Everything posted by caulfield12
-
2013 MLB Catch-All thread
QUOTE (Brian @ Jul 9, 2013 -> 04:36 AM) Even in her prime, Anna Benson was not as hot as people made her out to be and she came off as a b**** in interviews as well. Her husband was overrated as well on the diamond. Not looking so good without all the make-up and the beauty of youth and plastic surgery to cover up her ugliness.
-
Managing a Rebuilding Team Wouldn't Scare Ventura
QUOTE (GreenSox @ Jul 8, 2013 -> 04:42 PM) Hopefully, he won't have the opportunity to be scared. the White Sox need a professional, experienced manager who understands basic strategy (that befuddles Ventura), can evaluate talent and can develop talent and properly use the talent that he has. Ventura has shown none of these skills. Neither has Bell. Neither has Hahn, for that matter. Gillaspie was a good move, Keppinger a bad one. http://csnchicago.nbcsports.acquia-ps.com/...ite-sox-pulse-0 And what the hell is White Sox Pulse? If there was/is one, it's dead now.
-
7.8 Games
QUOTE (danman31 @ Jul 8, 2013 -> 09:56 PM) Hawkins is an embarrassment right now. Hopefully he can get his head right by next year. Someone with the Sox is going to have to play "bad cop" and tell him to shut down that twitter account. It seems to be an unneeded distraction to him at this point.
-
2013 MLB Catch-All thread
QUOTE (fathom @ Jul 8, 2013 -> 09:37 PM) Carlos Gomez with the play of the year to end the Reds/Brewers game Despite the impending Braun situation, Weeks falling apart and Aramis Ramirez going down like he was shot by a sniper just moving inches to his left, Carlos Gomez looks a LOT better than any player on the White Sox minor or major league roster. HIGHEST OBP on the Dodgers? Puig? Hanley Ramirez? Nope, Zach Greinke.
-
7.8 Games
Forgotten in all the discussion about prospects today is Carlos Sanchez. It's as if he doesn't even exist anymore.
-
2013 MLB Catch-All thread
http://sports.yahoo.com/blogs/mlb-big-leag...-213858535.html Anna Benson very much NOT quiet...
-
Game Thread 7/8: CUB @ SOX
QUOTE (Jake @ Jul 8, 2013 -> 05:35 PM) Let's brainstorm for a new manager. Someone with some fire in his belly! Guy can't be afraid to get in people's faces. Swear words are a-okay so that we know he's into the game. He should be very animated. He must speak the language of his Spanish-speaking players. Must be a former White Sox. World Series rings preferred. Any ideas??? This is your cue, Greg http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jeff_Banister Best manager I've ever been around. Now the bench coach for the Pirates in his 3rd full season. No nonsense, no mistakes tolerated, almost like a Marine Corps drill sergeant but everyone on the staff/front office respected the hell out of him and the players did too. Led us to the SAL championship in 1995 and has almost twenty years of experience now.
-
Midseason top 25?
QUOTE (Jake @ Jul 8, 2013 -> 04:03 PM) Phegley had a bad freshman year of college, so I'll say his 19 year old season in A ball would have been horrible. It's really apples and oranges. What would the comp for Hawkins putting up an 800 combined OPS all the way through the Carolina League last year at age 18? There simply isn't one.
-
Puig-Mania Thread
http://mlb.mlb.com/news/article.jsp?ymd=20...lb&c_id=mlb Why Puig not being in the game would be crazy http://mlb.mlb.com/news/article.jsp?ymd=20..._la&c_id=la Adrian Gonzalez throws his support to the PUIG campaign, cool move by a classy player
-
Game Thread 7/8: CUB @ SOX
QUOTE (fathom @ Jul 8, 2013 -> 04:33 PM) I agree that they'd be selling on him low right now. I also wonder why he is the scapegoat right now when so many others are making even worse mistakes than him. Simple, he's the youngest (lecturing him might have more of a positive impact as he's the most likely to be around, you don't criticize someone unless you really care about them and believe they can and will get better, etc.) or one of the youngest starters. Along with DeAza and Ramirez, his overall play has fallen off the most from 2012...but those other 2 guys are veterans and seemingly harder for a manager to criticize without running the risk of losing respect or the clubhouse itself (I would argue by seemingly NOT doing anything, he's lost some respect/fear as well). Next, there are more available options/alternatives at LF (Tekotte, Wells, Wise, Danks, Keppinger, Dunn, Jared Mitchell) than any position on the roster. We don't have natural back-ups for Ramirez and Rios. Third, he still has the most future potential if he puts it together of anyone on the roster. Fourth, everyone's tired of picking on Flowers and his replacement has already been brought up.
