
18 hrs · Like · 2
Chuck Babica Steve it's amazing how the Cubbie fans are coming out of the wordwork. Now I know why I've held such disdain for them for so long. The arrogance from most of them is nauseating.
16 hrs · Like
Steve Jankowski Out of the woodwork? Cubs fans have been getting ripped by Sox fans for showing up and supporting a bad team for years. Now that the Cubs are good it's "woodwork". Sorry chief! Not true
15 hrs · Like
Chris Rongey Ozzie Guillen JR, you have either a terrible memory, or it's selective. Either way, you need to get it together. I said the same things about the manager when your dad was here as I'm saying now. You're entitled to your own odd opinions, but not your own facts.