Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Soxtalk.com

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

caulfield12

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by caulfield12

  1. QUOTE (greg775 @ Jun 23, 2013 -> 08:46 PM) I don't know why we want to trade pitching. The goal is to get good again. To get good, we pretty much need to replace every one of our everyday position players. The pitching is fine. If we trade all our pitchers, we may never be good again, 15-25 years. The way to rebuild is get 3-4 position players through free agency for next season while keeping most of our pitching. If you want to trade one reliever and one starter, I guess I'm OK with that. How bout trading Crain for 2 outstanding prospects and trade Peavy if anybody wants him since he can't stay healthy. Repeat: Completely turn over our lineup; keep the pitchers. We're not the Royals quite yet. Or the Pirates, although they're having a a great season SO FAR.
  2. Hawkins finished 0/4, 1 BB, 1 R, all the way back down to .183. 2 k's. 3/41 with 24 k's now on his current stretch. Thompson all the way up to 44 RBI's.
  3. QUOTE (The Ultimate Champion @ Jun 23, 2013 -> 06:53 PM) Put it this way: if you WIN the deal IMMEDIATELY on paper AND you appear to be better off because of that deal over the length Sale's contract, then yes, you trade him. And that doesn't happen when you are dealing in prospects. If there's a team ready to pay with a bunch of Major Leaguers then sure. Not going to happen though, especially when Price & Stanton are on the market for the right amount of talent back. Both BTW should be cheaper than Sale since Sale comes at cost certainty without the FA clouds hanging over his head (Yankees, Red Sox, Dodgers, Angels, Cubs? etc.) how many teams can or would dare to outbid those guys? With those $25 million dollar checks going out to all the teams, you might be surprised how many "not traditional" powers might get involved in bidding for their own superstar.
  4. QUOTE (bighurt4life @ Jun 23, 2013 -> 05:23 PM) Buerhle, he was/is all heart, moxie, and smarts. His raw stuff has always been well below average yet he's been one of the most successful pitchers in the majors over the past 13 years Yeah, and I remember the Pirates comparing Matt Guerrier to Greg Maddux when he was acquired and gloating about how they were going to lose Marte from their 40 man roster anyway. That trade didn't exactly go their way, nor did the never-ending comparisons to Greg Maddux or Tom Glavine (any lefty that throws 87-91 MPH).
  5. QUOTE (Baron @ Jun 23, 2013 -> 04:17 PM) Oh ok so its sort of a conspiracy theory that Rick Hahn isnt actually doing what he'd paid to do....got it. I'm still waiting for ONE SIGN this season that someone's being held accountable for the results we've seen consistently on the field (or lack thereof). Can you name one? They had a team meeting and additional fielding practice once. Wow. Problem solved.
  6. That 13 minutes will be the same amount of time Chicagoans will be paying attention to the White Sox game Tuesday night with the Blackhawks Game 6 on. Maybe too generous.
  7. QUOTE (2nd_city_saint787 @ Jun 23, 2013 -> 04:08 PM) If they can pull of something ridiculous like the trade someone suggested in another thread with the Cardinals then I'd have to think about it. Getting Tavarez CF, Adams 1B/DH, and Wong 2B (Beckham moving to 3B or SS) can potentially turn around this offense and still leave you with Peavy-Danks-Q-Santiago-Johnson/Axe/FA pickup. Nothing short of 2 young, cost controlled, ready, impact bats...and then some. Except that goes against EVERYTHING the Cardinals as an organization believe in. They're not under pressure to win another World Series like, say, the Cubs. St. Louis is definitely not in a position of desperation.
  8. QUOTE (thxfrthmmrs @ Jun 23, 2013 -> 04:03 PM) He won't be. But if the Cardinals come calling for someone to fill in for Jaime Garcia, and is willing to offer Taveras, Kolten Wong and two pitching prospects for Sale and maybe Alexei, I would have a hard time saying no. This would be a similar deal to the Rays/Royals trade this off season. Except the Rays only gave up Shields for 2 seasons. It's more like Edwin Jackson/Hudson-Holmberg (the Shields deal). Jackson has always been talented, but he's never been a pitcher you built your entire organization and future around, either.