-
Possible Alexei Destinations
QUOTE (Dick Allen @ Jul 8, 2013 -> 03:36 PM) Alexei being traded is risky. The Sox don't have another SS, and the good ones aren't cheap financially or what they will cost in terms of talent to acquire. Holding onto Alexei much longer is equally risky. I'm not holding my breath about Ramirez being a totally different player again after redesigning spring training for the Sox again...although, in fairness, not resting him until this last has to be at least one of the top 2-3 factors in his defense performance. And he has improved his stolen base numbers/aggressiveness.
-
Midseason top 25?
QUOTE (Jake @ Jul 8, 2013 -> 03:23 PM) I think that Trayce Thompson is the highest ceiling player in our system and, even if not, is the current "most likely to be a star" player. It has to be between him and Hawkins. Obviously, Courtney has the most pop in his bat of anyone in the system. If you look at everything else, running/throwing/fielding....then Thompson has the edge or slight edge. And nobody can really project what batting average each would put up in the majors at the end of 2014 or 2015/16 for Hawkins. Way too early to even try extrapolating Courtney because of two completely conflicting years, some at the same level. Thompson does have more of a track record, and more "predictable" stat lines now...but there is still the idea floating around everything will just "click" one day and he'll make a huge step forward. Of course, I wouldn't say the odds of that happening are better than 50/50 at this point. Could go either way. I wouldn't with any amount of confidence at this point say he's going to be a breakout major league superstar.
-
Rios, $1M traded to Rangers
QUOTE (Dick Allen @ Jul 8, 2013 -> 03:24 PM) Ozzie and Rios are buddies. Rios had a problem with KW, and it almost got physical. Who didn't KW have a problem with, besides Buehrle, Konerko, Dye, Peavy and Thome? Then again, he probably had issues with Jake as well...trying to remember, probably about the way he became injured.
-
Midseason top 25?
QUOTE (oldsox @ Jul 8, 2013 -> 02:14 PM) I still say Hawkins should not be close to #1 ranking. That does not mean I am not pulling for him -- I am. But a #1 prospect should be a very good baseball player whereever he is playing. If he were at Kanny instead of W-S, would his numbers be as good as Micah Johnson's? I doubt it. He is struggling to hit .200 and strikes out over 50% of the time. Those facts should preclude him from that high of a ranking. He is not even close to Phegley. Do you think Hawkins could hit .316 in AAA? No. Is he as good a hitter as Ravelo or Johnson? No. And as far as Zapata goes, can't we wait for him to play a few games somewhere? If he is just 16, that means he is 4 years removed from Little League. Listing Hawkins as #1 reminds me of Joe Borchard. Almost everyone at ST thought he was #1 long after he showed be was not big league quality. If he repeats at High A next year and handles it, I'll be on his bandwagon, too. Not now. Except 16 in the Dominican is like 18 in the US, in terms of "Darwinian Theory" of the intense competition down there to get noticed, for agents/buscones to identify you as well as the MLB academies and scouting combine....I wouldn't describe him as being 4 years removed from LL because there's no such thing in the DR. You're fighting for your survival the first moment you step onto a diamond....sink or swim.
-
Midseason top 25?
QUOTE (bbilek1 @ Jul 8, 2013 -> 02:18 PM) Hawkins' offseason this year is going to be a huge. Everything he has learned this year has to be dealt with and he has to get comfortable with his mechanical changes going into '14. Which mechanical changes are those you are referring to?
-
2013 MLB Catch-All thread
Carlos Carrasco from the Indians is the arm I would go after. Another Coop project. He has all the tools, but just hasn't put it together in CLE.
-
Midseason top 25?
QUOTE (southsider2k5 @ Jul 8, 2013 -> 01:45 PM) Stritcly off of pure ceilings, I would rank Hawkins #1, and then Zapata would go no lower than after Hawk, Thompson, Anderson, and Johnson. I could see arguments for maybe Rienzo and Barnum being ahead of Zapata, but his ceiling is huge with that power. Rienzo's going great now, but how long will it last? If he does this for 6 more weeks, then it will be more impressive. Same thing with Gordon Beckham, Phegley, etc.
