In the left corner, standing 6'6" and weighing in at 285 pounds, Adam Dunn!

 

In the right corner, standing 5'11" and weighing in at 185 pounds, Brent Lillibridge!

 

The question is simple, who finishes with more homers?

 

Brent Lillibridge: 9 homers in 138 ABs.

Adam Dunn: 11 homers in 334 ABs.

 

What does Soxtalk think?

I have to believe it's Adam Dunn, based on history and that he will get significantly more chances to.

C. Katherine Heigl

 

/rim shot

I have to believe it's Adam Dunn, based on history and that he will get significantly more chances to.

 

I just want to say that I fully endorse naming the good version of Lillibridge "Lillibomb." We can refer to both players similar to CQ vs. TCQ and JP vs. JFP.

Edited August 10, 201114 yr by Eminor3rd

C. Katherine Heigl

 

/rim shot

 

:lolhitting :lolhitting

C. Katherine Heigl

 

/rim shot

 

Nicely played sir!

C. Katherine Heigl

 

/rim shot

 

I don't get it.....

I like the "Done" spelling in the thread title, and am surprised it hasn't been seen more around here.

 

With that said, I'll say Dunn. By a narrow margin.

I don't get it.....

 

Its either a reference to her bad movies or her boobs.

KITTLEBRIDGE IF THEY UNLEASH HIS FURY

 

Well, Dunn figures to hit about 15.

Can Lillibomb catch him? Doubtful.

 

p.s. The only way we can win this division is if Oz/KW keep batting Dunn seventh. Fourth is a killer to our lineup. A total killer.

Dunn: 18 HRs

Lillibridge: 12 HRs

 

If Lillibridge were to get as many chances as Dunn, it might be a different story.

Dunn: 18 HRs

Lillibridge: 12 HRs

 

If Lillibridge were to get as many chances as Dunn, it might be a different story.

That's what I was thinking. Lillibridge won't get as many ABs, but you never know. I voted for him anyways.

Another one would be the race for most homers between Alexei, Beckham, Lillibridge and Rios.

No Vote here. Just a good question

The Sox have always tried to get Lillibridge to be a slap hitter. I think they finally unleashed him. Let him hit his natural way. I wonder how many he would have if had as many ab's as Done.

The Sox have always tried to get Lillibridge to be a slap hitter. I think they finally unleashed him. Let him hit his natural way. I wonder how many he would have if had as many ab's as Done.

I dunno about that. Lillibridge has always had a long looking swing, this year a lot of the HR's he's hit have been on short and lightning quick strokes.

I dunno about that. Lillibridge has always had a long looking swing, this year a lot of the HR's he's hit have been on short and lightning quick strokes.

I believe Dunn is 6'6" but over 285 by more than 20# Lillibridge is probably not 5'11" and might be lighter than 185. I voted for Lilibridge but doubt he'll get as enough plate appearances. I believe the second coming of Dave Kingman will get mor ABs.

Somebody should ask Lilly in the media if he tries to hit a home run every at bat.

It sure looks like that is his approach to me.

 

He is a puzzling little fella.

I dunno about that. Lillibridge has always had a long looking swing, this year a lot of the HR's he's hit have been on short and lightning quick strokes.

 

 

I think Greg Walker worked with Lilli and it wasn't about being a slap hitter. I think you are right it was about his swing being shorter. Hit the ball good and it goes aways doesn't it?

Almost more amazing than the HR comparison is this one

 

RBI- Dunn 39, Pierre 30

Imagine the reactions if this question was posed in March.

Almost more amazing than the HR comparison is this one

 

RBI- Dunn 39, Pierre 30

 

Almost more amazing than the HR comparison is this one

 

RBI- Dunn 39, Pierre 30

 

Wow, that is so freaking sad.