  9. QUOTE (The Ultimate Champion @ Jun 23, 2013 -> 03:57 PM) Garcia is 22 & MLB ready. He's putting up numbers that, you are right, are not really "good" right now (.286/.328/.378 in 128 career MLB PA). But the only question on him really is the power, and if he finds that, you are talking about trading a closer for a potential all-star and our future RF. If Garcia was putting up power numbers he wouldn't be available at all, to anyone, outside of maybe a Stanton/Price deal or something of that order. To get a player who is already through the MiLB process with a very high ceiling and 6 years control, and seemingly with a pretty good floor as well, for a closer without extraordinary stuff? That's about as low-risk as it gets when it comes to big, potentially future-altering deals. It's much easier to "win" a closer deal than say a Peavy deal. I mean, if you think you can get a better player for Reed than that then great, I just don't think you can. And Castallenos, okay sure, but how realistic is it to expect a team's top prospect at the absolute height of his value for ANY of our players? See: Olt, Mike on this forum, as far as how a guy can go from "would you trade Sale for him?" to "I'd take him for Crain" in a few months time. Why is it even smart to buy unproven players at such a high price, even if you can? And that said, the Tigers may very well laugh us off the phone if we proposed Reed for Garcia. I'm just saying, MLB-ready position player who is young & has a very high ceiling is the type of player that you target if you're offering Reed, and if you get it offered to you, the deal should be done. They wouldn't laugh, but they're not quite ready to do it, either. OTOH, they acquired Torii Hunter to WIN NOW. Giving Garcia a chance to learn at the major league level wasn't the highest priority in that decision-making process (not unlike the same problems we had giving prospects time when every game/season we were playing for the playoffs, theoretically). And I don't think anyone expected Dirks to be quite so solid within their front office. Plus, Leyland absolutely loves Don Kelly, his favorite scrappy player now that Inge is gone. Not to mention Victor Martinez also blocks him getting a chance to hit at another spot in the line-up (granted, I would DH Hunter and put Garcia in RF most of the time).
  10. QUOTE (The Ultimate Champion @ Jun 23, 2013 -> 03:15 PM) This. We really know nothing. We don't have access to all these pro scouts, front office execs, etc. We had stats, little blurbs, second & third-hand old info, write-ups by people who never even watched the player, sometimes little snippets of video. But if you are in discussions with a team that needs a closer badly, and they offer say a SP prospect in AA who Don Cooper just LOVES, or a position player also very close who the organization is extremely high on & believes (regardless of what is out there in print) is a potential star & is going to see action this year, then you make that deal. You have to trust your personnel. You can't run an organization without risk. If Hahn, KW, Buddy Bell, Laumann, etc. all sign off on a prospect & all believe in that player then you have to have the balls to make that move. Even if it is the Tigers. In fact, I'd kind of like to see the competitive attitude & ballsiness that it would take to potentially hand the Tigers a WS in exchange for a better shot at beating them a couple years down the road. Like, we'll give you this help now, but 2 years & you're f***ed, we're coming for you. I'd like that. Of course, I'm not sure trading Delmon Young to the Tigers (helping them greatly) ended up making the Tigers feel the TWINS were "coming for them" exactly. It's got to be a prospect that's going to cost them a pretty price who goes on to become an All-Star. Like John Smoltz for Doyle Alexander. The kind of trade people in DET will be talking about 20-30 years later.
  11. QUOTE (Jordan4life @ Jun 21, 2013 -> 09:52 PM) Far as statistical and overall on-court (LeBron will never be as loved/popular) impact? Better? I wouldn't say that. Just as good? Definitely. If you want to break it up some and compare their individual skill-sets, etc, I see it like this: Getting to the rim and finishing: LeBron NOPE Ball-handling: Tie Post-game: MJ Mid-range: MJ Long-range: Tie (and I'm being generous here. Three of Michael's four best seasons from deep came when the 3-point line was moved in. Another year or two like '13 from LeBron, and he's got the edge) Rebounding: LeBron Passing: LeBron Defense: LeBron (his freakish size and versatility or the ability to guard every position on the floor well trumps Michael's insane on-ball defense) These are the things that you can either use stats or simply your eyes (though I'm sure some will disagree). I look at Kobe and the level he was playing at before his injury at age 34 and then think about LeBron, who's bigger, stronger, more athletic and injury-proof, and it's easy to project that he could very well still be the best player in the game at 34-35 if he plays until then (much like MJ). Another thing is that Jordan would absolutely hit clutch free throws at the end of games. LeBron can get jittery. Jordan would find the weakness in other teams psychologically and just exploit it...over and over again, offensively AND defensively. There's no way I'm going to agree that James plays better defense having watched most of his games from the time he was a freshman at North Carolina until the day he retired. No way. James still disappears at times in games....for large stretches, as well. And he defers to other teammates when he loses confidence. Or he tries to do it all himself and almost buried the Heat in Game 6 singlehandedly down the stretch trying to bull his way into the lane while out of control and frustrated. With Jordan, you never doubted him or believed that he wouldn't come through. You can't say that about James.
