Look at Ray Ray Run

He's fat albers from a few years back where he went two months without allowing a base runner and then was released a month later because he's actually bad and couldnt get anyone out without luck.

Lopez needs to find more consistent swings and misses. His out pitches and swing and miss pitches are so inconsistent.

Bummer is a + MLB reliever now. Marshall is trash.

Huh? Can you explain to me why A is better than B?

Relievers with 40 elite innings of production and 200 of shit do not have a lot of value regardless of their current WAR and etc. If you think Tommy Kahnle, with one half of MLB success, is more valuable than a career performer out of the bullpen I think youd be mistaken but I could be wrong and the yankees could have believed in the new kahnle.

I'm not sure what you mean... Inside Edge, Chetu, driveline, and Trumedia. Are some data driven tools that are more intuitive, educational and better predictors when applied correctly. Obviously a lot of those tools require data driven backgrounds to apply it, which is why Keith is publically available and respected. There are many more beyond what I listed but that proprietary information/software is available to you at a cost and is certainly better and more reliable (when applied properly) than Keith Law. Obviously most people dont have the education or background to use/apply those tools which is fine. Adding: SMT as my buddy swears by them but I have never seen or used the software.

Robertson was good but he wasn't worth a penny more than his salary so it's not as if he had surplus value that warranted a good prospect. Kahnle had been good for like 8 months and he was a reliever with control issues. Frazier was similar to robertson but even worse because he was worth a little less than his production. People really exaggerate the value of Kahnle and the guys in that deal.

Law is probably making a lot of money at ESPN; he would need a top tier position at an MLB team to not take a step back in salary. I respect Law, but I think you give him far too much credit. What has he originated from a talent evaluation standpoint?

Really? I like Law, but he wouldn't be in my top 100 in regards to what you are citing. He's not an originator in this world; he's an applier and an evaulator and that is fine... but I trust plenty of people/numbers more than Keith Law. For a publicly accessible, "free," resource I'd say he is in the top 5ish but for readily available tools at your disposal if you're willing to pay, he doesn't even compare.

Hes 26 years old. Sometimes, as guys get more reps they improve. Could he be a 120 guy? Surely he could be, since he's been it for half a season of play in his most recent half season. There is nothing that screams lucky about his outcomes so far either. My fault if I misred your point.

Lol if abrams is ever 1/2 the player tim anderson is I'll eat my shoe for you caufield. I love how he'll struggle to do something the rest of his career that he's comfortably doing this year. It was just a matter of time until the Tim haters started to come out.

He was near it but he absolutely was not vocal. He's moved around a lot so I definitely give him a pass but that was on Yoan. If I'm running down a ball in the left centerfield gap with runners on base, my left fielder is yelling a base for when I come up with the ball. Either cut, 3 or 2. I'm not finding the ball and then finding the runners. That takes too much time. If the play is not in front of you, your teammates should be guiding you.

Thinking anderson should have seen that third was the play there is an interesting take. This one is on Yoan - he needs to be yelling 3 there. That ball was hit deep enough in the hole that anderson cant be taking his eye off the ball to check third and he did not have any time to check it before the play to one. Yoan needs to be aggressive and loud there as he is Timmy's eyes on that play because tim had to focus on the ball.. since that's kinda important and all.

Sir said theres no chance he hits 300 in his career.... yoan better slow down a little.

Well if we're going to start citing 12 game samples that are capped off with ASG MVP's then we should probably stop assessing a prospect. The bulk of his work is certainly more important than the 12 game sample you are pointing too.

So he's every young batter alive?

Just to clarify. The sox were never "close" to moving there. It was never anything more than a bargaining chip. It's amazing how many took that threat seriously.

You're talking like a 12 game sample.

Why shouldn't Robert be up? I really don't understand the Robert logic... Robert is young for his level and has been dominant all year. He's a freak of nature with MLB talent right now, and he needs to learn and adjust at the MLB level. AAA really does Robert no good because the hitting environment is so pro-offense. He'll strike out a lot early in his MLB career, but the guy is ready and would compete at a very high level in the big leagues. Robert has less than 600 professional at-bats so I understand wanting to see a bit more but the fact that he ONLY has 500 professional AB's and he's this damn good is more supporting evidence that he should be up and not the other way around. He's already made fast adjustments to pitchers. Robert, right now, would be our best center fielder.

Cordell at least is a good defensive outfielder. Tilson blows as does palka.

Detwiler will be the starter called up

Rick deserves flack for his shortcomings undoubtedly - the draft still hasnt shown anything for him yet and his FA signings have not been great. But... let's talk about Rick's trades and the risks he took trusting his team with the talent they still saw. Eloy Jimenez and Dylan Cease for Quintana. Could he have possibly gotten a better package? If Eloy continues to grow and Cease is even a back end guy this is a steal assuming Eloy is the player he has shown he can be. I'd say no. Eloy a franchise offensive talent and cease just needs to be good enough to start for this to be a huge win. The Chris Sale trade will never be lopsided. Sale is too good for that but if he netted a 4-5+ WAR 3rd baseman for 6 years and a 3 starter (which is conservative) with a 2-3 WAR in Kopech then both sides win and Hahn looks sharp for him moving that talent into his window. The Adam Eaton trade. This could be an all-timer. If Lopez finds consistency or dunning bounces back, adding onto the fact that giolito alone would more than enough, this turns into an all time trade win. Giolito was trending downward but the arm talent was there. The Sox love the term arm talent in their organization. They maximized this one and now need to find that potion with reynaldo We can hate on Hahn and we can claim he had great assets but plenty of guys have traded away great assets for nothing. It looks like Hahn has traded his assets for the exact right pieces. Kudos. Go Sox.

Thru and thru. Some great tweets in his past.

Just in case people forget. 22/23 year old kids can be inconsistent and should be judged more so on their best showings when they outweigh the bad ones. He should be having and working through his remaining struggles at the big league level.

First time through. Scouting report shows heavy change. Mix up the report first time through and show them something else, mix in change lightly 2nd time through and then change/fb heavy 3rd time through after you changed their thought process with sliders and fastballs early.