Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Soxtalk.com

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

caulfield12

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by caulfield12

  1. This whole retooling thing is coming from having the core of the pitching staff in place....Sale, Quintana, Santiago, Danks, Johnson, Reed and Nate Jones. So that we're RETOOLING our starting line-up/offense but not rebuilding our entire team. The problem is that every one of our starters offensively has a laundry list of flaws and could be replaced as early as 2015...with the possible exception of Avisail Garcia. Of course, with the state of the minor league system, it's hard to say that "retooling" is all that's needed. It's the entire, systemic approach of the organization that's being questioned, other than pitching development.
  2. I want the Pirates because their bench coach, Jeff Banister, was our manager in 1995 when we won the South Atlantic League championship with Augusta. That, and Pirates fans have been suffering for over two decades (Sid Bream/Terry Pendleton!) and it's one of those Rust Belt cities that deserves good things....well, unlike Cleveland and Detroit, haha. Finally, after reading the article about defensive positioning....they're showing the signs of a progressive organization that isn't trapped in Hawk Harrelson-ish "old school" baseball cliches. The adapted, they changed, they moved into the future, something I wish the White Sox would do more of. From most desired to least desired World Series winners... 1. Pirates 2. Dodgers (Puig Mania) 3. A's (so they'll get a new stadium deal finally) 4. Rays (I would have had them higher but with Price no longer dominant, can't imagine them getting far...beware Longoria in last game of the season though, my God...finally, of the small market franchises, the Gold Standard for success despite sub 20,000 in attendance on a nightly basis) 5. Cardinals (my favorite NL team growing up, you gotta admire 10/14 playoff appearances and how they've carried on without Pujols, the overall job Matheny and Mozeliak have done) 6. Braves (meh...don't want to see Greg Walker become a cult hero because it's their pitching that has carried them all season, kind of like Billy Beane's early 00's A's teams with Mulder, Hudson and Zito) 7. Red Sox 8. Tigers
  3. Except the Billy Beane Cult will start up again if they win the World Series. Still, that would be better for baseball, and maybe get the A's a new stadium. Just wonder if the A's have enough offense with Moss, Cespedes and Donaldson. Reddick's had a disappointing year....still with Lowrie and Crisp, they've got some pesky hitters. That catcher Vogt, another example of a player who was available to every GM in baseball. White Sox were forcing Flowers into the catcher's position at that point, when he was released.
  4. QUOTE (Vance Law @ Oct 5, 2013 -> 09:27 PM) 2012 OPS+ Ramirez 75 Beckham 80 2013 OPS+ Ramirez 86 Beckham 87 All of Ramirez's "consistency" still didn't average out to better than Beckham over the season. Beckham has improved each of the past 2 seasons even while having surgery on his hand. While Ramirez bounced back from 2012, his power and ability to draw a walk seem to have left him. But the biggest thing pointing to the difference in value of the 2 players is that Ramirez makes about 3 times as much money as Beckham. I'm a very big fan of Semien. But neither his 32 games at AAA nor his 21 games in the majors (OPS+ 78) have proven that he's currently a better hitter at the major league level than Beckham. And I don't know anyone who suggests he's better defensively. Therein lies the problem with the White Sox. They haven't developed anyone to challenge most of their major league regulars. There are no better options to replace Viciedo or DeAza (no, Danks isn't a regular!) As far as the Beckham situation goes, it's more of a "change of scenery" situation where they might trade him for someone like Dustin Ackley to give him a fresh start. I don't know exactly what Gordon's going to get in arbitration, but it's probably going to be $4.5-5.5 million. At a certain point, giving that playing time to Semien if he's expected to be the regular in the long term makes more sense. I have no problem trading Ramirez simply because I don't think he's going to outperform the rest of his contract. They can play Beckham or Sanchez at SS, it really doesn't matter until 2015. Beckham ALSO regressed defensively in 2013...showed diminished range, and the fact of the matter is that 2B in today's game are expected to provide a lot more pop than the SS position. We're still used to that steroids era when you have all those guys like Tejada, Garciaparra, Tejada, Jeter, etc., putting up huge numbers, but it's shifted away from SS to 2B in terms of power. I wouldn't be surprised if there wasn't a bigger difference between the average OPS at 2B and SS than between 3B and 2B. In other words, Beckham's just not getting the job done.
