Everything posted by caulfield12
-
Winter Meetings Catch-all
OBE. Overcome by events.
-
White Sox asking for "top prospects" for Robert
Melky Cabrera as well...
-
When the f*** are we getting a new banner?
Now you made me think of poor Colas claiming he was on a plantation lol.
-
Crochet Traded to Boston
Poor Corey Lee...he actually looked legit for most of the first half.
-
Tucker to Cubs
Not without George Steinbrenner running things...
-
When the f*** are we getting a new banner?
https://sports.yahoo.com/white-sox-installed-former-navy-182907610.html How can you leave out Mahler?
-
State of the farm system
I meant coming off his Mets' deal with an injury rehab. Brandon Woodruff and Hays might be better examples. HaSeong Kim. Questionable (at best) character guys like Clevinger/Bauer, etc. B/C/D free agent guys just haven't worked. At all.
-
State of the farm system
Hahn wasn't even allowed to name his own manager...but is now slowly being made to look almost like a sympathetic Shakespearean character and not a major villain lol.
-
State of the farm system
Who could the White Sox possibly sign to 1-3 year deals except overpays...vets on their last contracts or rehabbing guys like a Hays or Conforto that will bolt at the very chance to escape?
-
Tucker to Cubs
In the same way the risk with a Bellinger extension was too high...the cost for Tucker will be in the stratosphere with a 6-8 fWAR season. Cardinals are already retrenching from Goldschmidt/Arenado years. The opportunity is certainly there for Cincy or the Cubs with their farm, but Milwaukee starts out the clear favorite until someone unseats them.
-
Tucker to Cubs
Fine...if they can sell really high on Cease, like the Astros just did with Tucker. Otherwise, you're a team with six $100+ million contracts in Darvish (through 28), Machado, Tatis, Cronenworth, Bogaerts, Musgrove (TJS and signed through 27) going nowhere fast. Merrill might also be looking at an extension. If you're trading Cease, then why hold on to Michael King as well with limited control? If you don't intend to compete with the LAD and no longer worry about keeping your job (Preller) and keeping your sellouts...trade both those pitchers and put Darvish on the market as well if anyone will bite, because past trades and lack minors depth mean you now have to completely rebuild that rotation from scratch. In that sense, Sasaki to SD makes as much sense as anywhere not NY/LA/SF/Boston/Tor, along with Seattle and the Cubs.
-
Crochet Traded to Boston
Onion??? Why does Getz look eerily like Jack Nicholson?
-
State of the farm system
This guy simply has to be related to either Getz or Brooks Boyer…he’s also forgetting we will be missing at least two (if not three) Top 1-3 draft picks because of the Jerry Reinsdorf “Sox are a large market club without acting like one draft rule.”
-
State of the farm system
486 [Karoll] Just a reminder of the White Sox Draft and Development History, here is every White Sox hitter over the last 30+ years that the team drafted who became an All-Star with the team: Tim Anderson, Joe Crede, Ray Durham, Frank Thomas. That’s it. For 3 decades. That’s a bit misleading because you also have Ventura, McDowell, Alex Fernandez, Buehrle, Sale, Rodon, but almost all the success on the pitching side. Mike Cameron, but once again, nobody close to recent vintage. Beckham and Borchard disappointments really stand out. Zack Collins lol. Vaguely remember when Call and Fisher and Walker, more “refined” college picks were going to revolutionize the system.
-
The 'no-trade' white sox scenario
I’m putting Robert down for at least 3 fWAR and Tatis for 4.5…closer to norms. Bullpen you only have Daniel Hudson, Bummer, Ian Hamilton, Foster off the top of my head. It’s basically Grandal Keuchel Steak and Potatoes Hendriks Kimbrel vet relievers like Kelly/Graveman Benintendi…
-
Crochet Traded to Boston
Leasure was the name everyone was pointing at going into last spring and he barely survived the season. You've got Varland Ellard Wilson Iriarte Bush Nastrini Berroa Leasure again...and a whole lot less veteran depth.
-
State of the farm system
Just look at how the Guardians covered the losses of Bieber and McKenzie internally in 2024. Heck, just look at their Top 8-9 for innings pitched in 2023 and the only name you will see in common is Tanner Bibee.
-
State of the farm system
But it still doesn't come close to where they stood in 2019. Basically double the number of starting pitching prospects with Cease Gio Kopech Lopez Dunning ... Moncada Jimenez Robert Vaughn Madrigal Burger etc. Right now you still have just four legit position prospects and Wolkow's potential/high bust rate.
-
State of the farm system
See Sox 2B prospects since the Marcus Semien trade. Romy Gonzalez had a better season offensively than any White Sox hitter but is basically a 1B DH PH. Baldwin Meidroth Sosa will battle it out at second. Vargas Montgomery Ramos at third.
-
State of the farm system
It's kind of the same with Crochet...dealing one of the best young LHPers in the game, only to (hopefully) replace him with Schultz and Smith.
-
State of the farm system
Especially with Zavala struggling so badly in 2024.
-
State of the farm system
16. Schultz 25. Teel 30. Smith 37. Colson Montgomery 54. Braden Montgomery 59. Quero Ramos and Inciarte are considered to be outside the Top 100...100% Ramos has fallen off. Thorpe/Iriarte/Grant Taylor the closest to Top 100, Thorpe was previously listed with NY/SD but fell out and/or is ineligible due to big league innings. He would be on the back end anyway. Grant Taylor seems to have the most upside after the Big 2 if he can actually stay healthy. source: mlb pipeline
-
Crochet Traded to Boston
Baez arm and Soler numbers hitting-wise, but I still think he would be hard pressed to come anywhere near Javy's first 5-6 years with the Cubs... So I've changed to a more athletic Hunter Renfroe but certainly not a burner out there.
-
When the f*** are we getting a new banner?
ASCHE...otherwise, you'll get a relative of Arthur.
-
Crochet Traded to Boston
If we get the combination of Soler/Javier Baez career-wise, we're going to be QUITE fortunate.