-
Tigers Garcia/Dirks "expendable"
QUOTE (LittleHurt05 @ Jul 8, 2013 -> 01:42 PM) Yet they trusted Papa Grande? He's always on again, off again...but yeah, they probably would have trusted a veteran more than Reed...that's how Leyland thinks (just like Ozzie in that regard). That, and how quickly they temporarily gave up on the kid (Rondon?) who was anointed the closer coming into ST and didn't even make it onto the OD roster. Definitely "win now" mode...and I wouldn't give up a lot to get Reed when there's just as good a chance Al Alburquerque straightens himself out.
-
Midseason top 25?
QUOTE (NorthSideSox72 @ Jul 8, 2013 -> 11:51 AM) Prospect evaluation cannot be SOLELY about perceived ceiling. If you have a guy in AAA who looks like a very likely solid or above average major league starting player/pitcher, and a super-toolsy guy in A ball who is struggling, I don't think it is out of hand to think the former is more valuable than the latter. I do agree that Hawkins still has an argument to be #1, but it is not nearly as cut and dried as you are making it seem. That's where rating Barnum and Walker will be difficult...Walker's playing at a level he's not quite ready for, he has some good tools (I like his balance at the plate, in particular), has been hitting better recently, but he's still in the 210's and striking out a lot and showing minimal HR power, which means he almost has to be a leadoff or #9 hitter in a major league line-up. Barnum hasn't done much, he's been injured over and over again, but he has to be somewhere between 6-10 based on sheer potential alone. Same with Zapata, if I was doing it. Zapata's somewhere in the 8-12 range, arguably. Finally, Beck and Snodgress are two more interesting guys where there are a boatload of differing opinions.
-
Tigers Garcia/Dirks "expendable"
QUOTE (southsider2k5 @ Jul 8, 2013 -> 01:36 PM) Freep Sports @freepsports 7m #Tigers' Andy Dirks, Avisail Garcia are expendable for trade, according to an ESPN analyst. http://www.freep.com/article/20130708/SPOR...-avisail-garcia … Now who would they possibly want besides Jesse Crain? I don't think they would trust Reed, to be honest. Their weaknesses are C, 2B and LF, and the bullpen. And Infante has been better this season than 2012. They don't need Keppinger, as they have Ramon Santiago for that role.
-
Rios, $1M traded to Rangers
QUOTE (Balta1701 @ Jul 8, 2013 -> 01:24 PM) Rios is close to having earned that money. The problem is the mysterious "one of the worst seasons in baseball history" in 2011 that really is a marvel in the middle of his career. If he'd been just "Bad" that season rather than "among the worst in baseball history" he'd have fully earned what the Sox have paid him. 2009 and 2011 still are sticking in everyone's "craw" as they say. That, and the lackadaisical play recently that's making it harder to trade him, not to mention the issues that he brought to the clubhouse by displacing Dye (blame that on KW, and also KW not completing the proposed Homer Bailey/Dye trade with some minor league prospects)...
-
Rios, $1M traded to Rangers
Overall, I wouldn't agree that Rios has earned all the money the Sox have paid him since 2009. It hasn't been a coup by Kenny Williams, by any means. And, going forward, it's not a contract you want on the books unless you also bring back Peavy, Danks and Ramirez, among others.
-
2013 Cubs catch all thread
Wow, I had no idea Josh Donaldson was traded by the Cubs for Harden (along with 3 other players, at the time, Gallagher being the centerpiece). Ooops. They could use a better 3B than Luis Valbuena, haha.
-
Midseason top 25?
QUOTE (NorthSideSox72 @ Jul 8, 2013 -> 08:03 AM) What makes you think Tim Anderson is "most likely ticketed for 2B/CF"? Your general impression of the list I agree with - better overall depth, but weaker on top without any elite names. The mixed results (at best) defensively so far and a preponderance of the scouting reports before and after the draft. That said, we all know that Derek Jeter made 50+ errors for Greensboro in 1993, so error totals in A ball don't matter quite so much because of the inferior fields/playing conditions/grounds crews. If he keeps this up going into AA, though, they'll have to look at a position change. Same with Micah Johnson.
-
Let's talk about Andy Wilkins
QUOTE (southsider2k5 @ Jul 8, 2013 -> 08:13 AM) I'm talking about guys already on the major league roster like Paul Konerko, Adam Dunn, and Dayan Viciedo. The other thing to take into consideration is that Ravelo missed the first 6 weeks of the season...(can't even remember what thread I'm in, lol)...going back and forth between Ravelo and Wilkins. I'm sure if Phegley gets hot, they're going to give him playing time at DH (and maybe 1B if he can play it) to keep his bat in the line-up, to make sure he doesn't wear down in July/August, and to give Dunn a break against LHPers from time to time. Assuming he keeps hitting, which we can't.