  5. Detroit Tigers Need to Send Justin Verlander to Bullpen from yahoo contributor network COMMENTARY | When the Detroit Tigers made Justin Verlander the highest paid pitcher before the 2013 season, it appeared baseball's best starter was only going to get better. What the team has witnessed this year has been far from a dream: it's a terrible nightmare. Verlander has struggle for much of the year, earning a rough 13-12 record with a 3.66 ERA. Though he has 195 strikeouts, the 30-year-old has yet to find an out-pitch, five months into the season. Maybe it's fans having unrealistic expectations after a 24 win 2011 season capped off with the Cy Young award. Or maybe it's a pure example of a fireballer suffering from wear, tear, and age. But his latest showing, September 18 against the Seattle Mariners, takes the cake. Verlander lasted seven innings, but allowed three earned runs, including a solo homer to Justin Smoak, against a light-hitting Mariners team that won 8-0. With the playoffs just two weeks away, the Tigers will be forced to make some difficult decisions. It's time they start doing that now. Send Verlander to the bullpen. Two years ago, heck, even last year, this would've been a crazy idea. But Verlander has fell so far from those days that even the Tigers' fifth starter, Rick Porcello, has out-pitched him. If the postseason started today, there would have to be some serious consideration to choose Porcello over Verlander, especially with a stronger infield defense anchored by Jose Iglesias. Verlander hasn't been himself at all this season, and the playoffs are no time to try to regain his confidence and ability to overpower hitters with ease. Again, the proof that he's not himself is found in his recent outing against the Mariners. Offensively, Seattle ranks in the bottom nine amongst major league teams. Their .239 average ranks 27. Verlander allowed three walks in the shutout, something that's received attention with his command issues. The Tigers have been shutout 11 times this season. Four of those have occurred with Verlander on the mound. Sure, Verlander only controls one side of that spectrum with him never picking up a bat. He can't account for the run support teammates provide him with. But that's not the point. Verlander's still considered an ace, the type of pitcher whom gives his team an opportunity to win a game every five days. Yet, he hasn't done that consistently this season, as Max Scherzer has taken over that duty Sending Verlander to the bullpen before the playoffs begin could be exactly what he needs. Scherzer had a similar demotion in 2010, but was rather sent down to Toledo to work on his craft. He returned to Detroit a much better pitcher and continues to be on the verge of winning his 20th game. So far, Verlander has avoided that type of demotion, even during his awful 2008 season. Being baseball's highest paid pitcher and having 137 major league wins, bullpen duties might turn out to be an embarrassment, but it could help Verlander turn his game around. At this point, anything's worth a shot. The Tigers are now 3-9 in games started by Verlander since the All-Star break. If they want to make a deep postseason run, it's time the team considers making a change. Ricky Lindsay has followed the Detroit Tigers and Major League Baseball with a close eye from Metro Detroit for several years. He's currently the sports editor for his college newspaper, The Michigan Journal, where he covers the University of Michigan football team on Saturday afternoons from Ann Arbor. You can find him on Twitter @RLindz35.
  6. Amazing game... Got to give credit to the rookie hanging in there all game long against Verlander. Lose this game and the A's are probably done.
  7. There wasn't really a specific incident with Logan. It was more about maturity (well, that's expected when you pluck a kid from A ball and stick him in the big league team, that happens about once a decade, usually with pitchers/relievers)....that they didn't like his attitude/cockiness, he wasn't getting along well with the coaching staff and was resistant to make adjustments or listen to instruction, etc. Sort of the same issues the Sox had with Nick Swisher, basically.
  8. QUOTE (southsider2k5 @ Oct 5, 2013 -> 08:37 PM) lol. I've gone over to the Dick Allen side for now. It's more fun.
  9. Guess Verlander's not taking too well to being skipped as the Game 1 starter. Ultimate competitor. Saw some articles saying that Verlander should be in the bullpen and his start should go to Porcello. Really?
  10. QUOTE (Brian @ Oct 5, 2013 -> 07:55 PM) I remember when folks were jacked for the 1998 Godzilla and it turned into one POS I think that was the last time that "lead actress" every appeared in a movie, lol. Would rather have seen Ferris Bueller's Day Off 2 (minus the Cubs' scenes), War Games 2 or Election 2.
