Chicago White Sox

I don’t see ace upside with Giolito, but maybe a quality #3 starter with a few more ticks and more consistent command.

Moncada probaly has top 5 tools in all of baseball and a great eye, so plenty of reason to be optimistic with him despite struggling some as a 23 year old.

Especially when Harper struggles to stay healthy and Machado has a history of knee problems.

What in the world are you talking about?

I don’t disagree, but Cooper at least has a track record of success. I do worry the game may be passing him by a bit.

I find it crazy that Steverson & Sparks are both still here given the struggles of most of our young hitters.

Thanks for sharing...did not know that about Mitchell.

Which rebuilds are you referring to? Make sure not to include the Cubs.

The chances Harper passes on signicant money is slim to none IMO. He wants a record breaking contract.

If they miss on these two guys, it puts the rebuild in a really tough spot. I’ll maintain optimism until that actually happens though, because I have to believe the front office sees it the same way and will act accordingly with their bids.

My take on the situation is the Sox & Phillies have both made offers much bigger than the Yankees and Team Machado is giving New York a couple weeks to raise their bid before settling on one of the other two teams.

We haven’t whiffed on either yet. And I still don’t get why everyone is suddenly so negative on Machado.

Kluber + Pollock is a better use of resources than Harper (for them) and could be had for probably less total dollars. I do think they’ll go back and make an offer for Harper first, but I think it will be of the 4 or 5 year variety and I can’t see Bryce accepting that.

Jared Mitchell was a speed based player and a poor comparison. Burger’s injury may prevent him from sticking at 3B but he still has the ability to potentially hit enough for 1B or DH. Way too early to write him off.

Not that I believe this is realistic at all, but figured I’d post this while everyone is already down about Harper.

A “husky” guy with huge question marks about being able to stick at 3B and just ruptured his Achilles twice is probably not an apt comparison. And yes, I’d be pissed if we traded him in this type of deal.

We’re on the same page fathom, I’m gusssing they trade Verdugo+ for Kluber or Realmuto and then turn around and sign Pollack for a fraction of the cost of Harper. That’s a way better use of their financial resources IMO.

They just traded a 2017 1st rounder for a bunch of rentals. Our fanbase would be livid if we did something like that and rightfully so.

He did seem to hint at that, but then kept playing along with it afterwards.

And for only one year.

All signs suggest the Yankees do not want to enter a bidding war and we have as much money to throw at Machado as the Phillies. Doesn’t mean we’ll do it, but there’s zero reason to lose hope right now.

Is Bryce that guy though? I want him more than anything, but a huge part of that is what his marketability brings to our franchise potentially. The Dodgers wouldn’t reap those same benefits.

Berlinger, Taylor, & Pederson combined for 9.4 fWAR (3.1 each) last year. Harper had 3.5. I think Bryce is a better player than that, but is he worth $40M+ in the short-term for what might end being only a moderate upgrade. I just can’t see Friedman doing that, but I know I’m in the minority on this one.

Yup, the Phillies are the bigger threat without question IMO.

? How does Harper going off the board affect the Yankees?