June 4, 20187 yr Is there not a thread on him? Every time he hits 1-2 XBH in a game I keep asking myself "Who is this guy and when is he going to come back down to earth?" A few days later, I see another couple of XBH. Is he having a Alejandro De Aza type of "mirage" partial season, or is there a chance he is the real deal? BABIP doesn't look outrageous, his K/BB leaves a lot to be desired but I just don't know what to make of the guy and don't see a lot on him.
June 4, 20187 yr If he could play even a high school level OF, there would be a lot of excitement about him. The problem is he is probably the worst OF I have seen in my lifetime, at least since Ivan Calderon.
June 4, 20187 yr http://www.soxtalk.com/forums/index.php?/topic/105260-could-palka-be-the-white-sox-schwarber/&tab=comments#comment-3618826
June 4, 20187 yr He's clearly a DH. But he had enough success in the minors to think his bat isn't a fluke.
June 4, 20187 yr Author 3 minutes ago, Kyyle23 said: http://www.soxtalk.com/forums/index.php?/topic/105260-could-palka-be-the-white-sox-schwarber/&tab=comments#comment-3618826 Ah, I didn't go back enough pages.
June 4, 20187 yr Just now, Greg Hibbard said: Ah, I didn't go back enough pages. it was buried. Schwarber-lite comp isnt so bad now lol
June 4, 20187 yr 2 minutes ago, southsider2k5 said: If he could play even a high school level OF, there would be a lot of excitement about him. The problem is he is probably the worst OF I have seen in my lifetime, at least since Ivan Calderon. He has no big league future unless he picks up a 1B mitt and can play it at least as well as Adam Dunn, which is bad, but tolerable if he can produce a 125 wRC+ or thereabouts.
June 4, 20187 yr https://baseballsavant.mlb.com/savant-player/daniel-palka-594953?stats=statcast-r-hitting-mlb He hits the ball hard. https://baseballsavant.mlb.com/statcast_leaderboard?year=2018&abs=50&player_type=resp_batter_id His Average Exit Velo is eighth. Barrels per PA? Eighth. Sprint Speed? NOT EIGHTH (313). He's basically a slightly faster catcher. I'm in favor of letting him run this hot streak out as DH.
June 4, 20187 yr His xOBA is .395 so he's actually been underperforming his exit velo numbers. It's really too bad that all his other tools are so awful.
June 4, 20187 yr 2 minutes ago, Greg Hibbard said: How does a guy with wheels this slow have three triples in 30 AB? ? They were actually HR that the league mandated into triples because of pace of pace rules.
June 4, 20187 yr 1 hour ago, chitownsportsfan said: He has no big league future unless he picks up a 1B mitt and can play it at least as well as Adam Dunn, which is bad, but tolerable if he can produce a 125 wRC+ or thereabouts. For his own career, he should be in the OF practicing at every single chance he gets. Batting practice, fungos, etc. If he can make himself into even a serviceable OF, he has a long career ahead of him.
June 4, 20187 yr 4 minutes ago, southsider2k5 said: For his own career, he should be in the OF practicing at every single chance he gets. Batting practice, fungos, etc. If he can make himself into even a serviceable OF, he has a long career ahead of him. I don't think he has any of the instinct needed to play the OF. As you mentioned he's possibly the worst OF to ever start a MLB game. I'm not sure how many reps with fungoes can help now. Presumably he's been taking a lot of fungoes in his pro career. Try him at 1B, he can't possibly be worse than the OF, can he?
June 4, 20187 yr 8 minutes ago, chitownsportsfan said: I don't think he has any of the instinct needed to play the OF. As you mentioned he's possibly the worst OF to ever start a MLB game. I'm not sure how many reps with fungoes can help now. Presumably he's been taking a lot of fungoes in his pro career. Try him at 1B, he can't possibly be worse than the OF, can he? I mean you are probably right, but I can't speak to the kids worth ethic or training programs either. If it were me, knowing the difference in demand between a 1b/DH type and a RF/LF type, I would be spending every waking second in the OF trying to make a name there if I were Palka. Odds are extremely high that you are 100% right and he will always suck there.
June 4, 20187 yr 3 hours ago, chitownsportsfan said: He has no big league future unless he picks up a 1B mitt and can play it at least as well as Adam Dunn, which is bad, but tolerable if he can produce a 125 wRC+ or thereabouts. If he's a 120-130 wRC+ bat, he'll have a ML future as a DH, especially since he's a left handed hitter.
June 4, 20187 yr Keep running him out there everyday in 2018 and see what you have at the end of the season.
June 4, 20187 yr 2 hours ago, chitownsportsfan said: I don't think he has any of the instinct needed to play the OF. As you mentioned he's possibly the worst OF to ever start a MLB game. I'm not sure how many reps with fungoes can help now. Presumably he's been taking a lot of fungoes in his pro career. Try him at 1B, he can't possibly be worse than the OF, can he? Yes he can. If he can't pick up throws in the dirt, he will kill the pitching staff.
June 4, 20187 yr I remember when the White Sox had Carlos Lee. He was bad in the outfield. During one off season he worked like a mad man improving his defensive skills. I'm hoping Palka does the same thing this off season. He looks like he could have a good career hitting with the White Sox.
June 4, 20187 yr 7 minutes ago, WBWSF said: I remember when the White Sox had Carlos Lee. He was bad in the outfield. During one off season he worked like a mad man improving his defensive skills. I'm hoping Palka does the same thing this off season. He looks like he could have a good career hitting with the White Sox. I saw a lot of Carlos Lee, and he was no where near this bad. One more name actually comes to mind. 1986 Carlton Fisk in LF.
June 4, 20187 yr 6 minutes ago, southsider2k5 said: I saw a lot of Carlos Lee, and he was no where near this bad. One more name actually comes to mind. 1986 Carlton Fisk in LF. I also remember a very good player who was sent to LF for a game or three, and stunk up the joint. Todd Helton in his rookie year.
June 4, 20187 yr 2 hours ago, Sleepy Harold said: It’s not unfathomable if he has had 100 of them hit his way. He has a lot of catching up. Another one where the eye test matches all the numbers. Usually that only happens if you are elite, or elitely, if that is a word, awful. Edited June 4, 20187 yr by Dick Allen
June 4, 20187 yr 36 minutes ago, bmags said: Ha, thanks for finding this. I saw it and it made me chuckle, then saw this thread and knew it needed to be shared. I knew Palka looked brutal out there, but seeing that just affirmed my eye-test for me.
June 4, 20187 yr I want to wait and see on a Palka love fest. Granted he has looked pretty good with the lumber in limited time in the bigs. But, remember everyone was ga-ga over Delmonico in his debut late last year. Haven’t seen a lot this season but it would be great if they both broke out Edited June 4, 20187 yr by elrockinMT
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.