  11. QUOTE (southsider2k5 @ Sep 30, 2013 -> 11:44 AM) We could well see an Edwin Jackson type of career from Santiago. Frustrating flashes of absolute dominance mixed in with irritating 110 pitch, 5 walk, 6 strikeout, 2 hit, 4 inning outings, add up into a wide range of years, and get pitching coaches fired. Except we're not talking a Top 3 draft pick with millions invested in him. Don Cooper's not going to be fired because of him. Cooper couldn't work any magic with Francisco Liriano and nobody blinked an eye...the "legend" continued. I've been a huge Santiago fan from the very beginning, and, if anything, I'm sure he will likely be much more successful with another organization and make us look stupid when we undersell on him.
  12. QUOTE (Marty34 @ Oct 5, 2013 -> 07:50 PM) Thanks for reaffirming my point. But the thing is, you will spend the next two years (at least) complaining about Hahn/KW before any type of change is made. Might as well be optimistic they might stumble upon the right player. Some of the former stud prospects like Domonic Brown, Davis and Pedro Alvarez finally emerged as impact players this season...so maybe Viciedo, Beckham and Avisail Garcia will likewise start becoming the players they were projected to be.
  13. Nobody saw Don Jon? That's the last movie that's ever going to make it through the censors here in Indonesia, so I'll have to wait until it's avail online.
  14. QUOTE (Marty34 @ Oct 5, 2013 -> 07:43 PM) Exactly. The Sox had the top "sealed bid" on the wrong guy. And so did 28 other teams. It was pretty much common knowledge from the very beginning that nobody was going to outspend Yankees' West. Lots of swing and misses. For the best GM's in the game. Like Mike Trout. Or picking up Chris Davis when he was available to practically every team in the league, etc. The last big time player we picked up was Quentin who had a huge impact on the offense.
  15. QUOTE (Vance Law @ Oct 5, 2013 -> 04:33 PM) The other thing to consider though is that Ramirez will be making $9.5 million compared $3 million and change for Beckham. You're probably right in that Alexei has been the better player the last couple years on the merits of his defense (though he did lead the league in errors this year) and it remains to be seen what Beckham could do at SS. Both are very good defensively and together the best double play combo in baseball. As a hitter, Beckham has been better than Ramirez in each of the last 2 seasons (even while having wrist surgery during that time) and he's going in the right direction. To me it's something of a tossup as to who's the better player going forward. Ramirez has the edge defensively and Beckham offensively in my opinion. It does. Which is why I'd say both of those stats # of hits and # of outs are not extremely useful in isolation. They really are largely a function of who gets the most plate appearances. Pedroia puts up a great OBP which is what's important. The fact that he plays every game, hits at the top of the order, and plays for a team with a great offense and therefore gets more at bats per game are what puts him on that outs list. Edit: I didn't realize Ramirez is under contract for 2015 as well. Maybe that means start Semien in AAA, see if he can dominate there. Beckham was going in the right direction? Are you sure you didn't skip the second half of the season? Ramirez was a much more consistent offensive contributor this season than Ramirez. I'm sure 1/3rd of the fanbase is ready to non-tender Beckham, if not more. If Carlos Sanchez didn't fall back this past season, then Sanchez and/or Semien would be your starters in 2014 (were they to deal Ramirez).
  16. QUOTE (Marty34 @ Oct 5, 2013 -> 04:45 PM) The Sox recent track record scouting hitters leaves me to believe that whatever their sealed bid is it will be way off. Like with Viciedo and Puig? They were in to the very last second on both of those guys. Cespedes, to a lesser extent. The only one they weren't pursuing hard was Soler.
  17. QUOTE (bbilek1 @ Oct 5, 2013 -> 11:35 AM) Funny how terrible reporting is these days considering the lady killed was unarmed. Probably because there WERE shots fired... But yeah, it would have been accurate to phrase it differently...imminent threat/harm situation, I don't know how you'd put it, but when someone comes at the White House, they tend to shoot first and ask questions later. Because the one time they really let their guards down, is the time something terrible happens to the President or VP, etc.
  18. QUOTE (bbilek1 @ Oct 5, 2013 -> 11:22 AM) Eric O' Flaherty or even Boone Logan would fit the bill. Boone Logan didn't leave the Sox on the greatest of terms. As long as KW's still around, don't see him coming back...any more likely than Jon Rauch coming back.
