Chicago White Sox

In the minors…you are saying they should have starting working him at 3B more frequently before we was called up.

Good at-bat even if the outcome wasn’t there

An early HR and some late innings hug watch would be swell

Woof

Martin actually K’ing some guys is all I want to see from him. A K per 9 rate below 6.00 is not going to cut it in the long run.

I think he’s far more likely to be part of an offseason trade, but probably needs to have a good August & September to improve his value.

The player being discussed is a slow, RH hitting 1B / DH who is currently posting -0.4 fWAR and currently has a lower xwOBA than the player you just called the “worst hitter in the sport over the past 2 calendar year”.

Why is this such a big deal?

I just addressed this in my last post.

Trying to get Sosa at-bats is probably a part of it, but don’t think Rojas has anything to do with it. Also, Colson could be an elite defensive 3B. And this isn’t intended to be a dig, but they also like Meidroth at SS much more than you do. Chase got high praise from his AAA teammates for his defense at SS last year. His value is way higher if he can stick at SS than forced to be a 2B. Right or wrong, I think that is a real factor here. Before the Crochet trade, there wasn’t really a threat for SS.

His ability to stick at SS was questioned, not his long term ability to play 3B. They gave him pretty much every opportunity to get better at SS. 3B has always been the backup plan and one that shouldn’t have required an overly difficult transition. We also have no idea whatsoever on if he got reps at 3B during practice, both in the minors and at the major league level. They could have easily been working on this behinds the scenes. There is plenty of stuff rip the Sox on, but asking a guy to slide over from SS to 3B is super low on my areas of concern right now.

These overreactions to a bad defensive game are crazy to me. We are rebuilding, not trying to make the last wild card spot. Unfortunately, young players are going to do dumb stuff and make mistakes. Such is part of the learning process. You don’t cut bait early on or change your plan because they have some defensive struggles in year 1. I also don’t think Colson splitting time at 3B in the majors is a sign of incompetence from a player development standpoint. If you feel that he should get the reps at SS over Meidroth, I am very much open to having that debate. But I think playing some 3B after years of playing SS is not an egregious ask. Yes, there are some differences, but this isn’t like when we threw Andrew Vaughn in the OF with zero experience. IMO, the shift should have almost zero bearing on the development of the rest of his game. As for Teel, it’s simply the “can’t play a catcher in a day game after catching a night game” BS. That being said, let’s not pretend this isn’t something every Sox manger has done in our lifetimes and many managers from other orgs do. The real issue is refusing to play Quero and Teel in the same game because of the “we can’t risk losing our DH in event of injury” BS. And even there, I’m willing to wait and see what happens post trade deadline. If Getz refuses to have them both play after the OF glut has been dealt with, then I will rip these guys to shreds for having such a dumb plan.

I am not a fan of trading for Vientos and would prefer actual prospects, but come on, there are a lot of worse outcomes possible than getting him.

I get you can’t force a specific type of return, but I have no idea what Getz’s plan is for the OF. At some point we got to find a way to add some young OFs. I am not concerned about the infield if I’m being sincere…lots of options even if Meidroth, Colson, etc, don’t end up being core guys. The OF is a wasteland outside of Braden (cross fingers) right now. Just frustrating here because the Mets have several OF prospects at tier that should be around these same guys mentioned above.

I mentioned it earlier, but his power last year was exaggerated by a 92 percentile barrel rate. Can he replicate that again? If not, I’m just not sure what’s so exciting about his profile.

I don’t think Vientos is a “bad return” per se if you believe he’s just having a bad season and there is a good chance he mostly returns to form. I just worry that 2024 was an outlier for him and that he ends up being a below average 1B.

Good. Would love to see one early trade.

If Tim Elko could play the OF he’d be a far more interesting dart throw

You talking about Vientos?

To be fair, Tray is very much pro Judaism and Chicago style hot dogs, he just hates Justin Ishbia, private equity, and the thought of a ballpark at the 78 site. And unfortunately his takes on the latter three subjects quickly become delusional and he starts hurling insults at those who refuse to accept his false realities.

I really hope so. And damn do I want Clifford in a Robert trade.

This helps in multiple ways so glad to see it.

He feels like a guy who will be part of the major league mix fairly early into next year.

These can’t be serious posts. One, he is not the controlling owner yet. Second, does his ownership stake increase if he infuses more capital into the org? Third, what we would even spend on during the middle of the season? Fourth, do you have any idea how private equity even works?