  12. QUOTE (JoshPR @ Jun 23, 2013 -> 03:44 PM) Alan Bannister for all I care.... Please don't bring up Jerry Dybzinski, lol.
  13. QUOTE (winninguglyin83 @ Jun 23, 2013 -> 03:42 PM) I believe Ramirez has played every inning at SS this season. I'm sure they'd love to dump him. I'm not sure who would take him. And who plays SS when he's gone -- Keppinger, Beckham, Sanchez, Morel??? No good option. It's time for a change. No doubt. But who do they change to? They're going to have to acquire a stopgap at the deadline or go to someone like Tyler Greene. Sanchez isn't close to being ready. Keppinger would be a disaster. If Beckham wasn't hitting so well, I'd consider trying him there, but don't want to mess with him. Morel, no way in Hades.
  14. QUOTE (elrockinMT @ Jun 23, 2013 -> 03:42 PM) I am not excusing Ramirez and his errors but it looked like to me that Jesse was having so hard of a time and threw a lot of pitches that Ramirez was back on his heels and not ready Thanks, Mr. Rongey. Just kidding, but that just about sounds like what he'd come up with. Or the fact that Ramirez has played every inning of every game so far this season and is wearing down physically.
  15. Anderson's at least not being overwhelmed out of the gate. That's a huge positive.
  16. NO. (Unless we want to rename ourselves the Florida White Marlins and merge with Loria's team in South Florida).
  17. QUOTE (Baron @ Jun 23, 2013 -> 03:34 PM) Why is it Jerry's problem when he's hired people to run this baseball team? He's the CEO, essentially. The buck stops with him, not Hahn. Hahn's seemingly just a puppet unless he proves otherwise. Someone has to step up and lead this team out of the quicksand.
  18. QUOTE (Noonskadoodle @ Jun 23, 2013 -> 03:33 PM) Exciting/Interesting/Compelling??? Why cause Puig? They still can't win with him. I don't care. At least he's fun to watch. That's more than I can say for anyone on the White Sox other than Sale and Crain. That doesn't mean I won't follow the Sox, but will just decide the only way not to go insane is to follow the minor league results more closely and hope/pray for major changes in the next 6 weeks.
  19. Jerry Reinsdorf, are you ignoring all the games this season like the rest of your fanbase? Because that's the only fathomable reason why nothing has been done about this train wreck of a season.
  20. QUOTE (JoshPR @ Jun 23, 2013 -> 03:30 PM) I meant here on the board. But yeah rongey might blame the ground Not, because that would implicitly mean he's taking a shot at the turf god Roger Bossard.
  21. QUOTE (Noonskadoodle @ Jun 23, 2013 -> 03:30 PM) Dont you have the Dodgers to go watch? At least they're exciting/interesting/compelling. Ed Farmer was coughing so much he had to leave so DJ's doing the whole game by himself, lol.
  22. QUOTE (Chet Kincaid @ Jun 23, 2013 -> 03:29 PM) His last name starts with an R and ends with "ongey". I think I'm going to call into the post-game and try to get Rongey to go ballistic and get fired.
  23. QUOTE (Buehrle>Wood @ Jun 23, 2013 -> 03:28 PM) They did rule it earned. Im not sure that makes sense given the error. Not giving up a run regardless, unearned or earned. Still scored upon, so the streak is OVAH.
  24. 12 errors....on the way to Jose Valentin territory, yay!
  25. Goodbye, Alexei. It was nice to know you. Just drop a nuclear bomb at 35th and Shields. But please make sure that Chris Sales' not there. None of those runs were earned. The scorekeeper changed the ruling on the Lough bunt. TYPICAL.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.