  19. QUOTE (KyYlE23 @ Oct 5, 2013 -> 09:01 AM) He didn't say anything remotely close to that Maybe if we trade for Joe Maddon and pay the Rays $30 million they'll also give us Dave Martinez?
  20. QUOTE (southsider2k5 @ Oct 5, 2013 -> 10:02 AM) IF anyone on the Sox ever said that, there would be meltdowns galore. There would be no more Darin Erstads or Mark Kotsays!!!! No....we can't have that.
  21. QUOTE (southsider2k5 @ Oct 5, 2013 -> 08:28 AM) And is five months younger. Everyone knows Ramirez and Viciedo are 2-3 years older than their "official" ages...
  22. QUOTE (Tex @ Oct 5, 2013 -> 06:54 AM) https://tcta.org/node/13678 I chose to teach in a district where there is a large migrant population, where there is a high level of poverty, where parents more often than not did not graduate from college. I am interested in how they will find a system that fairly allows my efforts to be compared to say Highland Park, Texas (which is similar to Highland Park, Illinois, if everyone in Highland Park, Illinois suddenly received large pay raises). Not only that, but I teach English Language Arts with a high percentage of English language learners. Perhaps that makes my job easier as gains are easiest to achieve with new motivated learners. Is it fair to use gains when a few times a year I receive students who are reading 7 grade levels below average versus other teachers who may receive mostly students reading above grade level. I am glad I am not trying to devise the system. I fear an unbalanced rating system will cause good teachers to flee these schools and head to where the going is easier. Which is about the opposite of what is necessary to keep the US competitive in a world economy that values intellectual skills over manual labor skills. Also we are taking away human judgement. Gone are the days where a supervisor evaluated the employees. We are trying to achieve an unbiased, numerical formula where one really doesn't exist. Depends on whether those teachers are more motivated by money/job security than they are the challenge and idealistic part of why they first got into teaching... There's long been a theory that if you raised the pay of teachers by some random number, let's say 25%, it wouldn't dramatically increase teaching quality. Of course, that's an argument usually made in public school districts where teachers' salaries are relatively high vis a vis "average" salaries in the surrounding metroplex and yet the schools are underperforming dramatically....say, for example, the St. Louis and Kansas City public school districts. A lot of ESL students are more motivated by finding a job as quickly as possible that provides them tangible benefits and skills...so in that system, you'd much prefer to teach them, let's say, Business & Management compared to Economics, which is much more theoretical and esoteric for high school students. I think there will always be a bigger problem evaluating great or above average "humanities" teachers (History, English/Rhetoric/Writing/Government/Philosophy or even Visual Arts or Debate) than, for example, Chemistry/Physics/Biology/Math...where standardized testing and the "universality of hard science" makes judging results more black and white. And of course, universities and parents are making the argument that those humanities teachers are not "worth" as much to their universities...and that's a dangerous slope to be on, where you start eliminating history classes to fit in more math/science or "back to the basics" approach. I taught in an IB international school in China the last couple of years and it was pretty easy to see which students scored the best...but proving a correlation with teaching "quality" versus class size versus natural ability/talent of those students, that's where everything becomes much more complicated. An evaluator might assume because we had two students with perfect 800 scores on the SAT and because the students are Chinese and "expected" to outperform in mathematics that their scores would be higher for HL Math than for HL English, but then if you look at the structure of IB grading, you'd realize you could be an average or below average English teacher and your students would still receive mostly 5's and 6's (out of 7) whereas a lot of the HL Math students might get 4's and 5's and have a MUCH better math teacher. Statistics can always be misleading, and always be twisted one way or another to protect/defend or attack a particular teacher's individual results.
  23. QUOTE (maggsmaggs @ Oct 5, 2013 -> 06:56 AM) I am convinced there is no "right" mentality to manage. Some players perform better for aggressive managers and some perform better for relaxed managers. Both styles have their pluses and minuses. Do you honestly feel Jerry Manuel or Terry Bevington were going to lead that 2005 team through the September collapse all the way back to the World Series title?
  24. QUOTE (Dick Allen @ Oct 5, 2013 -> 06:48 AM) First off, Dusty has been managing how many years? This is the first time I have ever seen that written as a problem, if it was, why would the Reds not only hire him, but give him an extension? Where has the same things been said about Ventura other than by people on message boards who come to that conclusion by the 2 or 3 shots of him shown in the dugout per game? I think this move was all about money. I think Reds ownership is thinking that point A to point B crap Krause used when he fired Collins. The article I read about cost of playoff tickets these days seems to me is going to put a lot of pressure on managers to avoid quick playoff departures. From what I read, a couple of these team could basically cover their entire payroll with a run to the WS just on playoff ticket sales alone. If that's the case, that the Indians were charging the most and were going to bring in something like $20 million per game...then there would be some incentive to fire Francona, but surely that's not the scenario. Likewise, unless the owner was Loria, it would have been nearly impossible for the Pirates to fire Hurdle even had they lost to the Reds (does the frustration of falling apart the two previous 2nd halves not get erased by breaking a two decade long playoff-less streak?). Following your line of logic, the pressure would be on the small market managers (the A's and Rays would be two other teams that jump to mind right away)...and yet Joe Maddon's job right now is probably among the most secure in baseball. Teams that are going to suffer financial setbacks if they get knocked out of the playoffs quickly without having had the opportunity to pocket all that additional revenue windfall. On the flip side of the coin is Don Mattingly, who the feeling is in LA right now that if he doesn't advance to the NL Championship (and perhaps win it or at least look like a convincing manager in losing) that he will be fired, and the Dodgers are THE Evil Empire West right now, yes? With the decision to walk Reed Johnson to face Craig Heyward in the rearview mirror...well, not even sure Ozzie Guillen at his worst would have done something that bone-headed. Finally, there's not a better franchise model in existence than the Cardinals, despite trying to upset the apple cart in the beginning with the 2nd manager hired with ZERO previous professional experience in Matheny. Rightly or wrongly, Ron Washington is going to be on the hottest seat of all beginning April, 2014.
  25. When I was reading this article, I thought about Jerry Manuel right away, and how we needed the opposite of Manuel at that time...and picked Ozzie. But it also reminded me of a lot of the same things that have been said about Ventura as well. Keep in mind, the Reds made the playoffs 3 of the past 4 years. The White Sox have only made the playoffs 4 times in the past 20 years. Besides the fact that this year's team SEEMED to be lacking in talent, competitiveness/comeback-ability and cohesiveness (well, you can say that about any team that loses nearly 100 games), what are the arguments for retaining Ventura, and by that, I mean "longer term," for at least the next 2-3 seasons? Do you worry that he's too passive? All those accusations about being not committed enough/uncertain...do you still feel 100% confident he's the right man for the rebuilding/retooling job ahead? http://news.cincinnati.com/article/2013100...040071?gcheck=1 The next man the Reds hire won’t be much like Dusty. He won’t list Jimi Hendrix’ All Along The Watchtower as his favorite song. And he will come with an edge that Baker never had, nor wanted to have. Of all the managers and coaches I’ve covered here since 1988, none wanted to avoid conflict as much as Baker. It’s too bad that conflict comes with the job. Baker’s inability to motivate his players down the stretch partly owed to that trait. He wanted to be a friend and mentor, not a leader. That played well when Scott Rolen was here. It failed this year. Somebody needed to kick some aspirations in the home clubhouse. It never happened. Ballplayers want to be led. Most of us do. We want to be inspired, pushed, challenged, driven. Choose your descriptive. Dusty’s style might have allowed his players to play free and easy. It also encouraged a certain complacency. No one who witnessed this team’s last week of games could come away thinking it needed to win. Wanted to win? Of course. Needed it? Not really. Baker lost points with ownership when he allowed Brandon Phillips to interrupt his daily pre-game media briefing, to berate an Enquirer reporter. He lost points by not saying to Joey Votto, “Hey, man, this is a team game. Runs help us win, not getting on base.’’ He lost points by not always being a team player himself. Baker is nothing if not stubborn. Suggestions made by those in charge were rarely heeded, be it lineup issues or the role of Aroldis Chapman. Mostly, Baker is out because his personality stopped working with the players he managed. That happens a lot in baseball. It’s a reason even good managers get fired, usually more than once. Baker is a good manager.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.